Book of Heroes

PvP: Statistical Analysis of Burn, Chill & Enchants

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 15, 2013 8:53 am
New Subject
PvP: Statistical Analysis of Burn, Chill & Enchants

OLD Subject
PvP: Ignite 75% proc Fire DOT

[speaking Navy Sailor dialect]@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~[returning to Civilian DOD dialect]

How can a War Mage go an entire PvP match with no Burn? not even a single Resisted Burn? For 3 PvP matches in a row?! Because War Mages have no 100% DOT like Wound rank 1 (100% proc Bleed DOT), Caltrop rank 1-3 (100% proc Physical DOT) or Poison Cloud (100% proc Nature DOT).

Also, a majority of War Mage attacks cannot proc Ignite (and a Fire DOT), even if the War Mage wants them, unlike Rend (Physical DOT) and Corrosive Blades (Nature Debuff increases Nature DOT damage) which proc from any class attack.

Class attack *does* not proc Ignite (0% proc)
--Basic Attack
--Staff Attack
--Frozen Shard rank 1-3 (100% proc Chill Stack 1, max Stack 1, 100% proc Deep Freeze Chill bonus)
--Ice Storm rank 1-3 (100% proc Chill Stack 1, max Stack 1, 100% proc Deep Freeze Chill bonus)
--Ice Lance rank 1-3

Versus

Class attack does proc Ignite (100% proc)
--Incinerate rank 1-3
--Flaming Pyre rank 1-3
--Fire Blast rank 1-3

Even if an attack does proc Ignite, Ignite rank 3 only has a 75% of proccing Burn, making it almost impossible to get a Burn Stack 3 in a PvP match and often no Burn Stack 2 and sometimes no Burn at all, while Justicars often get a Bleed Stack 3 and Shadow Walkers often get a Poison Stack 3. If the PvP opponent successfully Resists (Defend and/ or Status Resist Enchant) one of these Ignite successes, you will never get a Burn Stack 2.



I am suggesting a two part change.

Flaming Pyre (Group Attack)
Rank 1 has a 0% chance to proc Fire DOT (no chance, good for Ice Mages and Mobs)
Rank 2 has a 50% chance to proc Fire DOT (low chance for Ice Mages)
Rank 3 has a 100% chance to proc Fire DOT (certain chance for Fire Mage fighting Mobs similar to Chill and Ice Storm for an Ice Mage)

Ignite (100% procced by Fire Spells)
Rank 1 has a 70% chance to proc Fire DOT
Rank 2 has a 85% chance to proc Fire DOT
Rank 3 has a 100% chance to proc Fire DOT

Note: This means Ignite rank p3+ Flaming Pyre rank 3= Fire DOT Stack 2 which is the same Damage Per Second as Caltrop rank 3 (Physical DOT) or Poison Cloud rank 3 (Nature DOT)

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Aug 15, 2013 2:28 pm
BJ has just brought up a point that has irked me for a while...probability related to DOT effects.

See a Justi has Rend, and SW have Poison Cloud, Poisoned (corrosive blade, acid, toxic) and Caltrops.

The probability for Justi DOT and SW DOT effects are much more effective than a WM. Granted, Poisoned isn't DOT but it definitely can easily stack yielding a 45% reduced resistance. (Don't even get me started on Chilled versus Caltrops which are not only more effective at slowing but also a DOT).

But lets talk probabilities of DOT...the WM's only DOT is burning, with only two events (incinerate and fireblast, ignoring flaming pyre as its not a smart investment, nor effective for PvP) that have a probability to proc, and even then only with ignite.

Lets see how the probabilities stack up. Example:

first four attacks in a round, all sequential, none repeated:

Justi, one of the 4 is wound, and Rend is at 3.

Bleed 1x: 100%
Bleed 2x: 87.5%
Bleed 3x: 75%
Bleed 4x: 37.5%

Compare that to a Mage, Ignite is L3, only physically possible for 2 of the 4 to proc ignite. (note I am going to ignore flaming pyre as mentioned, bad for PvP).
Burning 1X: 93.75%
Burning 2x: 56.25%
Burning 3x: impossible
Burning 4x: impossible

See where as a Justi within his first 4 attacks has an 75% chance of maxing his 3x bleed stack, a WM is 50-50 on a 2x...even then the Justi is nearly as guaranteed a 2X stack as the WM is a 1x.

Funny thing is IM with BJ as well in that I have had several battles where statistically my Burn didn't proc after 3-5 fire attacks...that makes me question the accuracy of the 75% ignite I'm invested in.

Sure WM have chilled, but it is not incredibly effective compared to, nor does it have a DOT such as caltrops.

