Book of Heroes

SW's Ensnare, why EVER put 2-3p into it (suggestion) · page 2

Marney wrote:I'd simplify the mechanics a bit, personally (maybe just allow 1/3/5 instances of any damage taken before breaking stun), but overall, this is an excellent idea that would indeed make additional points in Ensnare not entirely worthless.

I am on the verge of creaming in my paints, thinking about the grotesque extent to which I can abuse this. Sorry. But if I can paralyze a mob and get the opportunity to hit it 3 or even 5 times before it can defend itself, I'm basically going to be able to pwn anything efforlessly.

My original suggestion was flawed in terms of numbers, in that the hp damage thresholds for when Net Points are removed, should be raised substantially. But I still think my idea is gone, exactly because it means that a single very high damage hit (such as the ones my level 25 SW are wont to make) will instantly remove all remaining Net Points on the mob.
Marney wrote:Another (or additional) possibility would be to grade creatures based on size. Ensnare 1 would work on normal monsters only, Ensnare 2 would work on large normal monsters as well, and Ensnare 3 would work on everything, including bosses.

I'm not particularly happy about this one. It's certainly unlikely to lure me into spending my precious skill points on more than the first level of Ensnare. And I'd guess that after trying it out, most players would re-spect back to a single point in Ensnare, not finding it sufficiently useful to be able to ensnare larger mobs, to be worth 1 or 2 skill points.

Also, I am fairly certain that none of Venan's mobs are defined by any kind of Size attribute or statistic, so they'd have go to through their database and add that, for all the run-of-the-mill mobs, all the dungeon bosses (the raid bosses can just "inherit" the Size stat or Size category from the dungeon bosses), and for the various unique bosses which each player only get to fight once each, such as the ones in the Amulet quest. That's a fair amount of work, for not much gain.
Peter34 wrote:But if I can paralyze a mob and get the opportunity to hit it 3 or even 5 times before it can defend itself, I'm basically going to be able to pwn anything efforlessly.
Whoops. You're right, of course; I was thinking in terms of DoT ticks going off (as in your original post) and not large single instances of damage. A level of damage mechanic like the one you mentioned earlier would indeed have to be incorporated to prevent possible abuse.
Peter34 wrote:It's certainly unlikely to lure me into spending my precious skill points on more than the first level of Ensnare. And I'd guess that after trying it out, most players would re-spect back to a single point in Ensnare, not finding it sufficiently useful to be able to ensnare larger mobs, to be worth 1 or 2 skill points.
Really? I never find it necessary to ensnare normal monsters anymore; that first point would be useful only for the early levels. In fact, I think that eventually almost everyone would put in the full three points for a nice comfortable boss routine... which would defeat your good intentions of creating a variety of viable choices. So maybe it's not a good idea on that score. :)
Peter34 wrote:Also, I am fairly certain that none of Venan's mobs are defined by any kind of Size attribute or statistic, so they'd have go to through their database and add that, for all the run-of-the-mill mobs, all the dungeon bosses (the raid bosses can just "inherit" the Size stat or Size category from the dungeon bosses), and for the various unique bosses which each player only get to fight once each, such as the ones in the Amulet quest. That's a fair amount of work, for not much gain.
This is a fair point that I hadn't considered, though I think you're overestimating the size of the job. Normal monsters wouldn't need a size attribute added, as any rank of ensnare would work on them, just as it does now; large monsters would simply be immune to ensnare rank 1, and boss monsters would be immune to ensnare rank 1 and 2. Anyway, I guess that's a technical aspect only Venan programmers themselves would be able to estimate.
Peter34 wrote:I think it's a standard game design principle. I'm no expert on AD&D, but I'd presume that one of the rules for the Sleep spell is that if the target takes any damage, the effect of the spell ends.
It was back in 2nd edition, the last one I played :) And yeah, I think it's a standard principle for most sleep/hold/freeze spells to give the target a chance at fighting back after suffering one free shot.
Peter34 wrote:There are no positions or distances in BoH, so one of the most obvious uses for a sleep/ensnare/stun ability in AD&D or WoW, to trap a mob so that you can run away from it, is irrelevant in BoH.
True, but preparation is still relevant. Trap a monster, then cast haste, vanish, and caltrops if you like, finishing up with acid spray. That's 1.05 seconds of prep time saved even at near-max haste; 0.75s at max. Same applies to mages.
Peter34 wrote:A much more general principle of game design is that good design results in players making a variety of choices, instead of all players gravitating towards the same choice.
Agreed; I'd like to see more variety in possible builds too.
Sleep spells & stun effects in DnD are broken specifically due to the pain of damage taken. What I think you guys want to think about is the Druids ensnare spell & the effects attributed to it. Pete's idea wasn't bad because he was trying to better a skill. I just didn't see an end result that held merit. That said, I'd propose changing the after effect of the skill. As of now, it locks down a creature from 3-5 secs. But of course when the creature sustains 1 point of damage it's free. This is where I feel a change/improvement to the skill would best suit all SW's.

Add an additional function to the Ensnare skill as an after affect. This after affect would decrease a creatures ability to Dodge by X% for the remainder of the time frame.

-Note- I was going to suggest an after affect like Caltrops, but then Caltrops become the next skill we have to fix.

I also felt it made sense to decrease a creatures ability to be mobile on the battle field with a net hanging off, or around them.

-shrugs- I still think the skill works fine as is, but you guys want more so that's my 2 cents.
Decreased Dodge would be nice, but one problem with that is that Ensnare itself is a Dodge-able effect. This means that even if Venan buffs Ensnare so that it has a Dodge-decreasing after-effect, it's not particularly attractive to try to Ensnare high-Dodge mobs like Ice Wraiths, Wolves or Bats, because there's a high probability that your action (opportunity cost) is wasted if the mob Dodges the Ensnare.
Peter34 wrote:even if Venan buffs Ensnare so that it has a Dodge-decreasing after-effect, it's not particularly attractive to try to Ensnare high-Dodge mobs... because there's a high probability that your action (opportunity cost) is wasted
While this is true, I still like dragonclan's suggestion in terms of "realism;" it's well-justified conceptually, and it would be useful (I suppose physical attacks are still part of a 'walker's repertoire, however little I use them).

Unfortunately it would still leave us with the original problem of how to justify investment in the skill itself beyond the first point. I suppose it could decrease dodge by an additional factor per rank, but as that would be a secondary effect, it still wouldn't make additional investment attractive.