The Shadow Walker's Ensnare 1st tier ability immobilizes a mob for 3, 4 or 5 seconds, depending on the number of skill points put into it, with the first SP being mandatory. Any damage whatsoever causes the Ensnare ability to disappear instantly.
With the first SP being mandatory, the question that each SW player must answer is whether it is worthwhile putting one or two additional points into Ensnare. For me the answer is a resounding no, and I think most other SW players agree with me.
The problem is that Ensnare is sensitive to DoT, Damage-over-Time effects, and this makes it nearly completely useless. I only ever use it during boss fights, and even then I use it rarely. I love using Caltrops, but Caltrops do two things, they slow down all mobs, and they give DoT to all mobs. I need the slow-down effect, but the DoT means that I'm effectively forced to choose between Ensnare and Caltrops. Caltrops wins 99% of the time.
Increasing the time to 3/5/7 or even 3/6/9 seconds changes nothing, because more time isn't really worth anything. 3 seconds is already an eternity in BoH, representing 60 game time "ticks". A lot can happen in 60 ticks. I don't need more ticks.
What Ensnare needs is the ability to not always evaporate instantly as soon as the Ensnared mob takes 1 hp of damage.
My solution is to do away with the time limit on Ensnare. It should last potentially indefinitely. Instead of basing it on time, base it on Net Points. Basic ability gives 4 Net Points on the Ensnared mob. Adding extra SP to the skill increases this to 7, eventually 10 Net Points.
Each time the Ensnared mob takes damage that is less than half its level, in a single instance, nothing happens. It remains Ensnared.
Each time an Ensnared mob takes damage that is less than its level but more than half its level, 1 Net Point is lost. Damage between 1xLevel and 1.5xLevel costs 2 Net Points. Damage between 1.5xLevel and 2xLevel costs 3 Net Points. And so forth.
When all the Net Points are gone, the Ensnare effect goes away, and the mob can move and fight again.
This way, I can have a Caltrops on all the mobs, and after that I can Ensnare one of them, and fight the other two. I can also fire off a Rune. The more DoT I have on the Ensnared mob, the faster the ensnare goes away. And there's now a real, genuine incentive to put more SP into Ensnare.
With the first SP being mandatory, the question that each SW player must answer is whether it is worthwhile putting one or two additional points into Ensnare. For me the answer is a resounding no, and I think most other SW players agree with me.
The problem is that Ensnare is sensitive to DoT, Damage-over-Time effects, and this makes it nearly completely useless. I only ever use it during boss fights, and even then I use it rarely. I love using Caltrops, but Caltrops do two things, they slow down all mobs, and they give DoT to all mobs. I need the slow-down effect, but the DoT means that I'm effectively forced to choose between Ensnare and Caltrops. Caltrops wins 99% of the time.
Increasing the time to 3/5/7 or even 3/6/9 seconds changes nothing, because more time isn't really worth anything. 3 seconds is already an eternity in BoH, representing 60 game time "ticks". A lot can happen in 60 ticks. I don't need more ticks.
What Ensnare needs is the ability to not always evaporate instantly as soon as the Ensnared mob takes 1 hp of damage.
My solution is to do away with the time limit on Ensnare. It should last potentially indefinitely. Instead of basing it on time, base it on Net Points. Basic ability gives 4 Net Points on the Ensnared mob. Adding extra SP to the skill increases this to 7, eventually 10 Net Points.
Each time the Ensnared mob takes damage that is less than half its level, in a single instance, nothing happens. It remains Ensnared.
Each time an Ensnared mob takes damage that is less than its level but more than half its level, 1 Net Point is lost. Damage between 1xLevel and 1.5xLevel costs 2 Net Points. Damage between 1.5xLevel and 2xLevel costs 3 Net Points. And so forth.
When all the Net Points are gone, the Ensnare effect goes away, and the mob can move and fight again.
This way, I can have a Caltrops on all the mobs, and after that I can Ensnare one of them, and fight the other two. I can also fire off a Rune. The more DoT I have on the Ensnared mob, the faster the ensnare goes away. And there's now a real, genuine incentive to put more SP into Ensnare.