Book of Heroes

Back to Hogwarts, or The State of the Mage

Mages are currently severely underpowered compared to the other two classes. This stems from two main factors:

1) mages must spend three actions merely setting up before they can begin to affect the enemy - Haste, Inner Focus, and then a Fracture. Only then can they effectively begin to use their spells. While having two interrupts, one a group interrupt (Time Warp) and the other a single-target spell (Icy Grasp) is useful, it can't make up up for the fact that mages are fragile in the first place and by the time they're ready to begin attacking, enemies have often attacked them already.

2) mages have neither cooldown-refreshing nor pushback skills. The shadow walker gets both effects in one skill (Smoke Bomb) while the justicar gets decent damage combined with pushback (Seismic Slash) and a very powerful refresh (Iron Will), and in a combat system in which the most precious commodity is always time, this lack is extremely serious.

A somewhat related problem is that the mage's boss-fighting skill, Combustion, is never maxed because it takes too long to take effect and offers little return on investment. This isn't something that necessarily has to be changed to put the mage on a more equal footing with the other classes, however, as they have situational "one-point wonders" as well.

Possible solution:

Remove Arcane Barrier entirely and replace it with Inner Focus in Tier 1. Arcane Barrier is useless; even when maxed, it doesn't appreciably improve the mage's survivability once he starts taking hits, because of his low health pool.

Combine the two Fracture spells into one, Elemental Fracture, lowering both cold and fire resistance. Move this to Tier 2. The mage will still have to invest points into fire and frost damage spells to take advantage of it, and it's unfair to require a double investment in setup spells.

Add a minor pushback effect to Time Warp which increases with upgrades, and remove the shortening prep time, which is useless. This will allow mages the setup time which is sorely lacking at present.

In Tier 3, create two new spells: the first should be a cooldown refresh skill like the Justicar's Iron Will, but with a weaker effect, a shorter prep time, and a shorter cooldown itself; call it Channelling or something. Ideally, it would be used to get rid of the "dead time" that occurs too frequently when the mage is hasted, and would be used on average 1.5-2 times per battle. The second new spell should be a group-target strong pushback with an up to 50% chance to inflict a frost DOT; call it Icy Gale. Medium prep time, medium cooldown.

Also, switch Flaming Pyre and Icy Grasp in the tiers, making Icy Grasp the second spell learned, giving the mage some crowd control at the beginning. Flaming Pyre belongs in Tier 2 with the comparable Ice Storm.
Makes sense! I have one of each class now, and the War Mage at level 21 is slower on raids than the level 17 Shadow Walker.

Swashbuckling_DrarrrrrrgonChick

ModeratorTue Jun 12, 2012 10:22 am
I agree, my Mage is severely underpowered when compared to my Justicar. Everything seems to take forever to set up and cast in battles, and I am lacking a quick hit (such as wound, seismic slash) that my Justicar has. Everything is much harder work with the Mage. I am still searching for the perfect combination of abilities which will turn my level 17 Mage into a character that is at least equal to The Overseer challenge, which she currently is not, despite having almost twice the required might.

Please look at the way the Mage class is set up, and rebalance stats/abilities or whatever to make them more playable!!

Little_Mike

Site AdminTue Jun 12, 2012 12:20 pm
We are aware of the current performance of all the classes. We will be addressing this soon and will let you guys know when it is closer to being finalized.
Marney wrote:Mages are currently severely underpowered compared to the other two classes. This stems from two main factors:

1) mages must spend three actions merely setting up before they can begin to affect the enemy - Haste, Inner Focus, and then a Fracture. Only then can they effectively begin to use their spells. While having two interrupts, one a group interrupt (Time Warp) and the other a single-target spell (Icy Grasp) is useful, it can't make up up for the fact that mages are fragile in the first place and by the time they're ready to begin attacking, enemies have often attacked them already.

I do agree with this to some extent. Most of our mages do not bother with Haste since it was nerfed to 20% because the time you get back from it is just not worthwhile. You can get to an acceptable level of Haste via hero tokens and some gems (I think most of them go for about 20-25% and they can feel free to correct me if I'm wrong).
Marney wrote:2) mages have neither cooldown-refreshing nor pushback skills. The shadow walker gets both effects in one skill (Smoke Bomb) while the justicar gets decent damage combined with pushback (Seismic Slash) and a very powerful refresh (Iron Will), and in a combat system in which the most precious commodity is always time, this lack is extremely serious.

