Book of Heroes

SW's Ensnare, why EVER put 2-3p into it (suggestion)

The Shadow Walker's Ensnare 1st tier ability immobilizes a mob for 3, 4 or 5 seconds, depending on the number of skill points put into it, with the first SP being mandatory. Any damage whatsoever causes the Ensnare ability to disappear instantly.

With the first SP being mandatory, the question that each SW player must answer is whether it is worthwhile putting one or two additional points into Ensnare. For me the answer is a resounding no, and I think most other SW players agree with me.

The problem is that Ensnare is sensitive to DoT, Damage-over-Time effects, and this makes it nearly completely useless. I only ever use it during boss fights, and even then I use it rarely. I love using Caltrops, but Caltrops do two things, they slow down all mobs, and they give DoT to all mobs. I need the slow-down effect, but the DoT means that I'm effectively forced to choose between Ensnare and Caltrops. Caltrops wins 99% of the time.

Increasing the time to 3/5/7 or even 3/6/9 seconds changes nothing, because more time isn't really worth anything. 3 seconds is already an eternity in BoH, representing 60 game time "ticks". A lot can happen in 60 ticks. I don't need more ticks.

What Ensnare needs is the ability to not always evaporate instantly as soon as the Ensnared mob takes 1 hp of damage.



My solution is to do away with the time limit on Ensnare. It should last potentially indefinitely. Instead of basing it on time, base it on Net Points. Basic ability gives 4 Net Points on the Ensnared mob. Adding extra SP to the skill increases this to 7, eventually 10 Net Points.

Each time the Ensnared mob takes damage that is less than half its level, in a single instance, nothing happens. It remains Ensnared.

Each time an Ensnared mob takes damage that is less than its level but more than half its level, 1 Net Point is lost. Damage between 1xLevel and 1.5xLevel costs 2 Net Points. Damage between 1.5xLevel and 2xLevel costs 3 Net Points. And so forth.

When all the Net Points are gone, the Ensnare effect goes away, and the mob can move and fight again.

This way, I can have a Caltrops on all the mobs, and after that I can Ensnare one of them, and fight the other two. I can also fire off a Rune. The more DoT I have on the Ensnared mob, the faster the ensnare goes away. And there's now a real, genuine incentive to put more SP into Ensnare.
I'd simplify the mechanics a bit, personally (maybe just allow 1/3/5 instances of any damage taken before breaking stun), but overall, this is an excellent idea that would indeed make additional points in Ensnare not entirely worthless.

Another (or additional) possibility would be to grade creatures based on size. Ensnare 1 would work on normal monsters only, Ensnare 2 would work on large normal monsters as well, and Ensnare 3 would work on everything, including bosses.
Ensnare is ment for lower level SW. It is not useless, but only seems so in some builds. Improving it may be useful, but even if I choose not to use it regularly, or at all, this doesn't make it broken. And if it isn't broken don't fix it. If you want them to fix something, how about dual wielding weapon damage for SW. Simple fix really, allow only the main hand to crit at 100% damage ( plus all bonuses) and have off hand only do base damage ( when it hits ) accordingly, adjusting when necessary for montster resistances.
dragonclan wrote:Ensnare is ment for lower level SW.
Um, no. One of the nice things about this game is that no tier of skills necessarily becomes outdated simply because a character gains levels.
dragonclan wrote:It is not useless, but only seems so in some builds.
There is no build in which Ensnare itself is "useless." Peter's post is about the fact that adding duration to the stun length of Ensnare is not a sensible use of skill points.
dragonclan wrote:Improving it may be useful, but even if I choose not to use it regularly, or at all, this doesn't make it broken.
Everyone uses Ensnare. Everyone. No one increases the skill rank beyond 1.

