Book of Heroes

PvP: Statistical Analysis of Burn, Chill & Enchants · page 2

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Aug 18, 2013 3:33 pm
Bj_DWR wrote:Subject
Enchant Research

MY PERSONAL OPINION
My feelings on Enchant Stats in the game:
[speaking Navy Sailor dialect]@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~@!$#^%*&~[returning to Civilian DOD dialect]

BoH is fairly opaque from a research/ testing point of view (adding cool down to Defend has made it much worse). Enchants may as well be Real World Magic or Lottery. If I could Duel a specific character, that may or may not help.

I am currently working on a Armor Piercing versus 1H/ 2H Damage article, and it is driving me bonkers. Though I am getting good data on Crit Power as affected by opponent's Level.

P.S. Mithrid, due to Real World Realities about how players choose Enchants and participate in Raids (note 1), most Monsters have zero Mitigation against attacks and instead have varying HP. Current research shows Armor Penetration is useless in PvE except for the free TVal rank 6, which I will Disenchant when upgrading to Tier 16 (not yet available).

So BJ, here you have nailed exactly what makes aspects of BoH so infuriating and yet at the same time so amazingly interesting and engaging as a game.
It is very difficult to understand exactly how many of the mechanics are executed because there are so many many variable. For someone who spent months modeling many aspects of the game, I have since given up on trying to build exact models and now treat much of it as a blackbox using crude approximations. A challenging aspect of the enchants as well is that many of them are counter to many others...so as pointed out in this thread, Accuracy works great against HIGH Dodge opponents, but against an opponent who forgoes dodge for defense, would AP work better or Damage? And I wish I could choose whether to use physical resist or magical resist against specific opponents but I cant with random matching...Tiffy made me laugh, I made a comment in PvP and she noted "Miths on PvP, better load up on Magic resist gems" ..if I KNEW I was fighting Tiffy, I would go high dodge, but high dodge actually hurts me against Matues and John who do as much or more damage against me with backswings...

...much of the common debates about "which enchant is better"is a misapplication...the reality is different enchants will help you differently against different opponents. So where as in many one-dimensional games, where it can become easy to pin down the most ideal build or strategy...BoH is infuriating because of the so many factors that can change the effectiveness of any given strategy or build...which is why I am still playing this game despite periodic frustrations...it is completely engaging and I still stand by the position that PvP is incredibly strategic.

Yes, AP is pretty useless in PvE. I do agree there. I havent determined how effective it is in PvP though, as when I did test with it, I didn't do to well...however its hard to say if my opponents during those specific tests just didn't have the defensive builds needed, that would have made it more effective. To your point about testing on specific and known opponents.

Now.. Back to DOT... :D

japster

ModeratorMon Aug 19, 2013 10:56 am
Mithrid wrote:
Yes, AP is pretty useless in PvE. I do agree there. I havent determined how effective it is in PvP though, as when I did test with it, I didn't do to well...however its hard to say if my opponents during those specific tests just didn't have the defensive builds needed, that would have made it more effective. To your point about testing on specific and known opponents.

Now.. Back to DOT... :D

From a DoT thread, now it's on AP enchant, after Accuracy enchant lol. But I insist to continue the digression here.

I trust maths, and from calculations, AP breaks even only around 60% overall damage reduction. And increases ever so marginally.

This means that instantly, AP is weaker than damage enchant as long as the enemy does not use defense enchant since there's simply no way to reach the breakpoint without defense.

A justicar with full defense enchant + max hero training (of either phys or mag resist) + max gems of corresponding resist will equate to a 69% damage reduction in either melee or magic.

A sw with full defense enchant + max hero training (of either phys or mag resist) + max gems of corresponding resist will equate to a 66% damage reduction in either melee or magic.

A wm with full defense enchant + max hero training (of either phys or mag resist) + max gems of corresponding resist will equate to a 65% damage reduction in either melee or magic.

At damage reduction 69% (justicar), armor penetration at max level (14.4%) provides approximately 44 more damage per 1000 damage dealt than damage enchant at max level (18%).

