Book of Heroes

"Hidden" Game Mechanics

Hello. I have been playing BoH and loving it for about a year now, and in that time I have been noticing that there are many game mechanics that are insufficiently explained by the game itself. Compounding this problem is that Venan seems to have taken every "familiar" MMO stat and twisted the mechanics into a new and unique shape for their game. I acknowledge that figuring these out is part of the fun, as it were, and would like to use this post to consolidate these few 'little things' here.

I state now without apology that there will be math, and lots of it, in this post, as well as in others that I reference. That said I will attempt to make the conclusions as accessible as possible.

This post is a work in progress, and despite extensive forum and in-game research there are still several mechanics that I have yet to figure out. I have marked these topics in my table of contents here. Let's use this thread for some constructive discussion and hopefully unravel some mysteries.

Table of Contents
1: Dodge/Block *Help Wanted*
2: 1h/2h damage, <element> damage
3: Armor Penetration
4: Accuracy *Help Wanted*
5: Initiative *Help Wanted*
6: Luck breakpoints

3: Miscellanious


1: Dodge and Block stacking:

It is an obvious fact that any given attach will be only ever blocked OR dodged, never both. So, on a hypothetical character wearing a light shield with 30% dodge and 12% block, how do dodge and block stack on the combat table? The answer has a large impact on the decision to use a shield in PvP. One of three things is possible:

Option 1: Dodge and block are evaluated simultaneously. If an attack is resolved by picking a random number from 1-100, Incoming attacks on the example character would result in

1-30: dodge (30% of the time)
31-42: block (12% of the time)
43-100: hit (58% of the time)

Option 2: Dodge resolves before block. In this case, two random numbers (RNs) are needed. The first decides if the attack is dodged, the second if it is dodged.

first RN:
1-30: dodge
31-100: check block
Second RN:
1-12: block
13-100: hit

This gives an actual results of
30% dodges
8.4% blocks
61.6% hits

Option 3: Block resolves before dodge. As above, we will need 2 RNs

First RN:
1-12: block
13-100: Check dodge
Second RN:
1-30: dodge
31-100: hit

Actual results:
12% blocks
26.4% dodges
61.6% hits

Theoretically, if I keep careful track of how mobs are hitting me and when, I could eventually accumulate enough data to figure out the difference. But I don't even own a shield.

2: Skill:1h/2h Damage and Magic:<Element type> Damage

These enchants are fairly self explanatory. If your attack does 1000 damage, and you have a piece of gear with 1% 1h damage (and a 1h weapon, of course), you will deal 1000*1.01= 1010 damage, which is a 1% increase. However, these enchants stack ADDITIVELY. If you have a physical attack dealing 1000 damage, a piece of gear with 1% 1h damage, and another with 1% physical damage, you will deal 2% increased damage.

There are a few passive skills that modify elemental damage types, exactly the same way as enchants do. Specifically, a Shadow Walker's Lethal Poison and a War Mage's Ice Mastery. These damage increases stack additively with these two enchant types. So a Shadow Walker with 3/3 Lethal Poison (@5% per rank) is treated like having an extra 15 levels of Nature Damage enchant. You can confirm this by checking the "Additional Details" section of your character stats. If this shadow walker deals 1000 Nature damage on a Toxic Blade before enchants and skills, then with 6% 1h damage enchants, 6% nature damage enchants, and 3/3 Lethal poison, s/he will deal (100+6+6+15=) 127% damage, or 1270 damage on the strike. This means that skilling Lethal Poison or Ice Mastery does NOT mean that you will deal 15% more damage. It means an additional 15% of BASE damage.

3: Skill: Armor Penetration

The math behind when armor penetration becomes worth more than 1h/2h damage has been thoroughly discussed in this thread: Armor Penetration versus 1/2H Dmg Enchant Statistics

To summarize, your target needs at least 55% defense mitigation to make Armor Penetration deal more damage than 1h/2h damage. This never happens in PvE, and only happens in PvP against a target who has enchanted for defense.