I like BJ's suggestions, Ive also wondered if an alternative was to have chilled add a form of DOT damage as well...though by doing that you force a WM to split enchant between Fire and Ice damage for DOT, though SW already have that dilemma between Nature and Physical.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Aug 16, 2013 9:52 am
Subject
Accuracy, Deep Freeze & Chill vs Spell Dodge, Riposte
Mithrid wrote:
Sure WM have chilled, but it is not incredibly effective compared to, nor does it have a DOT such as caltrops.

With no Frost Runes in PvP, one cool techinque is to spend 24 Amber Flux and 2550 Essence on Accuracy Rank 3 for Tier 9- 14 Helm, Gloves and Sword. This is 50% as effective as Rank 6 for 9% of the Materials. With Deep Freeze rank p1- 3 (Chill increased 5%)+ Chill (15%)+ Accuracy 13.5= -33.5% to both Hasste *and* Dodge. If your Shadow Walker opponent has Dodge 33.5% or less, no Spell Dodge so no Riposte when your Ice Lance or Fire Blast hits.

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Aug 16, 2013 1:03 pm
That is an interesting consideration BJ...my tradeoff would be sacrificing 17% 1H damage bonus however...I would have to consider if the number of attacks being dodged, that I could recover with accuracy, are doing more damage then the current 17% boost I get for every damage attack that lands...
But it's not a 17% reduction in damage. It's additive with Magic enchants. Going from 136% to 118% is only a 13.2% reduction in damage.

Furthermore, you don't have to drop all 3 1h/2h enchants for dodge. Dropping only 1 will drop you down to 130 damage, or -4.4%. What will a rank 6 dodge get you?

Assuming your opponent has 35% dodge, minus 20 from chilled/deep freeze, you will reduce his dodge from 15% to 6%, increasing your effective damage from 85% to 94%, a 10.5% increase. Against a shadow walker with maneuver and 50% dodge, you go from 70% to 79% damage, or 12.8% more damage.

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Aug 16, 2013 6:16 pm
Myainsel,
Your approach at analysis, while correct for a specific example, makes several assumptions.
Say for instance I have no other magic enchant/damage bonuses, or they are very low, which is typical in PvP because health is a much more valuable Gem investment then magic bonus.

So right off the bat, your 13.2% reduction in damage is an assumption...yes it may not be 17% but it may still be much higher than 13.2%.

Also, you assume they have a chilled effect...which they may or may not, so your 15 to 6% drop is an example, and one analytical point out of many many considerations.

Your final example is for a SW running 50% dodge, but what if I am fighting a Justi with no dodge invested, and if I chill them its already reduced to near zero...now I sacrificed my only damage bonus for no gain due to accuracy.

My point then is yes, you are correct in that there are specific examples where it may be an improvement, but I see more examples where it will not be an improvement.

And that is the tradeoff that I have to balance...I need to consider the exchange in light of the gaussian distribution of my opponents, not a few specific examples. I also have to consider it in light of my own build where I am running little to no damage bonus besides my 1H enchant.

japster

ModeratorFri Aug 16, 2013 7:14 pm
Bj_DWR wrote:Subject
Accuracy, Deep Freeze & Chill vs Spell Dodge, Riposte
Mithrid wrote:
Sure WM have chilled, but it is not incredibly effective compared to, nor does it have a DOT such as caltrops.

With no Frost Runes in PvP, one cool techinque is to spend 24 Amber Flux and 2550 Essence on Accuracy Rank 3 for Tier 9- 14 Helm, Gloves and Sword. This is 50% as effective as Rank 6 for 9% of the Materials. With Deep Freeze rank p1- 3 (Chill increased 5%)+ Chill (15%)+ Accuracy 13.5= -33.5% to both Hasste *and* Dodge. If your Shadow Walker opponent has Dodge 33.5% or less, no Spell Dodge so no Riposte when your Ice Lance or Fire Blast hits.

From what I understand about the mechanics, this is not how accuracy enchant works. If it did work this way, I would enchant accuracy in a heartbeat.

It isn't a direct subtraction. I did ask Mike a long time ago and his explanation for accuracy enchant went this way.

If player A has 50% dodge, and player B has accuracy enchant that improves accuracy by 25%, then when player B attacks player A, player A's dodge is reduced by 25%. I.e. player A will have 37.5% dodge (0.5*0.75).

Unless someone else has a direct source that explains accuracy enchant mechanics, I think this understanding is the accurate one ;)

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Aug 16, 2013 8:02 pm
Honestly Japster,
I have never been entirely clear on exactly how accuracy is applied. So I will use your approach as described here.

I question too if we understand how armor penetration is applied as the general understanding results in AP being vastly underpowered (though in my test cases using it, they seem to confirm it's inferiority...but thats a very limited set of test cases). --I'm thinking of AP here having just read your post on the PvP thread.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Aug 18, 2013 6:11 am
Mithrid wrote:That is an interesting consideration BJ...my tradeoff would be sacrificing 17% 1H damage bonus however...I would have to consider if the number of attacks being dodged, that I could recover with accuracy, are doing more damage then the current 17% boost I get for every damage attack that lands...

