japster wrote:
I trust maths, and from calculations, AP breaks even only around 60% overall damage reduction. And increases ever so marginally.
This means that instantly, AP is weaker than damage enchant as long as the enemy does not use defense enchant since there's simply no way to reach the breakpoint without defense.
Armor Penetration (AP) is definitely a PvP enchant, but what if it is aimed at War Mages who always do damage?
"Armor Penetration causes a portion of your damage to overcome enemy defenses" may be refering to Spell Block and Spell Dodge. If I do 100 points of Spell Damage, and they Block or Dodge for 50 points then Damage Mitigate for 30% (lets through 70% of damage), so down to 35 damage or 0.35 points inflicted per 1 point rolled. What if Armor Penetration lets 0.8% of damage ignore all defenses. If the War Mage has 3 items at Rank 3 for 7.2% Armor Penetration. Then 7 point for Armor Penetration is always allowed through, 93 remaining points goes down to 46 for Spell Block/ Dodge to 32 points for Damage Mitigation plus the 7 points already through for Armor Penetration equals 39 or 0.39 points inflicted per 1 point rolled. Versus 0.3815 for the same Ranks in 2H Damage (or less depending on how Venan rounds Damage fractions). In fact, the more Defense Ranks the opponent has, the better Armor Penetration gets.
The Math is even better if Armor Penetration ignores Defend's 50% Damage reduction.
Regardless, I still think Armor Penetration is a poor choice for an Enchantment, but the 0.8% would make a little more sense.