4: Skill: Accuracy

There are two models already in game for the Accuracy enchant. War Mage's Chilled, which subtracts directly from dodge chance, and Shadow Walker's Caltrops, which reduces dodge by a percentage. Initially, I assumed that it worked like Chilled. Unfortunately, based on my own experience testing with 7.5% accuracy and Caltrops, I would still see monsters dodge my attacks. This means that either the monster had more than 15% dodge, or accuracy enchant works like Caltrops.

If this is true, then if your opponent has 30% dodge, 7.5% accuracy will reduce that by 2.25%, giving him 27.75% instead. Accuracy is a vastly inferior option for damage compared to 1h/2h Damage.


5: Skill: Initiative
I admit it. I have no clue how initiative works. Does it increase the frequency of surprising enemies and decrease the frequency of them surprising you? Does it increase the time you get when you do surprise and reduce theirs? Both? Neither? The in-game description reads, "Increases the odds that you will surprise your opponent," so I am inclined to believe that it is the former. But I made a similar assumption about accuracy and I was totally wrong.


6: Luck Breakpoints
I am listing the 'break-even' points for different levels of the luck enchant. This is the amount of essence you would need to farm in order for the extra .5%/level of essence from the luck enchant to return the amount of essence used to enchant the gear with luck in the first place. The general formula is (Essence cost / % increase) = break even. It is important to note that it doesn't matter how many pieces of gear you enchant with luck. The break even point for two pieces of gear with a level 1 enchant is the same as one piece of gear with a level 1 enchant.

Level 1: 100/.005 = 20,000 essence
Level 2: 350/.010 = 35,000 essence
Level 3: 850/.015 = 56,667 essence **9 level 6 enchants cost 84150 essence**
Level 4: 1850/.020 = 92500 essence
Level 5: 4350/.025 = 174,000 essence
Level 6: 9350/.030 = 311,667 essence
Level 7: 19350/.035 = 552,857 essence **9 level 9 enchants cost 849,150 essence**
Level 8: 44350/.040 = 1,108,750 essence **12 level 9 enchants cost 1,132,200 essence**
Level 9: 94350/.045 = 2,096,667 essence

So, in summary, to get the most essence out of your luck enchants, if you plan on stopping at level 6, like everyone did before 2.0, then you should stop at luck level 3. Going higher will require you to farm more essence than it takes to enchant a full set of gear. Going all the way to level 9 enchants, Luck will pay for itself up to level 7. Enchanting up to luck level 8 or 9 will require more than one full set of gear enchanted. It's likely that a set of gear for pvp would make level 8 luck worth it, but luck level 9 will require 23 pieces of gear fully enchanted in order to break even.
The problem with luck in the onslaught world is that your return is typically higher from physical/ice/fire/nature/spirit enchants than luck so you don't have your luck gear on while you are collecting most of your essence.

Therefore, I doubt that level 7 is worthwhile. The question is whether level 6 is worthwhile or not from a pure essence point of view. I am running luck when silver farming though. Given the Diamond Engraver price, we need to run silver return calculations on the luck enchant as well as essence. I may do that myself when I have time.

japster

ModeratorThu Jan 9, 2014 1:39 pm
Myainsel wrote:

Table of Contents
1: Dodge/Block *Help Wanted*
2: 1h/2h damage, <element> damage
3: Armor Penetration
4: Accuracy *Help Wanted*
5: Initiative *Help Wanted*
6: Luck breakpoints

Actually most of what you're asking have already been known.

1. On dodge and block, view here. block vs crit

4. Simple. If you have 10% accuracy and the enemy has 50% dodge, the enemy now only has 45% dodge. That's how it works. The more difficult question is the accuracy enchant interaction with chilled/caltrops. Not too sure whether the flat reduction is resolved first followed by the % reduction from the enchant or vice versa.

