Book of Heroes

Making combat more tactical

Add a standard pushback of 0.05 seconds to current prep time whenever either an enemy or a player takes damage of any kind, including DOT damage.

Hero Training: Unflinching
%chance to ignore standard pushback from damage, no cap, but diminishing returns after 50%. Blue gem.

Immunities by creature type:
Undead, golems, and automatons shouldn't take DOT from Wound or Poison Cloud. Such creatures would also be immune to standard pushback from damage.

Separate the damage ticks and the duration of DOT effects, so a renewal or a stack doesn't reset the counter and reduce overall damage. Or, upon renewal or stacking, immediately assess a tick of the new DOT, then reset the counter.

Allow a rest in 0.05 second increments.

Allow monsters to change the target of their buffs in mid-prep, so, for example, a monster won't add Fury to another monster which has just added Fury to itself. Communication is key, monsters! Even when infuriated!

Here's an idea which could work, but I'm doubtful of its value: color-coding the prep bar of monsters to signify buff (blue), heal (green), direct damage (red), or debuff (orange). I keep mixing up those automatons' Rampage and Charge abilities, and which I should interrupt. :) To signify inexperience with new monsters, perhaps this could only come into play after a certain number of kills of a particular monster. It could be further tweaked by not even naming the abilities of new monsters at first.
It would be great if the higher level enemies are smarter - make the battles less repetitive.

Lord_Venan

Site AdminFri Jun 22, 2012 5:09 pm
Great suggestions. Some of those are things we'd like to explore, and it's great to see that the users are open for fights being more tactical.
Further thoughts on possible monster immunities:

Large creatures like dragons shouldn't be affected by the Shadow Walker's Ensnare skill, or if they are, they should only be interrupted, not stunned for a duration. Maybe flash "Diminished Effect" over the creature if the latter happens.

Shadow Walker Caltrops shouldn't affect insubstantial creatures with no feet, such as shades, or flying creatures, such as Wyverns, Bats, and Snow Sentinels.

Give high-level monsters more status effect abilities, such as the Witch's Burning Hilt. (But make Burning Hilt itself affect only regular attacks, and skills which actually use a weapon, such as Piercing Strike - don't just make all skills which use weapon damage as a base unusable.) Speed up creatures and lower their damage, if necessary; Trask may do over 600 points with his Deathly Curse, but he never gets to finish casting it.

Give mage-type monsters the ability to remove player buffs. Give others the ability to remove debuffs placed on monsters, one at a time or as a group. Give monsters more interrupts, and let bosses summon minions in combat, or have minions automatically appear every so often.

If a monster slowed by an Ice Storm or Frozen Shard takes fire damage from any source, remove the slow debuff. In parallel, a monster suffering a burn effect should have it negated if it takes frost damage.

Put a cooldown timer on Cleansing potions, and perhaps reconsider allowing things like Combust (which might not directly affect the character in the first place, depending on how one imagines it functions) to be cleansed at all. If a stacked effect (such as Frostbite) is affecting the player, only remove one stack, not the whole effect.
Some of these ideas are interesting. It some are too much. I don't like the idea of a .05 second rest. I don't like the idea of flinching due to damage and having casting time increased because of it (can't think of any RPG off the top of my head that has fights like that). Changing target of the spells because the original target is dead sounds like unnecessary scripting. And more immunities for enemies? I'm a Mage. I have fire and ice and a weak melee and have to interchange between at least two of the basic types because of cooldowns.... So yes I use fire on fire resistant enemies already while waiting for ice to cooldown but you want to add more immunities?