The problem for War Mages is if Riposte triggers, it negates the advantage of both Burn (DOT) and Chill (Haste Debuff). It is possible for a lucky Shadow Walker to attack twice for every one War Mage attack, one fast attack before yours, then one simultaneously with Riposte, than repeat. With a couple of lucky rolls, I destroyed a fellow Shadow Walker that way. He kept Reflexive Striking which kept giving me 0.16 second Piercing Strikes when I Riposted.

Accuracy is also useful against high Dodge War Mages and Justicars.

The advantage with 1H damage is it always works, against everyone.
Some players are experimenting with mixing Enchants. Ex: 1H Damage Rank 6 on Weapon, Accuracy Rank 6 on Gloves, and one or the other on Helm.

I have a lot of Knight Valor, so I am enchanting several sets of items to Rank 3 to test PvP. Especially with Gloves, even a Tier 9 (Silver Coin) items does not effect my Stats much (Note A).

Since this is Beta PvP, it will be interesting if one of the PvP consumables is equal to a Major Frost Rune (improved Chill).

Note A)
Bj_DWR wrote:
Note 2)
This unpublished Draft compares swapping T14 Luck Gear (useful against Bosses with Treasure Chest) with T12 Poison Gear (useful for Poison Cloud against Mobs). The current conclusion is due to diminishing returns, not much difference between two sets of gear for main Stats, but a +9% Nature Bonus Damage (3* Nature Damage rank 3 Enchant). With this Gear, the character uses T12 Poison Gear versus Mobs, then switches for T14 Luck Gear just before combat with a Dungeon Boss. Either Manually switching 3 items, or using Spec 2.

Gems in T14 Amulet/ T12 Amulet
Crit
Haste
Magic
Phys Resist

Gems in T15 Ring/ T12 Ring
Crit
Dodge
Magic
Magic Resist

Gems in T14 Cloak/ T12 Cloak
Defense
Crit Power
Dodge
Haste
Melee

total Stat T14/ Stat 12 (difference in Stat)
Defense 22.16%/ 21.47% (-0.69%)
Crit 35.33%/ 34.61% (-0.72%)
Crit Power 179.37%/ 179.21% (-0.16%)
Dodge 48.61%/ 47.86% (-0.75%)
Haste 37.13%/ 36.71% (-0.58%)
Magic 847 Bonus/ 832 (-15)
Magic Resist 36.0% Mitigation/ 35.04% (-0.96%)
Melee 796 Bonus/ 793 (-3)
Phys Resist 28.99% Mitigation/ 27.94% (-1.05%)
Offhand Upgrade? Tier 10 Dagger upgrade

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Aug 18, 2013 6:22 am
Subject
Enchant Research
Mithrid wrote:
I have never been entirely clear on exactly how accuracy is applied. So I will use your approach as described here.

I question too if we understand how armor penetration is applied as the general understanding results in AP being vastly underpowered (though in my test cases using it, they seem to confirm it's inferiority...but thats a very limited set of test cases). --I'm thinking of AP here having just read your post on the PvP thread.

MY PERSONAL OPINION
My feelings on Enchant Stats in the game:
[speaking Navy Sailor dialect]@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~[returning to Civilian DOD dialect]

BoH is fairly opaque from a research/ testing point of view (adding cool down to Defend has made it much worse). Enchants may as well be Real World Magic or Lottery. If I could Duel a specific character, that may or may not help.

I am currently working on a Armor Piercing versus 1H/ 2H Damage article, and it is driving me bonkers. Though I am getting good data on Crit Power as affected by opponent's Level.

P.S. Mithrid, due to Real World Realities about how players choose Enchants and participate in Raids (note 1), most Monsters have zero Mitigation against attacks and instead have varying HP. Current research shows Armor Penetration is useless in PvE except for the free TVal rank 6, which I will Disenchant when upgrading to Tier 16 (not yet available).

Note 1)
Bj_DWR wrote:
Nevla wrote:
2. Does Armor Penetration work for magic attacks or just for melee? Or: is Armor Penetration of any value to a mage?

Armor Penetration is useful for a Fire Mage when fighting a Fire Resistant Creature and an Ice Mage when fighting an Ice Resistant Creature. It is useful for Fire/ Ice Mages when fighting both Fire Resistant and Ice Resistant Creatures. Due to the lack of Fire Resistant and Ice Resistant Creatures in Captian Valor Raids, and enchants are aimed at Tier 14 Gear, Armor Penetration is less popular than other enchants. If Venan allows characters to store items they are not carrying, this may change in the future.