5. I don't have a clue on this one and the devs are SUPER tight-lipped over it despite me asking several times. This is my analysis based on over 2 years of BoH experience.

How initiative works (japster's theory)

From what I understand of game mechanics, "surprise" basically means having a headstart in your timers in a fight. Every fight you enter gives you a roll to determine if you're gonna get the headstart or the opponent, and how much of a headstart/lag. I believe initiative affects the latter and not the former. I.e. initiative affects only the amount of headstart/lag in timer, instead of determining who goes first. When you obtain (by random roll every start of the fight) a certain amount of timer headstart, you basically get the "surprise" message. E.g. all rolls with a headstart in timer of 0.9s or more = surprise message.

Note that even without "surprise", you can still have a headstart on the enemies. Notice that in every fight, the headstart timer you get is different and it varies not just with each encounter, but also within multiple monsters in an encounter. Similarly, when you encounter monsters and lose the first roll (i.e. their attacks start first), each enemy has a different timer on their attack (even if both monsters are identical and using the same move).

This suggests to me that every fight, every monster/player on the field rolls separately on initiative against each other to determine how much initiative they get.

Then how is it determined who goes first? My theory is that it is resolved first by a simple roll between you versus the enemies (as a group, if more than 1 enemy is encountered). I think in PvP the chance for this roll is 50-50 while in PvE it's skewed in favor of the player. After the outcome of that roll is decided, then the game rolls again INDIVIDUALLY against each enemy to determine the initiative timer (which determines the amount of headstart if you go first, or lag if you are going last). Therefore two rounds of rolling actually occur, and initiative stat only affects the second round. Probably only the "winning" individual of the first roll will roll again in the second roll to determine how much of an initiative/headstart he gets. His initiative = your lag, so there shouldn't be a need for both sides to roll the second roll.

My theory was recently fortified by the latest 2.0 patch where the patch notes suspiciously mentioned that haste stat no longer affects initiative. If initiative referred to the first round (i.e. determining who goes first), then I simply do not see how haste should affect it unless Venan has a weird formula where haste % affects the chance of the roll. This seems unlikely. It is more probable haste difference used to affect the initiative timer, since it's pretty self-explanatory haste affects timers.

Under my theory, pre 2.0, haste would have affected timers in the past by perhaps adding/deducting whatever initiative timers you rolled. E.g You have a haste rating of 40% and you rolled the first round and lost, therefore causing you to go last. Your enemy then rolls on the initiative timer and obtains a 1second headstart on you. Your 40% haste allows you to deduct that to 0.6s. Therefore you no longer get "ambushed" by the enemy, because 0.6s is not sufficiently long to qualify for a "surprise". Still, you must wait for 0.6s before you can move.

Probably what v2.0 did was to remove the effect of haste stat while decreasing the range of rolls for the initiative roll to make up for it.

Lastly, if my theory is indeed correct, then initiative is probably worthless for PvP because in all my PvP experience of almost 2000 matches, the initiative timer never exceeds anything more than 0.2s (in fact I think my max I've encountered was 0.18s). Chances are the initiative timer range in PvP has been vastly reduced by about 60% or so thereabouts to prevent the unfortunate incidents where one enemy has a 0.8 to 1s + initiative (can you imagine the outrage in PvP if that happened?).

If that is indeed so, then the measly amount of initiative bonus by % will not do much to add to the initiative timer we roll, therefore making it useless.

TLDR version.

1. At the start of each encounter, the game rolls once to determine whether you or the enemy goes first.
2. The game then rolls again for the winner of the first roll to determine how much of an initiative in timer the winner gets.
3. The winner of the first roll gets a chance to roll on the second roll against EACH individual enemy on the battlefield.
4. The winner's initiative = the loser's lag.
5. Initiative enchant adds to the initiative timer rolled on the second roll by way of % based on your enchant level.
6. You achieve surprised status only over a certain threshold of initiative timer.
7. Initiative timer rolls in PvP have been scaled down by at least 60%.

