Bj_DWR wrote:Subject
Enchant Research
MY PERSONAL OPINION
My feelings on Enchant Stats in the game:
[speaking Navy Sailor dialect]@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~[returning to Civilian DOD dialect]
BoH is fairly opaque from a research/ testing point of view (adding cool down to Defend has made it much worse). Enchants may as well be Real World Magic or Lottery. If I could Duel a specific character, that may or may not help.
I am currently working on a Armor Piercing versus 1H/ 2H Damage article, and it is driving me bonkers. Though I am getting good data on Crit Power as affected by opponent's Level.
P.S. Mithrid, due to Real World Realities about how players choose Enchants and participate in Raids (note 1), most Monsters have zero Mitigation against attacks and instead have varying HP. Current research shows Armor Penetration is useless in PvE except for the free TVal rank 6, which I will Disenchant when upgrading to Tier 16 (not yet available).
So BJ, here you have nailed exactly what makes aspects of BoH so infuriating and yet at the same time so amazingly interesting and engaging as a game.
It is very difficult to understand exactly how many of the mechanics are executed because there are so many many variable. For someone who spent months modeling many aspects of the game, I have since given up on trying to build exact models and now treat much of it as a blackbox using crude approximations. A challenging aspect of the enchants as well is that many of them are counter to many others...so as pointed out in this thread, Accuracy works great against HIGH Dodge opponents, but against an opponent who forgoes dodge for defense, would AP work better or Damage? And I wish I could choose whether to use physical resist or magical resist against specific opponents but I cant with random matching...Tiffy made me laugh, I made a comment in PvP and she noted "Miths on PvP, better load up on Magic resist gems" ..if I KNEW I was fighting Tiffy, I would go high dodge, but high dodge actually hurts me against Matues and John who do as much or more damage against me with backswings...
...much of the common debates about "which enchant is better"is a misapplication...the reality is different enchants will help you differently against different opponents. So where as in many one-dimensional games, where it can become easy to pin down the most ideal build or strategy...BoH is infuriating because of the so many factors that can change the effectiveness of any given strategy or build...which is why I am still playing this game despite periodic frustrations...it is completely engaging and I still stand by the position that PvP is incredibly strategic.
Yes, AP is pretty useless in PvE. I do agree there. I havent determined how effective it is in PvP though, as when I did test with it, I didn't do to well...however its hard to say if my opponents during those specific tests just didn't have the defensive builds needed, that would have made it more effective. To your point about testing on specific and known opponents.
Now.. Back to DOT...