You're missing the point.
dragonclan wrote:If you want them to fix something, how about dual wielding weapon damage for SW. Simple fix really, allow only the main hand to crit at 100% damage ( plus all bonuses) and have off hand only do base damage
That's not a fix; that's a balance adjustment.
Perhaps I missed his point. Perhaps I saw the end product, & realized what he was asking for was without merit. SW are diverse in many ways. Killing stuff is so easy after a certain level of gear that his idea is wasted because everything is dead. I use ensare as an interrupt like everyone else, & successfully. His idea would make my SW impossible to hit ever; while that would be great I doubt it's a possibility in the making.
dragonclan wrote:Perhaps I missed his point.
There's no "perhaps" about it. You did. Because you didn't appreciate the fairly obvious distinction between using a skill at all and increasing its rank.
dragonclan wrote:Perhaps I saw the end product, & realized what he was asking for was without merit.
The "end product," as I understood Peter's original post, was supposed to be a reason to increase the skill rank of Ensnare. Why is that "without merit?"
dragonclan wrote:Killing stuff is so easy after a certain level of gear that his idea is wasted because everything is dead.
So because 'walkers can kill easily at mid to high levels (as can either of the other two classes, incidentally; not as quickly, but with equal ease), there's no need to make it worthwhile to increase Ensnare's skill rank. Not exactly an argument. More of a non sequitur, but you seem to have a penchant for those.
We see it differently Marney. Why do you keep quoting me. Just be honest. I've said some things you don't like, so now your going to naysay me? Stop trolling me & help Peter better his idea, & leave me to my opinion. Further more, just as you are entitled to your opinions, I'm entitled to mine.
I just think ensnare works fine as is.
dragonclan wrote:Why do you keep quoting me.
To make it clear what I'm responding to. :) There's nothing sinister about it.
dragonclan wrote:Just be honest. I've said some things you don't like, so now your going to naysay me? Stop trolling me & help Peter better his idea, & leave me to my opinion.
I'm being perfectly honest: you've said some things I disagree with. Likes and dislikes don't come into it. And in my very first post in this thread, I did try to help Peter with his idea. My support for it predates your involvement, so it can't have been caused by any animus you're implying I have.

I'm not attempting to "troll" you in any way, I'm simply responding to what you post about game mechanics: my disagreement with you in this thread, on entirely technical grounds, has nothing to do with my distaste for your conduct anywhere else.
dragonclan wrote:I just think ensnare works fine as is.
At rank 1, yes it does. Investing a point or two points does not make its combat effectiveness increase, because its actual use in rotation is different from how it was originally conceived, presumably - which was the point of this thread.
I ran my SW up to level 25 without even thinking an extra second of delay would help me. Fortunately there are tons of other skills I can put my points in, which increase more effectively with extra points. I don't use caltrops against minions anymore, just bosses to slow them down a little.

That said, and as OP said, 3 seconds is an eternity to a high level toon. It's not long enough at low level. I've just started a new toon within the last week, and am realising that powers don't work quite as well at those low levels as I am used to with my level 25 characters.

It would be nice if additional levels granted, as the OP said, immunity to one or more subsequent hits. If it's really a net as the picture suggests, why should your opponents be freed by a hit at all?
Pfaff wrote:It would be nice if additional levels granted, as the OP said, immunity to one or more subsequent hits. If it's really a net as the picture suggests, why should your opponents be freed by a hit at all?

I think it's a standard game design principle. I'm no expert on AD&D, but I'd presume that one of the rules for the Sleep spell is that if the target takes any damage, the effect of the spell ends.

Venan simply followed this principle, when designing Ensnare, and did not quite think the matter through, in terms of the various ways in which RPGs and computer games like World of Warcraft differ from Book of Heroes. For instance, in terms of spatial location not mattering. There are no positions or distances in BoH, so one of the most obvious uses for a sleep/ensnare/stun ability in AD&D or WoW, to trap a mob so that you can run away from it, is irrelevant in BoH.

Also, much of the problem is that Caltrops has a DoT effect. And I still think my suggestion is good, because it changes Ensnare from an absolute and binary thing, in which a mob either IS or IS NOT Ensnared, and in which any damage to the mob, however tiny, removes the IS state, and into a matter of degree, in which a mob can be more or less Ensnared, and each time the mob takes damage, its degree of Ensnaredness is reduced, but remains IS until the degree zero.



A much more general principle of game design is that good design results in players making a variety of choices, instead of all players gravitating towards the same choice.

My claim about Ensnare is that it is badly designed, and the proof is if I am correct in almost no players choosing to put more than 1 point into the skill (sameness: Everyone has less than 2 points in Ensnare). Unfortunately, I do not have the power to do a statistical analysis of player choices. Only Venan can do that, and they may not care to.