P.S. I also will not rule the two other possible methods for initiative mechanics under my theory. Firstly, it could also affect the first roll of who goes first by a % of the initiative enchant (therefore making the enchant even better). Secondly, it could ONLY affect the first roll (therefore making the enchant even suckier).

6. Luck breakpoints. This is easy to calculate. It's just a spreadsheet. But it's also tedious to do. I'll let someone else handle this. 8-)

japster

ModeratorThu Jan 9, 2014 2:03 pm
B4Play wrote:The problem with luck in the onslaught world is that your return is typically higher from physical/ice/fire/nature/spirit enchants than luck so you don't have your luck gear on while you are collecting most of your essence.

It depends. This view isn't entirely accurate. If your dps from your rotation already far outstrips the max health of the enemy in onslaught, any further increase in damage is worthless since you're just going to be landing overkill after overkill (btw bear this principle in mind for onslaught if you truly want to achieve max kills…overkill =/= max kills; onslaught is about efficient dps, not maximum dps :roll: )

E.g., it's better to farm CoC for silver, undead ichor, and gs with luck enchant than elemental enchant if you're decked out with over 35k might.

Hence any luck breakpoint comparison versus damage enchant is going to be arbitrary without a reference to a particular combat encounter and full combat stats.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Jan 9, 2014 4:18 pm
Overview
Initiative Enchant appears to work like Luck Enchant,
+1.0s to opponent's "Waiting" (Initiative) instead of Bonus Loot Roll (Luck).

Body
japster wrote:
When you obtain (by random roll every start of the fight) a certain amount of timer headstart, you basically get the "surprise" message. E.g. all rolls with a headstart in timer of 0.9s or more = surprise message.

From my experience with a War Mage using the Initiative Enchant, it appears that there are two duration rolls in PvE. Somehow Initiative is decided. Somehow duration of "Waiting" is decided. Duration of "Waiting" appears to vary by Monster Type. Ex: a Goblin Marauder has a larger range of "Waiting" than a Goblin Master Thief. Everyone "Waiting" rolls for Surprised. Chance of rolling Surprised appears to vary by Monster Type. If the player, or any Monster, rolls Surprised, +1.0s are added to their "Waiting", similar to rolling a Critical Hit or Bonus Loot.

The Initiative Enchant appears to increase the Monster's chance of rolling Surprised and getting the +1.0s. If true, Initiative Enchant is more like Luck Enchant then Knockback Resist.
japster wrote:
Actually most of what you're asking have already been known.

I had hoped this was the case!
japster wrote:
1. On dodge and block, view here. block vs crit

That's helpful, and seems to imply the first case. Unfortunately the thread ends right when someone asks the question I really wanted to answer, for the same reason that I was interested.
japster wrote:
4. Simple. If you have 10% accuracy and the enemy has 50% dodge, the enemy now only has 45% dodge. That's how it works. The more difficult question is the accuracy enchant interaction with chilled/caltrops. Not too sure whether the flat reduction is resolved first followed by the % reduction from the enchant or vice versa.

I would assume the flat reduction comes first. When chilled by a WM in PvP, my stats screen is updated with a new dodge value, 20% less than what it used to be. I would assume that the enchant % reduction applies after that.
japster wrote:
5. I don't have a clue on this one and the devs are SUPER tight-lipped over it despite me asking several times.

***** devs.
Bj_Knows wrote:
The Initiative Enchant appears to increase the Monster's chance of rolling Surprised and getting the +1.0s. If true, Initiative Enchant is more like Luck Enchant then Knockback Resist.
If that's true, then I have high hopes for the initiative enchant, at least in a non-onslaught situation.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Jan 10, 2014 11:50 am
Subject
Initiative Enchant, Dodge Reduction, PvP Research Bouts

MY PERSONAL OPINION
Currently, I have given up on the Initiative Enchant (Note 2). Unlike other Enchants, it is most useful in Speed Raids, RPP Races and HoliGob. Currently my characters do not have enough Might Rating to win most RPP Races, especially my Shadow Walker (we will skip my Riposte vs Mob Rant).

