Book of Heroes

How to Shadow Walker- ARCHIVE · page 3

TCG_Garrison64 wrote:Crit and magic are much more important that melee or haste.
I disagree about haste being less important. I didn't figure out about magic, but with haste and crit I know that haste gives you better dps bonus per might until 30%.
With T3 vanish, 250% crit power, and nothing on crit, you would have a 55% chance of doing 300% damage. So, you're already doing 210% normal damage, (55% of 300%+ 45% of 100%). Getting to the semi soft cap of crit, (40%), would make it 280% of normal damage, (90% of 300%+10% of 100%). After knowing that you can realize that getting to the semi soft cap of crit only gives you a 33.3...% bonus, (280%/210%-100%).
Now for haste. With T3 dark lunge and nothing on haste, you would have a 20% reduction in time taken to do attacks. Meaning you'd be doing 125% normal damage, (100%/80%). Getting to 30% base haste would make it 200% normal damage, (100%/50%). Therefore, getting haste to 30% would give you a 60% bonus, (200%/125%-100%), while getting to 40% crit, (which takes more points to get to), would give you only a 33.3...% bonus.
P.S. technically you only need 27.51% haste, (with a sword), but because i was doing statistics, and not real life senarios where it goes by 0.05 seconds. I decided to say 30%.
Pureawesomeness wrote:
TCG_Garrison64 wrote:Crit and magic are much more important that melee or haste.
I disagree about haste being less important. I didn't figure out about magic, but with haste and crit I know that haste gives you better dps bonus per might until 30%.
With T3 vanish, 250% crit power, and nothing on crit, you would have a 55% chance of doing 300% damage. So, you're already doing 210% normal damage, (55% of 300%+ 45% of 100%). Getting to the semi soft cap of crit, (40%), would make it 280% of normal damage, (90% of 300%+10% of 100%). After knowing that you can realize that getting to the semi soft cap of crit only gives you a 33.3...% bonus, (280%/210%-100%).
Now for haste. With T3 dark lunge and nothing on haste, you would have a 20% reduction in time taken to do attacks. Meaning you'd be doing 125% normal damage, (100%/80%). Getting to 30% base haste would make it 200% normal damage, (100%/50%). Therefore, getting haste to 30% would give you a 60% bonus, (200%/125%-100%), while getting to 40% crit, (which takes more points to get to), would give you only a 33.3...% bonus.
P.S. technically you only need 27.51% haste, (with a sword), but because i was doing statistics, and not real life senarios where it goes by 0.05 seconds. I decided to say 30%.

Those numbers don't translate into reality very well. YOu take your 55% crit and I'll take my 90% and lets see who gets through the mobs faster. You'll be wasting time on extra attacks from missed crits, taking more damage and using more healing potions or wasting more time using interrupts to keep from getting hit. In the mean time I cast vanish and poison cloud and wipe out all 3 mobs on almost every fight. Even bosses generally only take 3 attacks with maxed crit. Haste doesn't do squat if you don't get to use it. The only way haste outperforms crit in your scenario would be if there were really long battles where the extra speed had a chance to overcome the performance of getting crits most of the time. In this game there aren't any battles that long. Also my crit is at about 95% now so I rarely miss a crit. With the guild bonus it will be at 100%.Haste becomes almost meaningless at that point but my haste is currently at 47% anyway so it is possible to have both. In the long run though crit is still more important than haste on a SW.
TCG, mathematically, (and in reality), it makes more sense to get haste to 30% THEN crit to 40%, (or more). Yes, the crit being higher first makes it more predictable, and a little less frustrating, but haste is better overall.
If you still don't believe me, try, (temporarely), taking off you're crit gems, and test it with maybe a trask or 2, (basically anything would work if you do it enough, and it's not too easy), then do the same with haste, (you'd also have to reset your abilities to get dark lunge again, so if you don't want to test this I understand), then get back to me. It won't be a perfect example cause of the bonus from hero training, but it's close enough

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 30, 2012 3:08 pm
Pureawesomeness wrote:
With T3 dark lunge and nothing on haste, you would have a 20% reduction in time taken to do attacks. Meaning you'd be doing 125% normal damage, (100%/80%).

Actually, with Dark Lunge/ Hasten, ther is a casting penalty.

I recommend my Guildmates have a least Haste -30% before using either ability.

Currently I am running Haste -40% and Dark Lunge/ Hasten rank 1 with my characters.

In v1.4, Haste does not affect Cool downs. Depending on your ability choices, this may also effect actual DPS.

REDACTED

Draft excerpt from an Post I am working on:
"-
REDACTED
-"
BjofCJandBj, that was confusing, but I think i understood most of it. Although, I have a couple of questions.
1: what's with the best for Shadow Walker and War Mage thing, how are you determining that? I didn't notice anything that explained what you meant by that specificaly, or how you calculated it.
2: you mentioned I wasn't taking the cast time of dark lunge in to account. I know that i didn't, I was just trying to make the point about haste vs crit. The thing that confuses me though is I didn't see you take it in to account for the DPS% either. I know it's difficult to do so, but I thought that, considering you meantioned it, you would factor it in and give an estimated DPS%. Instead of not taking it in to account, and giving an exact DPS%.
So you're going to tell me you'd actually rather play a SW with high haste than high Crit? Ok then I set this challenge to you. Remove all your crit gems and run 10 Trask Runs. Then put all the crit gems back and remove all the haste gems and do the same thing. Time from the first of each run to the end. Add it all up and average it and then tell me what you find. Let's put those numbers to a reality test.
TCG_Garrison64 wrote:So you're going to tell me you'd actually rather play a SW with high haste than high Crit? Ok then I set this challenge to you. Remove all your crit gems and run 10 Trask Runs. Then put all the crit gems back and remove all the haste gems and do the same thing. Time from the first of each run to the end. Add it all up and average it and then tell me what you find. Let's put those numbers to a reality test.
I don't have much time for dungeons right now, Because my guild doesn't have a lot of extra time between raids right now, but I'll get back to you eventually.
P.S. I said eventually not as soon as possible, it'll probably be a while.
TCG, how do you want me to test the times?
1: should I use dark lunge for crit, haste, both, or neither?
2: should I use as many haste/crit gems as possible, or just enough to get 30% haste/40%crit, or to the semi soft caps of 40% for each?
3: should I try to clear the waves as fast as possible, (as in cast times), or try to take as little damage as possible?
P.S. I think that. 1, it being at, whatever points are needed to get to 30% haste, for both crit and haste. 2, using dark lunge for both.
And, 3, trying to take as little damage as possible. Would be the most accurate test, because what I was saying with my original post was. That it's better to get to 30% haste first, and for the damage vs speed thing. I was saying before that it's better to get to 30% haste first, and I'm thinking that the point of the game isn't supposed to be based on how long it takes to kill enemies. But that's just my suggestion/opinion, and it's your test.
TCG, if you don't reply I'm not doing the test. You don't have to reply soon just get back to me when you can.