See, this is what really got me and why I am making this post. Smoke Bomb is NOT an effective cooldown lowering ability. You want to use Smoke Bomb near the beginning of the fight to avoid getting hit and by that point guess what you haven't used. Abilities that have long cooldowns. SW's don't really need a cooldown lowering ability and if Venan took that part of Smoke Bomb out my reaction would be, "And nothing of value was lost." Iron Will is pretty sweet, but don't insult SW's by claiming Smoke Bomb serves the same function. It just erodes the credibility of your argument. This is not a secret lobby to separate Smoke Bomb into two abilities. SW's do not need it, especially if our other class issues actually get addressed.
Marney wrote:A somewhat related problem is that the mage's boss-fighting skill, Combustion, is never maxed because it takes too long to take effect and offers little return on investment. This isn't something that necessarily has to be changed to put the mage on a more equal footing with the other classes, however, as they have situational "one-point wonders" as well.

I don't have a single mage that complains about being unable to do bosses. Perhaps you're doing something wrong? The complaints I have from mages are the same reason I stopped playing mine. My mob 3 pack rotation used to be +dmg buff -> fire debuff -> Time Void (when it was a stun) -> Kamehameha -> Collect Loot. Obviously that was way too good </sarcasm> so Time Void got nerfed to the point where it's hardly functional and nothing was done to balance out the gaping hole in the 3 pack rotation. I got tired of getting beaten senseless everytime I ran into 3 mobs before I could kill them. Could mages use another tool for killing bosses? Uhh.. I guess. I think this was addressed in 1.3.3 by the lower cast time of Flaming Pyre.
Marney wrote:Possible solution:

Remove Arcane Barrier entirely and replace it with Inner Focus in Tier 1. Arcane Barrier is useless; even when maxed, it doesn't appreciably improve the mage's survivability once he starts taking hits, because of his low health pool.

Calling Arcane Barrier useless is pretty kind. I think it should be made into a passive skill to be honest. Leave it in the tier, but just have it always active at whatever you skill it up to. That would probably make it a lot more palatable if you didn't have to cast it and refresh it on long boss fights.
Marney wrote:Combine the two Fracture spells into one, Elemental Fracture, lowering both cold and fire resistance. Move this to Tier 2. The mage will still have to invest points into fire and frost damage spells to take advantage of it, and it's unfair to require a double investment in setup spells.

This is another example of what I would consider a design flaw. I whole heartedly agree with this concept. I understand the dynamic of wanting people to either spec fire or frost, but there are much more creative ways of doing it.
Marney wrote:Add a minor pushback effect to Time Warp which increases with upgrades, and remove the shortening prep time, which is useless. This will allow mages the setup time which is sorely lacking at present.

I actually thought the .5 second stun on it was perfectly fine.
Marney wrote:In Tier 3, create two new spells: the first should be a cooldown refresh skill like the Justicar's Iron Will, but with a weaker effect, a shorter prep time, and a shorter cooldown itself; call it Channelling or something. Ideally, it would be used to get rid of the "dead time" that occurs too frequently when the mage is hasted, and would be used on average 1.5-2 times per battle.

I think part of the skill test is figuring out how to balance your haste so that you minimize your downtime. Perhaps a better use would be a low damage, low cast time filler spell similar to Reflexive Strike without a cooldown. I do not consider melee attacking with the staff to be a viable use of filler time no matter how much Arcane Focus pretends to increase your melee damage. On that note, why haven't you asked for Arcane Focus to be combined with another buff spell and the +melee removed?
Marney wrote:The second new spell should be a group-target strong pushback with an up to 50% chance to inflict a frost DOT; call it Icy Gale. Medium prep time, medium cooldown.

You're going pretty deep on this one. Mages already have two AoE spells and you're asking for a third?
Marney wrote:Also, switch Flaming Pyre and Icy Grasp in the tiers, making Icy Grasp the second spell learned, giving the mage some crowd control at the beginning. Flaming Pyre belongs in Tier 2 with the comparable Ice Storm.