At damage reduction 66% (sw), armor penetration at max level (14.4%) provides approximately 34 more damage per 1000 damage dealt than damage enchant at max level (18%).

At damage reduction 65% (wm), armor penetration at max level (14.4%) provides approximately 31 more damage per 1000 damage dealt than damage enchant at max level (18%).

Honestly, that's not very satisfactory, since not all opponents will be geared this heavily into defense, and generally most opponents, if we take an average (sw with a light shield with moderate resists), would be hovering around the 40% overall damage reduction (assuming they do not have defense enchant and have 15% phys/mag resist, which is a balanced average).

Even if we think the whole world will use defense enchant, once again using the sw with a light shield as the average, the damage reduction of such a toon would be around 62%. This translates to AP dealing about 21 more damage per 1000 damage dealt.

That's a HUGE opportunity cost for such small gains, and the enchant has absolutely ZERO pve utility compared to damage enchant.

Also we're being very generous to assume that most players would have 15% phys/mag resist to begin with, because we all know that's a luxury stat that most people do not spend hero training tokens on until they reach end game might (28k onwards). Chances are their resist are closer to the 7-9% region just based on blue gems and minimal hero training. This makes armor penetration even more worthless since they are even further from the breakpoint.

Some points to explore AP's usefulness include, it's interaction against a WM's ice shield as well as defend status during pvp. Armor penetration WOULD interact against the enemy's gained damage reduction, because defend and ice shield actually increases phys and mag resist stat when it is active, thus armor penetration should interact with this. I'm unwilling to test the true effectiveness of armor penetration in PvP just because of this ONE possible saving grace, simply due to opportunity cost for enchant mats. I welcome anyone who has full 3*level 6 armor penetration enchant to do some testing for me on this.

On other hand, with regards to block, I don't think armor penetration is factored in at all once an attack is blocked. But I think neither is damage enchant, but I can't be sure on this. Even then, if both damage and armor penetration are nullified by block, this becomes a neutral factor.

Another point that AP might actually be worth it, is how it interacts with crit damage. If armor penetration is calculated first to determine the damage of a base hit after all defensive calculations are made, THEN crit multiplier is added into the equation AFTER the defensive calculations are done, armor penetration would make crits hurt alot more. On the other hand if armor penetration is only calculated AFTER crit damage multipliers have been factored in, then it's once again useless. As I am unsure on how exactly crit damage is calculated vis-a-vis defense, I am unsure if armor penetration would become powerful in such a scenario or not. If armor penetration does interact favorably with crit, then SW may want to consider it since they are the only class that has a high enough crit rate in PvP to properly capitalize on this advantage.

TLDR: Stick with damage enchants unless Venan somehow buffs armor penetration or nerfs damage enchant.

Suggestion: Armor penetration would be more viable if they boosted it to 1.5% per level. That would make absolute sense since it should just be a natural counter to the defense enchant! It could also be made to somehow interact against block.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Aug 19, 2013 11:42 am
japster wrote:
From a DoT thread, now it's on AP enchant, after Accuracy enchant lol. But I insist to continue the digression here.

I trust maths, and from calculations, AP breaks even only around 60% overall damage reduction. And increases ever so marginally.

I have fixed the Subject Topic :D

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Aug 21, 2013 4:54 pm
Japster,
I think your analysis is spot on....here is a food for thought as well...it would only take your opponent not using 1 gear of Defense enchant for say Status resist or Knockback to bring the % low enough where AP is no longer beneficial...as you say it is an extremely rare toon then against which AP seems viable.

So this is something I have always wondered about...do we just not understand how AP interacts with the mechanics OR did Venan seriously overlooked AP effectiveness and if they did, they had to have recognized it by now...so why haven't they tweaked it?

I wish I knew the answer to this...



