Book of Heroes

How to Shadow Walker- ARCHIVE · page 2

I have to agree that using garotte immediately after smoke bomb is misunderstanding how to work the skills. Obviously you use it later in your sequence when the pushback would be useful.

Vs mobs my sequence is:

Smoke Bomb, Vanish, Acid Spray, Poison cloud... and they're usually all dead. Mop up if necessary.

Vs Boss:

Caltrops, Smoke Bomb, Vanish, Acid Spray, Poison Cloud, Toxic Blade... and by that time if the Boss is still around I need to check his timer to see how much time I still have to act.

I keep a point in reflexive strike, and only use 2 in smokebomb. I never felt the extra .25 seconds mattered enough for the 3rd point, especially as I am now 50% haste without Dark Lunge. RS can still do over 900 damage even with just one point in it.

Garotte I use it only when I reach a certain point in the Boss cycle (between .75 and .4 seconds). At 0.65 I can use garotte and still ensnare if it fails to push back, but at 0.4 I use Reflexive strike and then ensnare. If I have 0.75 seconds I can get in a regular Toxic Blade or Piercing Strike before the ensnare. btw, didn't Garotte used to have an 80% chance of resetting the enemy timer?

It's very handy that 1 GS for a skill reset is no longer using up a limited resource, so I started with Dark Lunge but cut it back each time I didn't need the full buff to put the spare points elsewhere.

It's a shame Caltrops is in the original 4 skills, it is intended as a mob slow effect but is replaced by smokebomb later on, and yet you have to have a point in it. Mages have the same problem wiith their defense spell, nobody at lvl 25 is using it (at least nobody I know) so it's a wasted point.

I like the Justicer class best, so I may write a quick guide to the system I use. I equip 1-h sword for speed, and I know many people prefer 2-h axe for damage, so I'd be sure to have a lot of disagrement.
I always use Caltrops after Smoke Bomb, it makes the pushback even bigger.

I always start fights with Smoke Bomb, Caltrops, Vanish, Acid Spray. Then Poison Cloud if I'm fighting mobs or Toxic Blade vs. a boss.
Targos wrote:I always use Caltrops after Smoke Bomb, it makes the pushback even bigger.

I always start fights with Smoke Bomb, Caltrops, Vanish, Acid Spray. Then Poison Cloud if I'm fighting mobs or Toxic Blade vs. a boss.

I haven't used Caltrops or Ensnare in quite some time. Nothing is requiring me to do so. Mostly my group pulls are, "Will anything attack in the next 1.25 sec? If no, Vanish -> Acid Spray -> Poison Cloud. If yes, Smoke Bomb first." This has held true through Vallus. For bosses it's usually Vanish -> Acid Splash -> Toxic Strike -> Smoke Bomb -> Toxic Strike -> Piercing Strike/Poison Cloud -> Continue.
Is Smoke Bomb 3 followed by Caltrops 3 better than Caltrops 3 first and then Smoke bomb 3?

If yes, why?
Peter34 wrote:Is Smoke Bomb 3 followed by Caltrops 3 better than Caltrops 3 first and then Smoke bomb 3?

If yes, why?

Edit: As it turns out, the numbers are about the same for total pushback. Caltrops applies itself to the pushback time added via Smoke Bomb if Caltrops is applied first. However, Caltrops has a short duration and will give the target a 26% speed boost when it wears off for the current action. Tactically it makes more sense to use it second but the gain is small enough that you won't be punished too badly most of the time. Also, you can Smoke Bomb to buy time for Caltrops, but you can't Caltrops to buy time for Smoke Bomb.

beekeo

Site AdminTue Jul 31, 2012 2:10 pm
Meian wrote:
thekitchensink wrote:I was told by a mod today that offhand weapon damage is not factored into SW magic attacks (acid spray, poison cloud, toxic blade). He seemed to indicate that he thought toxic blade should factor it in, but that he'd have to look into it. Personally, in the experimenting I've done with switching between offhand weapon and shield it seemed like those abilities still did slightly more damage with an offhand weapon equipped, but he's a mod... so take that for what you will.

A mod told you that? *facepalm* I'll go ahead and pretend they didn't say that. Suffice to say, the mod is wrong in this case.


I'm probably the mod in question here. I went digging through my notes and the database and then tested again. I was led astray by the gems attached to my offhand weapon -- had to check numbers with normal load-out, with no gems and then again with no offhand at all. Meian is correct.
Whats the step by step recommendation for training?
Max haste first? or split it with magic/meelee?
Crit and magic are much more important that melee or haste. With enough magic and high crit you can quicky take out any group and make mince meat of bosses. Remember that poison attacks are considered magic and can't be blocked or dodged. If you use vanish and your crit is above 40 you will have a 90% chance, or better, of critting. If you make all your blue gems Crit Power you will be doing a lot of damage with each strike. To me Melee and haste are also important but take a back seat to magic and crit. I only use melee when I have to because it can still be blocked or dodged. Haste is important to have but I would never put it before crit.