Book of Heroes

Clean up guild chat

Someone needs to clean up some guild chats for minors at least. No parent can police or tell what is going on in a guild chat until they have joined a raid. I am blown away by some of the horrible talk that goes on and can't imagine the game is good for anyone under 18 for this reason. I would not even want to hang out with people like this, protected by a fake name and electronic device. Virtue guild is one that is very, very descriptive and over the top porn to mention one. I would never let my kids play this game. Another guild, crusaders has a horrible racist member that remains in the game.

I don't believe that a game open to public use is the place for the over the top chat I have witnessed and experienced. If anyone wants to be drunk, stoned or on whatever and use talk the way I have witnessed it should be done in a private arena. Doing the right thing is all I am suggesting and if games such as Boh won't set some rules then boh should be policed perhaps.

Go ahead, spew all you will now at me.
Last year I was in G rated guilds. But I haven't even seen one of those in ages. In fact, one of the others that used to be clean says 18+ in their description.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Dec 16, 2013 2:02 pm
Its a hard call Puff. I think the idea that Venan polices Global and allows guilds freedom in their chat is a compromise and as good as you can get. Venan has to allow some freedoms to the players and, that being said, it would be impossible for them to moderate guild chat anyway...logistically speaking.

At some point parents need to be aware of what their children are doing and Venan has allowed for at least the game itself to be 9+. My kids have accounts and I am very aware of what guilds they are in. Just like I let my sons play BlackOps, TeamFortress 2, Unreal Tournament, and a slew of other online games, but I also police and monitor what servers they join and what chat is when they are playing and step in when appropriate.

The game has infrastructure in place to allow for 9+, and the game itself is 9+...but just like in real life, where people expect government to do the job of parents (be it education, protecting them from drugs, alcohol, inappropriate material).... it simply fails, and always will. Parents need to be responsible for their children's activities.

I for one an just glad my kids can play BoH and I know that there is nothing inappropriate in the game itself...and as long as I know what guilds they are in..I'm not worried.
Mithrid wrote:Its a hard call Puff. I think the idea that Venan polices Global and allows guilds freedom in their chat is a compromise and as good as you can get. Venan has to allow some freedoms to the players and, that being said, it would be impossible for them to moderate guild chat anyway...logistically speaking.

The solution is to give GMs and Officers mod powers on guild chat only. Then a guild could effectively decide to be G rated and enforce it.

Of course, it's development work and Venan may have a hard time justifying the ROI.
On the one hand, most of the paying customers are grownups, and enforcing PG chat in private environments (Guild, Whisper) the same way it's enforced in Global will just drive away revenue.

On the other, I'm a parent myself, and would object to people using that sort of language around my son.

It has been suggested a few times that guilds who have explicit chat can mark themselves as such in raid finder. Usually these suggestions come from these guilds themselves. They're not out to deliberately upset people. Unfortunately, that option is not yet available.

Some guilds deliberately enforce PG friendly chat - Helmsmen's Jacuzzi is a good example. Woe betide the member using Bad Words there!! Others actively encourage wild chat with no limits - Virtue are by no means what you would consider the worst. If they offended you, then for the love of all that is holy, NEVER go to Frësh Hëll!!!

At the end of the day, this is a game based on the internet, with real people. In any environment of this kind, the onus is on the parent to control what their children do. If you're worried that your kids might merc "bad" raids, or join "bad" guilds, then check those guilds out yourself. Most members will openly state whether their chat is child friendly, and actively discourage under agers where it is not.

Disclaimer: I have toons in Helmsmens' Jacuzzi, which is child friendly, and in Knights of the Old Republic, somewhat less so. I have no issues with either perspective, and participate appŕopriately in both. But... it's up to you to keep your kids safe online, not for everyone else to do it for you.
However, I agree that better tools to help you to do so - such as the afforementioned "This guild chat is / is not PG" would definitely help in doing so.
Puff, Puff, Puff. This is not a black and white area. Nothing is with maybe the exception of a zebra crossing. Global should of course be rated G. No argument from anyone except really stupid people. But the adults who play the game (majority of BoH) want to be able to express themselves as they choose. So, yes, it would be great if guilds had the ability to set themselves as 18+ which would block minors from joining guilds and/or raids. I would certainly support this myself, as would most players, I'd believe. Maybe minors could even merc into those guilds but have chat be disabled. I'm not sure what Venan is capable of as far as doing such or what plans they have. It is a topic that should be addressed. My suggestion is buy 10 wagons a day for a month and then Lord Venan will be more likely to take your call. Personally I prefer whispering Beekeo, but he always just responds: "go away Bims."
HJ has the benefit that Amy can moderate. She's created this myth that she sleeps on occasion, but I don't buy it. :D
CarlosDanger wrote:HJ has the benefit that Amy can moderate. She's created this myth that she sleeps on occasion, but I don't buy it. :D

She doesn't. Ever. Shame her iPhone doesn't charge as effectively!! :-D
Sleep? What's this sleep you speak of?

Oddly I'm in the cleanest chat around, HJ, and the stank nastiest, Fresh Hëll. One of these days I'll forget where I am...
Queen_Amy wrote:Sleep? What's this sleep you speak of?

Oddly I'm in the cleanest chat around, HJ, and the stank nastiest, Fresh Hëll. One of these days I'll forget where I am...

Please wait until we have video of players attached to chat for that...