Some of the BoH Mechanics are nearly impossible to research (v1.7.2 Snap Cast %), some require some creative thinking (Note 3) and/ or large chunks of research time, but a significant number of Mechanics can be quickly resolved with cooperation between two characters in PvP. Dodge Reduction (Note 1) would be displayed on your Stat Page during PvP (Note 5).

CJ and I used to PvP against each other (Note 4) to do research. You can even PvP versus yourself with two characters. PvP Research Bouts will be even easier to do when Venan allows Dueling (choosing an opponent).

Note 1)
Myainsel wrote:
japster wrote:
4. Simple. If you have 10% accuracy and the enemy has 50% dodge, the enemy now only has 45% dodge. That's how it works. The more difficult question is the accuracy enchant interaction with chilled/caltrops. Not too sure whether the flat reduction is resolved first followed by the % reduction from the enchant or vice versa.

I would assume the flat reduction comes first. When chilled by a WM in PvP, my stats screen is updated with a new dodge value, 20% less than what it used to be. I would assume that the enchant % reduction applies after that.

Note 2)
Myainsel wrote:
Bj_Knows wrote:
The Initiative Enchant appears to increase the Monster's chance of rolling Surprised and getting the +1.0s. If true, Initiative Enchant is more like Luck Enchant then Knockback Resist.
If that's true, then I have high hopes for the initiative enchant, at least in a non-onslaught situation.

Note 3)
Level 3 Bandit vs. Level 30, 209.37%... - RESOLVED

Note 4)
PvP: Guild Party or time based Dueling system- ARCHIVED

Note 5)
Some Mechanics , like Shadow Walker Poison (Debuff Nature Resist) and Spirit Runes (Debuff all Resists) work different in PvE (Monsters can have negative Resists, some start with negative Resists) and PvP (PvP does not allow negative Resists).

japster

ModeratorFri Jan 10, 2014 1:36 pm
Bj_Knows wrote:Overview
Initiative Enchant appears to work like Luck Enchant,
+1.0s to opponent's "Waiting" (Initiative) instead of Bonus Loot Roll (Luck).

Body
japster wrote:
When you obtain (by random roll every start of the fight) a certain amount of timer headstart, you basically get the "surprise" message. E.g. all rolls with a headstart in timer of 0.9s or more = surprise message.

From my experience with a War Mage using the Initiative Enchant, it appears that there are two duration rolls in PvE. Somehow Initiative is decided. Somehow duration of "Waiting" is decided. Duration of "Waiting" appears to vary by Monster Type. Ex: a Goblin Marauder has a larger range of "Waiting" than a Goblin Master Thief. Everyone "Waiting" rolls for Surprised. Chance of rolling Surprised appears to vary by Monster Type. If the player, or any Monster, rolls Surprised, +1.0s are added to their "Waiting", similar to rolling a Critical Hit or Bonus Loot.

The Initiative Enchant appears to increase the Monster's chance of rolling Surprised and getting the +1.0s. If true, Initiative Enchant is more like Luck Enchant then Knockback Resist.

If initiative works the way you explain (since you have it), please do try it in PvP and let us know if it works! Might be a totally useless enchant for PvP like luck :P

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jan 15, 2014 8:47 am
japster wrote:
(since you have it), please do try it in PvP and let us know if it works!

Looks like I disenchanted my Initiative Enchants to make room for Armor Penetration Enchants for SPOONS! second attempt at KFS Speed record.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jun 4, 2014 11:31 am
japster wrote:
(since you have it), please do try it in PvP and let us know if it works!

Japster,

You might want to talk to Eric and Tacita
EricM_Returns_July_2nd wrote:
fighting tacita. She's got one piece at 6 I think, and ends up letting her start anywhere from like .01-0.15 ahead of me.
Possible Bug? ( riposte)- Riposte vs Initiative