On a side note...I would like to point out that I am still extremely frustrated with Ignite/Burn proc.
Routinely I will hit the target with 3 fire spells that fail to proc...the % just seem off to me....I wish I was tracking this stat better.

japster

ModeratorThu Aug 22, 2013 9:09 am
Mithrid wrote:Japster,
I think your analysis is spot on....here is a food for thought as well...it would only take your opponent not using 1 gear of Defense enchant for say Status resist or Knockback to bring the % low enough where AP is no longer beneficial...as you say it is an extremely rare toon then against which AP seems viable.

So this is something I have always wondered about...do we just not understand how AP interacts with the mechanics OR did Venan seriously overlooked AP effectiveness and if they did, they had to have recognized it by now...so why haven't they tweaked it?

I wish I knew the answer to this...



On a side note...I would like to point out that I am still extremely frustrated with Ignite/Burn proc.
Routinely I will hit the target with 3 fire spells that fail to proc...the % just seem off to me....I wish I was tracking this stat better.

One of my believes is that the reason why armor penetration and accuracy enchant (both are terrible in terms of opportunity cost, compared to damage enchant) are weak is because they are "free" recipes and are gotten easily. On the other hand damage enchant needs to be farmed or bought from black market. Thus Venan decided to make the free recipes relatively useless compared to the damage enchants.

AND YES, IGNITE PROC NEEDS A 100% RATE...or change incinerate to let it always have a chance to put burning even without ignite.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 22, 2013 11:23 am
Subject
War Mages can be tough
japster wrote:
AND YES, IGNITE PROC NEEDS A 100% RATE...or change incinerate to let it always have a chance to put burning even without ignite.

and
In PvP Chat,
Bj_DWR wrote:

Ow, Ow, Ow Lovebucket(KayJayWon), when you got Burn Stack 3, I was sweating!

Except for the fact that Poison Cloud cannot be Dodged and has 100% proc Nature DOT, I would withdrawal my suggetion of 100% Ignite. As it is, I am now on the fence (75%? or 100%?) having fought some really tough War Mages.

Possessed_Mithrid

Thu Aug 22, 2013 11:32 am
Bj_DWR wrote:

Except for the fact that Poison Cloud cannot be Dodged and has 100% proc Nature DOT, I would withdrawal my suggetion of 100% Ignite. As it is, I am now on the fence (75%? or 100%?) having fought some really tough War Mages.

I won't argue BJ that there are a few tough WM, but there are a considerably higher number of tough to impossible Justi and SW by comparison, for a WM.

As for Burn, when compared to poison stack or bleed, both of which proc on almost any attack and ergo stack faster, also having at least one 100% proc attack, and readily do more damage (bleed anyway).... I think burn proc could use some sort of boost and actually improve balance.
Mithrid wrote:

there are a considerably higher number of tough to impossible Justi and SW by comparison, for a WM.

I'm curious who are these mysterious impossible justies;) surely not mine as u beaten him quite a lot just like tiffy and almost everyone with high might toon and good pvp build

Possessed_Mithrid

Fri Aug 23, 2013 2:25 am
john12345 wrote:

I'm curious who are these mysterious impossible justies;) surely not mine as u beaten him quite a lot just like tiffy and almost everyone with high might toon and good pvp build

I'm Speaking for all the mages that can't beat you, Matues or Tiffy... Ie 99.99999% of them. ;)

1 or 2 others is an anamolie and don't count. :)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Aug 24, 2013 9:47 am
Subject
Fire and Ice Mages
Mithrid wrote:
As for Burn, when compared to poison stack or bleed, both of which proc on almost any attack and ergo stack faster, also having at least one 100% proc attack, and readily do more damage (bleed anyway).... I think burn proc could use some sort of boost and actually improve balance.

As an opponent, the problem I have with Ignite is Chill. With Defend having a 0.5 sec cool down, I have to choose between all Ice Attacks having Chill + Deep Freeze rank p1- 3, which reduces my Dodge *and* Haste by -20% or Fire Attacks which can proc a Burn Stack. On Thursday, I was demolished by War Mage who managed to get me with both Debuffs very early in the match.

I conceed that since 1.0 was released in the US, it has been tough to build a good War Mage. It seems to be the most difficult class to master.