Soo.. you'd have Mages start out with Fireball on a cooldown and a stun? I think it would be better served perhaps as the third spell? Not that the first few levels take all that long.
Meian wrote:Most of our mages do not bother with Haste since it was nerfed to 20% because the time you get back from it is just not worthwhile. You can get to an acceptable level of Haste via hero tokens and some gems (I think most of them go for about 20-25% and they can feel free to correct me if I'm wrong).
Actually mine is at 40%, and I still use level one Haste to get to the cap (same with my shadow walker). It's not about time used casting versus time saved; it's about being able to interrupt enemies efficiently, at least in my playstyle.
Meian wrote:Smoke Bomb is NOT an effective cooldown lowering ability.
In conjunction with its pushback, certainly it is. Combine the 1.05s of natural cooldown over the duration of the net pushback (with 50% haste) with the 0.75s of instant refresh, and you're up to 1.8s. That's almost half the cooldown of both interrupts, the net and the garotte.
Meian wrote:You want to use Smoke Bomb near the beginning of the fight to avoid getting hit and by that point guess what you haven't used. Abilities that have long cooldowns.
It's not the abilities with long cooldowns that are helped by Smoke Bomb's refresh; it's the abilities with short cooldowns, as I mentioned above. 1.5 interrupts per fight or 3? I'll take 3.
Meian wrote:SW's don't really need a cooldown lowering ability and if Venan took that part of Smoke Bomb out my reaction would be, "And nothing of value was lost."
I agree with this only because shadow walkers are incredibly overpowered.
Meian wrote:Iron Will is pretty sweet, but don't insult SW's by claiming Smoke Bomb serves the same function. It just erodes the credibility of your argument. This is not a secret lobby to separate Smoke Bomb into two abilities. SW's do not need it, especially if our other class issues actually get addressed.
SWs have class issues? You mean, apart from being able to kill anything in the game without being hit even once?
Meian wrote:I don't have a single mage that complains about being unable to do bosses. Perhaps you're doing something wrong?
I guess I explained this part badly. My problem with playing my mage is not that it's difficult, or that I'm unable to kill bosses; it's that I don't have any fun while killing them. Playing a mage is much less dynamic than playing a shadow walker or a justicar, at least for me, probably because of the lack of meta-abilities. Or maybe, as you said, I'm just doing something wrong. :)
Meian wrote:I think this was addressed in 1.3.3 by the lower cast time of Flaming Pyre.
I'm certainly eager to give 1.3.3 a spin, and I'll update my impressions when I do. I hope you're right.
Meian wrote:Calling Arcane Barrier useless is pretty kind. I think it should be made into a passive skill to be honest. Leave it in the tier, but just have it always active at whatever you skill it up to. That would probably make it a lot more palatable if you didn't have to cast it and refresh it on long boss fights.
True. Well, anything that removes it as a castable skill is fine with me.
Meian wrote:This is another example of what I would consider a design flaw. I whole heartedly agree with this concept. I understand the dynamic of wanting people to either spec fire or frost, but there are much more creative ways of doing it.
Indeed. The DOT/slowdown split in fire and ice is one; perhaps if the DOT tick/refresh issue were addressed, among other things, that would help?
Meian wrote:I actually thought the .5 second stun on it was perfectly fine.
I agree. If Time Warp reverted to that it'd address much the same concern.
Meian wrote:I think part of the skill test is figuring out how to balance your haste so that you minimize your downtime. Perhaps a better use would be a low damage, low cast time filler spell similar to Reflexive Strike without a cooldown.
I wouldn't mind that either.
Meian wrote:I do not consider melee attacking with the staff to be a viable use of filler time no matter how much Arcane Focus pretends to increase your melee damage.
No, that's true. Mages shouldn't have to hit things physically; that defeats the whole focus of the class.
Meian wrote:On that note, why haven't you asked for Arcane Focus to be combined with another buff spell and the +melee removed?
Had to leave something for you. ;) Honestly, the idea didn't occur to me. With what would you combine it?
Meian wrote:Mages already have two AoE spells and you're asking for a third?
Mages traditionally fill a glass cannon role; their high damage is offset by their vulnerability; to allow them a chance at survival, they are also supposed to be good at crowd control. However, at present, I think they're woefully inadequate to the task.
Meian wrote:Soo.. you'd have Mages start out with Fireball on a cooldown and a stun? I think it would be better served perhaps as the third spell? Not that the first few levels take all that long.
Both your points are well taken. Anyway, given the substantial buff the mage seems to have received in 1.3.3, all this may be moot by the end of the week. Let's see how things work in practice.
Marney wrote:In conjunction with its pushback, certainly it is. Combine the 1.05s of natural cooldown over the duration of the net pushback (with 50% haste) with the 0.75s of instant refresh, and you're up to 1.8s. That's almost half the cooldown of both interrupts, the net and the garotte.

Or if you use Smoke Bomb combined with Caltrops at the right time you push a boss's cast bar back to past 4.0. That's why I don't consider it terribly effective as a cooldown lowering ability. Using it for that purpose just does not happen in my rotations consistently enough for me to consider it a feature of the spell.
Marney wrote:It's not the abilities with long cooldowns that are helped by Smoke Bomb's refresh; it's the abilities with short cooldowns, as I mentioned above. 1.5 interrupts per fight or 3? I'll take 3.

