Book of Heroes

Blessing of Stamina

Let's take a look at the math.
(Full disclosure: I haven't actually used the blessing yet myself, but this is how it looks to me.)

What it does:
Energy regenerates 20% faster; ie, 2 points every 4 minutes, instead of 2 points every 5 minutes. Thus, at 15 ticks per hour, that makes it 30 energy gained instead of 24, or 6 extra points. So, over the 12-hour duration, we gain a total of 72 extra points of energy, assuming constant regeneration (an energy bar that is always less than full). So far so good.

Now, when is extra energy most often needed? During raids, of course. During solo play you can just go do something else when you run out of energy; there is no urgency. However, the longest raids are only 6 hours long, and I imagine that even the late-game raids are done under that time, and don't go right up to the wire (I'm only up to Overseer so far, but that finishes in 4 hours and change). That means only 36 extra points of energy, at maximum, would be gained over the course of a 6 hour raid - possibly as little as 24.

But this gain would be split over all three phases; therefore, it wouldn't do much for the RPP bonus. Buying energy directly for shields at the best rate gives a conversion of 3 energy per shield, and all the extra energy can be used in a single phase for maximum RPP gain. You'd need to play for over 5 hours and 4 minutes before the cost/benefit ratios began to favor the blessing over the direct purchase of energy. As established earlier, though, the RPP bonus would still be a consideration even if you did.

In sum, the blessing doesn't seem to be worth the cost. If the duration were halved and the energy regeneration increased to +40%, it'd make more sense. As it is, I'll try it out next time my guild has a 6 hour raid, but I'm not expecting much return on investment.

Thoughts?

[Update: see below.]
Update: I tried the blessing today and it worked exactly as I surmised it would above, with all concomitant shortcomings.
Marney wrote:Let's take a look at the math.
(Full disclosure: I haven't actually used the blessing yet myself, but this is how it looks to me.)

What it does:
Energy regenerates 20% faster; ie, 2 points every 4 minutes, instead of 2 points every 5 minutes. Thus, at 15 ticks per hour, that makes it 30 energy gained instead of 24, or 6 extra points. So, over the 12-hour duration, we gain a total of 72 extra points of energy, assuming constant regeneration (an energy bar that is always less than full). So far so good.

Now, when is extra energy most often needed? During raids, of course. During solo play you can just go do something else when you run out of energy; there is no urgency. However, the longest raids are only 6 hours long, and I imagine that even the late-game raids are done under that time, and don't go right up to the wire (I'm only up to Overseer so far, but that finishes in 4 hours and change). That means only 36 extra points of energy, at maximum, would be gained over the course of a 6 hour raid - possibly as little as 24.

But this gain would be split over all three phases; therefore, it wouldn't do much for the RPP bonus. Buying energy directly for shields at the best rate gives a conversion of 3 energy per shield, and all the extra energy can be used in a single phase for maximum RPP gain. You'd need to play for over 5 hours and 4 minutes before the cost/benefit ratios began to favor the blessing over the direct purchase of energy. As established earlier, though, the RPP bonus would still be a consideration even if you did.

In sum, the blessing doesn't seem to be worth the cost. If the duration were halved and the energy regeneration increased to +40%, it'd make more sense. As it is, I'll try it out next time my guild has a 6 hour raid, but I'm not expecting much return on investment.

Thoughts?

Bonus RPP is capped at 150. You should get to max bonus with a single full energy burn (if not then you should buy your squire, soldier and hero token upgrades as well as possibly the cheapy shield upgrade) so the RPP bonus is doesn't really make much difference in whether this blessing is good or bad. I maintain it still probably isn't worth it. I actually misread it as 40% for some reason and thought it was good. As the other blessing, it just doesn't pay out. Shields are better spend on gems rather than durdling with RPP and blessings that give you minimal return.
Meian wrote:Bonus RPP is capped at 150. You should get to max bonus with a single full energy burn (if not then you should buy your squire, soldier and hero token upgrades as well as possibly the cheapy shield upgrade) so the RPP bonus is doesn't really make much difference in whether this blessing is good or bad.
Actually, it does; the point I was making was that the extra energy generated by the blessing would be spread out over several phases. The bonus is reset when you start a new phase, and regardless of whether or not you eventually reach the cap in each phase, energy expended when you are at the cap is more efficient in generating RPP than energy spent to reach the cap.

I'm not trying to say that RPP is vital, or even worth shield expenditure; I'm only making the point that RPP is less efficiently generated by the energy gained from this blessing than by spending shields to buy energy directly.
One thing that would benefit me from buying the blessing of stamina would be the feat of purchasing 20 blessings...
I have to reassess my evaluation of this blessing in light of the fact that I'm now doing more than one raid a day. In that context, with over 5 hours and 4 minutes of gametime (not necessarily gameplay, of course) in which energy regeneration is a factor, it does indeed become cost-effective. Of course, I made that caveat in my initial post - I just wasn't in a situation at the time for it to affect my first impressions. I now use the stamina blessing pretty much routinely, and it is decidedly helpful.