Book of Heroes

Armor Penetration versus 1/2H Dmg Enchant Statistics

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Nov 20, 2013 10:58 pm
So AP vrs 1/2H Enchants for Skill (Amber flux) items has been discussed on several occasions. Most notable in these threads:
PvP: Statistical Analysis of Burn, Chill & Enchants
PvP: Statistical Analysis of Burn, Chill & Enchants

I've been doing a lot more analysis lately for kicks and giggles and am going to release more of my math in a little bit, but I find this plot very convenient so I am throwing it up to get feedback.
The debate has always been whether or not AP makes a difference or is beneficial versus 1H and 2H enchants. Historically only considered against armor/resist mitigation of a toon, it was deemed 1H/2H is better because the break even point is ~55% defense mitigation, and only Maxed toons with resist gems barely seem to get over that point.

I actually think that the picture becomes very different if we assume that AP mitigates not only standard Defense/resists ratings, but also block, Defend and buffs such as Ice Shield (pvp), Shield Wall (GK) and Vile Guard (LoB).

Ill provide more later.

Attachments

AP_DMG_ENch_vr_DEFmitigation.png
Mithrid wrote:Shield Wall (GK) and Vile Guard (LoB).

One you get in the mid-20K might range, those two are useless. I don't even attempt to stop them from invoking them anymore.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Nov 20, 2013 11:18 pm
CarlosDanger wrote:
Mithrid wrote:Shield Wall (GK) and Vile Guard (LoB).

One you get in the mid-20K might range, those two are useless. I don't even attempt to stop them from invoking them anymore.

There is truth to that, though for the purposes of this conversation it is worth noting how much better AP would serve you than 2H/1H dmg in such cases.

The reality is very few creatures have higher than 50% defense mitigation which means AP is really only useful for PvP activities.

So it begs the question at what point do we switch to AP for PvP, from 1H/2H Dmg enchant.
Don't mean to hijack your topic here, but you can't talk about pvp without talking about accuracy. If your opponent has more than 5.66% dodge, accuracy wins over 1hDamage, until you have enough accuracy to take your opponent below 5.66% dodge. Even toons who put no focus on dodge can get far more than that. The question then becomes how many accuracy enchants should you use, since any that goes over 100% becomes useless.

Maths: accuracy vs 1h damage:
Assume a test character with 1000dps.

With 5% dodge:
dps with no enchants: 1000*.95=950
dps with 18% 1h damage: 950*1.18=1121
dps with 9% accuracy, 12% damage: 1000*1.12=1120

With 10% dodge:
dps with no enchants: 1000*.90=900
dps with 18% 1h damage: 900*1.18=1062
dps with 9% accuracy, 12% damage: 1000*.99*1.12=1108.8

with 30% dodge:
dps with no enchants: 1000*.70=700
dps with 18% 1h damage: 700*1.18=826
dps with 9% accuracy, 12% damage: 1000*.79*1.12=884.8
dps with 18% accuracy, 6% damage: 1000*.88*1.06 = 932.8
dps with 27% accuracy, 0% damage: 1000*.97 = 970

with 55% dodge:
dps with no enchants: 1000*.45=450
dps with 18% 1h damage: 450*1.18=531
dps with 9% accuracy, 12% damage: 1000*.54*1.12=604
dps with 18% accuracy, 6% damage: 1000*.63*1.06 = 667
dps with 27% accuracy, 0% damage: 1000*.72 = 720

55% may seem high, but for a Shadow Walker with 3/3 maneuver, its very possible, and a focused, maxed toon can go even higher.

That being said, I am unsure of how accuracy enchant interacts with caltrops/chilled. I have observed dodges on mobs with a 7.5% accuracy weapon while debuffed with caltrops. This leads me to conclude that the mobs have more than 15% bases dodge, which seems very high, or that I am making some mistake in assuming how they calculate.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Nov 21, 2013 12:13 am
LOL...Myainsel, so Accuracy is already the next full comparative study...have done some work on it but not complete. Lets save that for another thread. ;)
Ekko wrote:Accuracy counted as a percentage not as an absolute value. Ask Beeko if u want.

Asdfsbehzjsvzu!!!
Dammit venan.
1h/2h should be better because they are less flexible. My top justi uses 2h for most PvE, but 1h for KFS (and PvP, if I ever return). AP works reasonably well with both, but the weapons themselves use the 1h/2h enchants.
Back on topic, your graphs are close to ideal, but there is another variable to consider.

1h/2h damage enchants stack additively with Magic damage enchants of the appropriate type. Assuming a specialized character, your actual damage increase with three levels of 1h/2h will be (18/118) = 15.2%. This represents the same amount of raw damage, but a smaller percentage increase.

Armor pen enchants, however, give a larger raw damage increase if you have Magic damage enchants. I don't have the time right now to crunch numbers, but the presence of Magic damage enchants will move the tipping point in favor of armor pen. Not by much, but by a little.

Possessed_Mithrid

Tue Nov 26, 2013 11:02 pm
Myainsel wrote:Back on topic, your graphs are close to ideal, but there is another variable to consider.

1h/2h damage enchants stack additively with Magic damage enchants of the appropriate type. Assuming a specialized character, your actual damage increase with three levels of 1h/2h will be (18/118) = 15.2%. This represents the same amount of raw damage, but a smaller percentage increase.

Armor pen enchants, however, give a larger raw damage increase if you have Magic damage enchants. I don't have the time right now to crunch numbers, but the presence of Magic damage enchants will move the tipping point in favor of armor pen. Not by much, but by a little.

That is why I choose normalized damage factor. Assuming the 1H/2H stack with any other bonuses (magic gems, melee gems, dmg enchants), I can ignore those for now as I treat whatever that number is as base damaged increase by the 1H/2H enchant.

Likewise for the AP curves, they assume that that base number is what it is (includes melee and magic gems, magic dmg enchants, etc).

So, by normalizing all other factors, the plots are able to show how 1H/2H/AP damage will vary as a function of defensive/resistance (since that is what really affects AP's effectiveness)..all other factors held constant/normalized.

There are far too many variables to try and factor in absolute values, %, etc...so the normalized plot seemed to be the best approach for just studying these two enchant tradeoffs.