I really don't have much issue with interrupts. Garrote isn't terribly reliable, but when it isn't I can usually just use a Break Rune and call it good. If I do things right I tend to kill most things fast enough that unless I get really unlucky my interrupts are off cooldown by the time I need them again.
Marney wrote:I agree with this only because shadow walkers are incredibly overpowered.

Smoke Bomb is overpowered. Especially combined with a high % slow. The rest of the abilities, not so much. Especially when I see my mages (pre-1.3.3 mind you) landing 5000+ crits on bosses that I am lucky to see half that damage with all crits in the same amount of time. Actually, that's not fair. If TS and both my melee hits crit I get to about that damage and maybe a little more. Still 3 crits vs 1 is pretty rough until tomorrow I suppose.
Marney wrote:SWs have class issues? You mean, apart from being able to kill anything in the game without being hit even once?

Actually, yes.

1) It's just more expensive to be a SW than it is for the other classes. Because we pretty much have to DW we get to unlock all the sockets and buy matching sets of gems for two weapons instead of one for exactly the same benefit as a Justicar or Mage with a 2H.
2) With the 75/25 DW nerf coming in 1.3.3 I am going to lose roughly 20-25% of my damage output for no reason besides Venan feels the need to punish me for dual wielding beyond all of the obvious points I make in my other thread.
3) Shadow Stalker is worthless, but so is Dodge so that's not a surprise. To pre-empt the "dodge is good" argument, I assure you when monsters are launching balls of fire and nether death at you, 100% dodge is the same as 0% dodge. Also, historically dodge works great until it stops.
4) Reflexive Strike is mediocre. It's sort of like a filler and is sometimes useful but the damage is rather pathetic and many times I could just as easily use a rune as I could use Reflexive Strike and get more out of it.
5) Piercing Strike might be better come 1.3.3 but only because melee attack is looking VERY unattractive. Also, Piercing Strike will only be truly attractive until I hit the soft cap for Crit (VERY likely within a day or two of 1.3.3 launching).
6) Our poisons scale with magic damage and our strikes scale with melee and I don't get the benefit of having a % based damage buff that increases both. Instead, I get a 50% bonus to Nature Damage for 3 seconds (or about two Toxic Strikes and maybe a Poison Cloud if I'm feeling squirrely). Without that buff up, it's rather underwhelming for damage unless for some reason I stacked heavy Magic on my melee class (rather counter-intuitive) but if I do that then all my other attacks are near worthless.

So, yeah. I'd say SW's while rather overpowered thanks to Smoke Bomb have some pretty nasty fundamental flaws as a class. There are more I've found, but I haven't compiled a list and I'm just shooting from the hip at the moment.
Marney wrote:I guess I explained this part badly. My problem with playing my mage is not that it's difficult, or that I'm unable to kill bosses; it's that I don't have any fun while killing them. Playing a mage is much less dynamic than playing a shadow walker or a justicar, at least for me, probably because of the lack of meta-abilities. Or maybe, as you said, I'm just doing something wrong. :)

I could see that. I got bored with my Mage's rotation too. It could stand to have some more versatile abilities thrown in.
Marney wrote:Indeed. The DOT/slowdown split in fire and ice is one; perhaps if the DOT tick/refresh issue were addressed, among other things, that would help?

Oh, you hate having to track when your DoTs are going to tick so you don't clip them with a refresh too? Here I was thinking it was just me. You wouldn't happen to have ever played WoW as an Affliction Warlock or a Shadow Priest would you?
Marney wrote:
Meian wrote:I do not consider melee attacking with the staff to be a viable use of filler time no matter how much Arcane Focus pretends to increase your melee damage.
No, that's true. Mages shouldn't have to hit things physically; that defeats the whole focus of the class.
Meian wrote:On that note, why haven't you asked for Arcane Focus to be combined with another buff spell and the +melee removed?
Had to leave something for you. ;) Honestly, the idea didn't occur to me. With what would you combine it?

If it were me, I would combine the +physical defense of Arcane Barrier with the +magic damage of Arcane Focus and in the empty spell slot put in a thing where your Defend ability also grants a 20/35/50% chance to reflect a harmful spell to it's caster and/or decrease the cast time of your next spell, but I'm just cool like that.
Marney wrote:Mages traditionally fill a glass cannon role; their high damage is offset by their vulnerability; to allow them a chance at survival, they are also supposed to be good at crowd control. However, at present, I think they're woefully inadequate to the task.

