Book of Heroes

Making combat more tactical · page 2

[Deleted rude comment. Sorry again. :.( ] I do like some of your logical suggestions like ensnare not trapping a dragon amd caltrops not working on floating/flying creatures, except that would only hinder the shadow walkers.
Ah yes, the old "you have no life" argument. Why don't you tell me I must live in a basement next? Personal attacks always win people over. :)

I'm not interested in some sort of silly internet flamewar. Please talk about the gameplay mechanics, and not the person who proposed them.

Moving on.
OneDannyBoy wrote:I do like some of your logical suggestions like ensnare not trapping a dragon amd caltrops not working on floating/flying creatures, except that would only hinder the shadow walkers.

Thanks for the compliment. I'd argue that shadow walkers need to be hindered somewhat; the smoke bomb/vanish/acid spray/poison cloud combination is an "I win" button (okay, four buttons) against pretty much any non-boss mob, and it's not difficult to acquire enough haste and magic to make it almost unbeatable. With the 26% additional slow of caltrops3 on top of the flat 1.5s pushback of smoke bomb3 providing a chance to clean up any unlikely stragglers, it is unbeatable. If some creatures were naturally immune to caltrops, that would at least make it theoretically possible for them to attack maybe once.
Idunno about the personal insults. There are chat rules so be careful before insulting anyone.

But yea, M, just because it's easy for you doesn't mean it's easy for other people. I play daily but not a whole lot and I don't spend real money. Not saying you do just saying... Well, let me put it a another way: The game isn't hard but it CAN take a while for average joe to amass might.

You seem to have a good head on your shoulders from what I've seen you post in other places so I'm sure you can understand, you hardcore player =P
If some or most of this is implemented, then the game mechanics also need to be made more transparent. For instance by giving monsters permanent and visible buffs if they are Huge (immune to net ensare) or Incorporeal (immune to caltrips). There's presently too much guesswork involved in playing the game, because Venan has opted for concealed game mechanics instead of transparency.
Chriss wrote:Idunno about the personal insults. There are chat rules so be careful before insulting anyone.
Yeah, and apart from the rules, isn't it kind of useless? I mean, I can't imagine a Venan dev coming across this thread and thinking (on the off chance that he or she likes one of my ideas), "Y'know, I'd like to use this, but OneDannyBoy really insulted her quite eloquently! She has no life, therefore I don't want to improve the game!" :)
Chriss wrote:But yea, M, just because it's easy for you doesn't mean it's easy for other people. I play daily but not a whole lot and I don't spend real money. Not saying you do just saying... Well, let me put it a another way: The game isn't hard but it CAN take a while for average joe to amass might.
Well, that's a fair point, and maybe some of my suggestions would make it too hard for people to level up at an acceptable rate. I thought I offered fairly reasonable suggestions on the whole, but then, that's what this entire thread was created to discuss! :) I'm happy to talk about specifics - I just don't think I'm qualified to address the broader questions of what would be acceptable in general terms. What the effects on progression would be - yes. But whether they're desirable, or not? That's a balancing act that only the devs would be properly suited to consider, in my opinion.
Chriss wrote:You seem to have a good head on your shoulders from what I've seen you post in other places so I'm sure you can understand, you hardcore player =P
Thank you! I appreciate the fact that we've agreed as well as disagreed here and in other topics, and in the latter case, you've never descended into calumny. Makes the conversation so much more pleasant. :)
Peter34 wrote:If some or most of this is implemented, then the game mechanics also need to be made more transparent. For instance by giving monsters permanent and visible buffs if they are Huge (immune to net ensare) or Incorporeal (immune to caltrips). There's presently too much guesswork involved in playing the game, because Venan has opted for concealed game mechanics instead of transparency.
I agree with your general point, though I think it might not be so much a deliberate concealment as the fact that people haven't asked yet, and perhaps a design decision involving accessibility. This is still a rather young game, a fact its polish sometimes makes it easy to forget.
I agree with marney, i have a job and a kid and still have time to increas my might relatively quickly. if you optimize your equipment, gem allocation and hero training you should not have might difficulties. Also of you raid as much as possible and use Lockboxes to turn excess silver to gold then the game is relatively straight forward.
The issues I have are that I am maxed out in crit, crit pwr and haste stats with only tier 10 gear and lvl3 gems (>10.5k might so last raid is covered). And since I'm a warmage I have no hope of getting passed the crit soft cap of 50% while shadow walkers can get upto 100%.
To make things more interesting, I would add in higher stat soft caps to make it worth getting t11 gear and lvl4 gems, and implement a MMA (mixed martial arts) style feature where one class can choose to learn a certain ability of the other classes (limited to one or two). Finally the sigils are much less worth the gold (or valor) than they used to be (before update) especially when raiding. E.g. The coveted knight sigil will only give an extra 330 rpp in any raid which is not a very high increase especially when it is quite difficult to obtain. I think going back to 1en per encounter will greatly increase the advantages of sigils and will probably make more players spend the shields to get them. If changing the 'en per encounter' isn't an option then getting more sigils with bigger energy boosts will probably have the same effect.
The inconsequentiality of expensive sigils in the context of raids is certainly a problem, but if the entire structure of raids is being reconsidered (as Lord Venan said in his devblog), then that particular problem may solve itself.
Ya, im sorry. I did come across rude, and I was having a bad day and I think I took it out on you Marney without even realizing what I was doing. Looking back in hindsite, I see I was wrong. And I feel really bad :(
That's all right, apology accepted. No hard feelings. :)

Actually, you made a point that helped me think through the implications of my suggestions regarding caltrops and ensnare.

I think the shadow walkers such a change would affect (ensnare not working on large creatures, or working at a lower effectiveness depending on rank, as I expanded on here, in reference to Peter's original post) would not primarily be low-level characters. Consider the enemies it would apply to: shades, I believe, are the first insubstantial enemies, and bats the first flying ones. Both first appear at around levels 8-10, by which point people are at least familiar with the game. All rath'een, who appear throughout the game, would still be affected, as would all goblins. The actual number of enemies fought (as opposed to types of creatures) that would become less vulnerable, or immune, to the two skills would actually be quite small.