Getting might is tough enough as it is. Let's keep it simple.
Chriss wrote:Some of these ideas are interesting. It some are too much.
This isn't a coherent bundle of ideas all of which I necessarily want to see implemented into the game as it stands; it's more a collection of thoughts that I jot down as they occur to me. I agree that implementing them all at a go would probably be a bad thing, but I'm just throwing them out there for individual consideration. I suppose I should've made that more clear in the initial post.
Chriss wrote:I don't like the idea of a .05 second rest.
Yeah, you're right; that's way too finicky, in retrospect.
Chriss wrote:I don't like the idea of flinching due to damage and having casting time increased because of it (can't think of any RPG off the top of my head that has fights like that).
Actually, this is one of the ideas I'm rather more fond of. It would make DOT effects more significant (who cares about the piddling damage they do at present?) and it would be "realistic," while not being hugely game-changing. As for other RPGs, well, other RPGs don't work in visible 0.05 second increments that the player can have a deliberate and consistent effect on.
Chriss wrote:Changing target of the spells because the original target is dead sounds like unnecessary scripting.
Well, what I proposed was allowing monsters to change spell targets if their original target already had the buff they were casting. And what you're objecting to is already in the game. ;) At least for players - impossible to know by observation alone if it's there for monsters.
Chriss wrote:And more immunities for enemies? I'm a Mage. I have fire and ice and a weak melee and have to interchange between at least two of the basic types because of cooldowns.... So yes I use fire on fire resistant enemies already while waiting for ice to cooldown but you want to add more immunities?
I have a character at level 25 in all three classes, and I've written extensively on the mage's problems before; I'm not specifically trying to make playing a mage more difficult. Also, if you'll notice, most of my suggested immunities would apply to Shadow Walker skills... not War Mage skills. The only thing I suggested concerning mage skills was that the remaining duration of the secondary effects of some skills might be cancelled out by opposite elements. I said nothing about resistances. Could you at least argue against things that I have proposed?
Chriss wrote:Getting might is tough enough as it is. Let's keep it simple.
Not one suggestion I made had anything at all to do with the might stat. Anyway, it's not "tough" at all to get might. At one point, I had 7062 might without any valor on my main character, and only one shield-purchased piece of equipment (MH). My alts are around 6k and 5k, again, with no valor equipment, and much less attention given to them.

People who spend even one second complaining about having low might, when they could be doing something to change that instead, are getting to be one of my pet peeves.

That aside, I think the point about "keeping it simple" is a good one, and I have to admit that the added complexity some of my ideas might introduce may not be worth any value they'd add to gameplay. :) That's why I posted them here, for players as well as devs to consider and comment on.
When I said might is tough enough it was a general statement. All your improvements seem to make things tougher. It's easy to get around 6k might with decent guilds but wow that last raid requirement is a doozy and was what I was looking at and calculating before I jumped into the forums haha
Please, the might requirement for War of Fellmarsh is merely 10250. That can be met with nothing but Tier 10 equipment bought for soldier valor; in fact, one of my friends is well past that point already, and we haven't even completed the challenge to qualify for the Vallus raid yet. And as I pointed out earlier, I once had over 7k without any valor equipment; full deathblights, boss drop gems, and a single tier 9 weapon were sufficient. No one needs a guild for that.

It's easy to meet all the might requirements, just as pretty much everything about this game is easy, apart from the managerial chore of trying to get enough people online at the same time to finish a raid without spending shields for energy. I think the actual gameplay needs to pose more of a challenge, which is why most of my suggested improvements would "make things tougher" (though the DOT and color-coding suggestions in the original post would mostly help players, and the standard pushback idea is pretty neutral). I'd like to actually lose health points on occasion.

The biggest challenge in the game should not be convincing people to show up and play the darn thing.
New mechanic: Standard Variation
Whenever an ability is initiated, whether by a player or a monster, add a random percentage to the prep time (between 0 and 25%). This represents unforeseen and unspecified complications on the field, where moves and spells have to be executed not in the nice quiet Glenfort training room where you learned them, but on the slippery slopes of a glacier with frostbite numbing your toes, or in a dank filthy marsh with a faceful of mosquitoes, or deep inside the suffocating heat of volcanic caverns.

New hero training: Discipline
Reduce the standard variation by a percentage, with diminishing returns after 50%. Yellow gem.



This would serve to make combat less stultifyingly predictable, and hopefully throw off the precise timing that at present allows any class to win any fight without taking any damage. Break runes would have a reason (beyond convenience) to exist again, as would health potions, and the three damage mitigation stats, not to mention dodge, might actually begin to matter.