So, what we're looking for here really is Time Void somewhere between where it used to be and where it is now. I think that would address many of the CC issues.

I am working on an SW primer and I may or may not have it done sometime in the next week as my schedule allows. I also need to see how much Crit rating I will need to soft cap (a soft cap is a number that you get to via stats and can get to the maximum when you have a buff on you, in this case Vanish).
Meian wrote:Or if you use Smoke Bomb combined with Caltrops at the right time you push a boss's cast bar back to past 4.0. That's why I don't consider it terribly effective as a cooldown lowering ability.
Fair enough; I do like to put Trask on hold when he starts his Deathly Curse. :) Amusing, if a little mean.
Meian wrote:1) It's just more expensive to be a SW than it is for the other classes. Because we pretty much have to DW we get to unlock all the sockets and buy matching sets of gems for two weapons instead of one for exactly the same benefit as a Justicar or Mage with a 2H.
Yeah, I agree with this, as I said in your other thread. But that's not a problem exclusive to shadow walkers.
Meian wrote:2) With the 75/25 DW nerf coming in 1.3.3 I am going to lose roughly 20-25% of my damage output for no reason besides Venan feels the need to punish me for dual wielding beyond all of the obvious points I make in my other thread.
Have you considered how we'll be affected by the lifting of the 50% crit cap? Might make up for it to a degree.
Meian wrote:3) Shadow Stalker is worthless, but so is Dodge so that's not a surprise. To pre-empt the "dodge is good" argument, I assure you when monsters are launching balls of fire and nether death at you, 100% dodge is the same as 0% dodge. Also, historically dodge works great until it stops.
Agreed; I've never seen any reason to try to raise my dodge percentage, though if your passive skills idea is ever implemented, it'd be worth a second look.
Meian wrote:4) Reflexive Strike is mediocre. It's sort of like a filler and is sometimes useful but the damage is rather pathetic and many times I could just as easily use a rune as I could use Reflexive Strike and get more out of it.
I tried max RS for a bit after freeing up points from buffs, after upgrading gems. It did about 2.5k max on a crit. Have to agree, not worth it with the long cooldown. Maybe a point to shave off the last little sliver of something that barely survives a poison cloud.
Meian wrote:5) Piercing Strike might be better come 1.3.3 but only because melee attack is looking VERY unattractive. Also, Piercing Strike will only be truly attractive until I hit the soft cap for Crit (VERY likely within a day or two of 1.3.3 launching).
Never had much use for this skill. I've had it maxed, I've had it in rotation with a single point; either way, it didn't make much of a difference.
Meian wrote:6) Our poisons scale with magic damage and our strikes scale with melee and I don't get the benefit of having a % based damage buff that increases both. Instead, I get a 50% bonus to Nature Damage for 3 seconds (or about two Toxic Strikes and maybe a Poison Cloud if I'm feeling squirrely). Without that buff up, it's rather underwhelming for damage unless for some reason I stacked heavy Magic on my melee class (rather counter-intuitive) but if I do that then all my other attacks are near worthless.
This is a good point that I hadn't considered fully, though I do stack magic more than melee myself, so it doesn't really affect me. It is notable that our debuff only affects one of our damage types, while the other two classes get a buff that affects all their damage types.
Meian wrote:Oh, you hate having to track when your DoTs are going to tick so you don't clip them with a refresh too? Here I was thinking it was just me. You wouldn't happen to have ever played WoW as an Affliction Warlock or a Shadow Priest would you?
Both, though my warlock was a summoner with a minor in affliction. ;) Is it that obvious? Anyway, I suggested a solution for the DOT problem here.
Having played with the mage a bit now in 1.3.3, here are my impressions:

I'm definitely hitting harder, and it's palpable, not just on paper - fewer casts are necessary to get through equal-level mobs. The reduced prep time on fracture helps too, allowing a monster to be eliminated and another trapped before the mage begins to take hits. I don't think the addition of direct damage to Icy Grasp was necessary, but heck, I won't complain.

Unfortunately, downtime is still a problem in a standard rotation, and the abilities are still too mechanical, with no dynamic adjustments possible. This was a good tweak, but it was only a tweak. The numbers are better, and they have a real and positive effect on the viability of playing a mage, but I guess I just don't like the style of play: pushback and cooldown abilities would make a real difference; this is merely tinkering with a flawed model. I suppose that's more my problem at this point than the game's, though, and I'm sure the vast majority of mages are satisfied with the changes. :)