Book of Heroes

snapcast

why is it that everytime i choose snapcast it doesn't happen instantly? my opponent always gets a chance to choose something and it's usually defend which screws me because my spell doesn't the damage i desire. someone please explain this. when i fight the computer in quests snapcast is instant.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Mar 2, 2014 11:24 pm
In PvP, snapcast works a little different...and this is to accommodate the idea of taking turns in PvP...and it only matters/occurs at a point where both players are choosing their next action simultaneously.


Example, other player is stunned and you hit them, now you both have 0 timer as you both get to choose your next move...

You choose snapcast and then the attack that is going to fire, the timer can't begin though because the other player has to choose his action...if he sees you are choosing snapcast, of course he can choose to defend or otherwise mitigate it... point being the action timer cant execute your snapcast until it has an action to tick off for your opponent as well. If he doesn't have an action immediately selected when you choose snapcast...he gets to choose one and then the action timers start.

The only way to avoid your opponent choosing an action to defend against your snapcast is to choose snapcast in a situation where your opponents action is already selected and timing down..

example, it is your tune to choose an action, and your opponents next attack has 0.05 sec left to execute..you choose snapcast and he cant do anything about.

So again, the only time your concern is valid, is when both opponents do not have an action selected and need to choose...if the first one chooses snapcast, then the other gets to see that it is coming and can select his next move to help mitigate it. To avoid this...only choose snapcast when your opponent still has time left on their next action and not when you both need to select an action. (Note however that you can not always avoid this, nor do you always want to avoid it)
Snapcast is the most cheesy, broken ability in any PvP ever created. Ideally, in PvP there should be a balance of ability between classes. Tell me one thing that either the Justicar or Shadow Walker has that compares to an instant, unstoppable casting ability.

While your at it, explain why the Shadow Walker has zero abilities that stun and also do high damage like Icy Grasp.

I know you're dying to do Frozen Shard, Ice Lance, Snap Cast, Icy Grasp ad nauseam, but give it a rest. There's a reason why War Mages in BoH have a 3:1 win / loss ratio once they hit level 17 and figure out the combo of ultimate cheese.
Starkus wrote:Snapcast is the most cheesy, broken ability in any PvP ever created. Ideally, in PvP there should be a balance of ability between classes. Tell me one thing that either the Justicar or Shadow Walker has that compares to an instant, unstoppable casting ability.

Juggernaut paired with Heroic Will and Brutal Strike + Seismic Slash. Heroic Will can also be used to bypass the starting cooldowns, which makes for a very powerful exploit.

A good justicar is very OP, even more so than War Mages.

I'm not sure what is going on at lower levels, but at hight might + level this is the case.
Mithrid's post is mostly correct.

In PvP, if both players have 0 timers, such as the example Mithrid gave of breaking a stun, and the WM chooses Snap Cast, sometimes the computer has the opponent choose before the WM has to select the ability to be used with Snap Cast and sometimes the WM has to choose first. I havent figured out what causes the server to switch the selection order, but I think its related to resist checks... Ie the server is counting a chck as an action, so alternates to the next player.

In the case that the opponent has to pick between the selection of Snap Cast and the companion ability, if the opponent chooses to defend, the WM can also defend, then pick their ability so it hits after defend is down.

I personally think this is broken and the WM should always have to choose the companion ability before the opponent.
Im going to try and simplify this as much as possible.

The way ties seem to work:
If you gain initiative at the start of a match, your opponent will win the tie next time you both have the exact same casting time. Then it alernates every time it is a tie.

Now let's say you're a mage and you gain initiative in the beginning of a match. You do your "wait until i can icy grasp" casts and then you stun your opponent. You cast something, and then you are both at 0.00. This counts as a tie, and your opponent wins this tie, thus he will get to choose his attack first, the same way he would if it was a "normal" tie (he hit's you and chooses his attack while you are at 0.00) while leaving you AGAIN with 0.00 since your snapcast executed after he chose his attack.

Let me know if I got anything wrong or if it is unclear, but I think my analysis is correct.

As a simple rule you can keep in mind that if you cast snap cast after you have won a tie/had, you will have the upper hand. I can't remember a single instance where this hasnt applied when I've been keeping track of the ties.
Nevla_Nom wrote:Im going to try and simplify this as much as possible.

The way ties seem to work:
If you gain initiative at the start of a match, your opponent will win the tie next time you both have the exact same casting time. Then it alernates every time it is a tie.

This has been confirmed previously by devs as the way it works. Not at a pc, so I can't search for the thread, but it's definitely the case.
Nevla_Nom wrote:

Juggernaut paired with Heroic Will and Brutal Strike + Seismic Slash. Heroic Will can also be used to bypass the starting cooldowns, which makes for a very powerful exploit.

A good justicar is very OP, even more so than War Mages.

I'm not sure what is going on at lower levels, but at hight might + level this is the case.

Nevla, I couldn't have said it better, just think you missed the negation of dodge through back swing.
Starkus wrote:Snapcast is the most cheesy, broken ability in any PvP ever created. Ideally, in PvP there should be a balance of ability between classes. Tell me one thing that either the Justicar or Shadow Walker has that compares to an instant, unstoppable casting ability.

While your at it, explain why the Shadow Walker has zero abilities that stun and also do high damage like Icy Grasp.

I know you're dying to do Frozen Shard, Ice Lance, Snap Cast, Icy Grasp ad nauseam, but give it a rest. There's a reason why War Mages in BoH have a 3:1 win / loss ratio once they hit level 17 and figure out the combo of ultimate cheese.


I'm sorry I'm a war Mage, pretty good record over all but there are 2 ppl in particular that I have about a 50% give or take just a bit against.... Neither are mages.

As far as you saying snap is an instant cast, that's correct but so is reposte isn't it? A sw can defend for .01 seconds and snap out of it.... Multiple times throughout fights which the good ones utilize to their advantage, and that's only defend. Add up the disappearing attack timer with a sw and tell me it adds to more than the 1 second (maximum if slowed and have low haste) that snap cast eliminates and continue to argue your point about snap being overly op.

Now justi: as said heroic will + seismic to start. That knocks my ass back over 1 second. So if I'm not quick enough, or if the justi gets the jump on me easily creating a gap that is hard to come back from.... Add in jug.... Mages NEED stacks to win a fight. That literally makes it impossible if used at the correct times.

The classes are actually rather well balanced. I don't claim to be the best pvp Mage out there, but my record as of recent shows I'm a decent contender.

None of this will matter when the justi fixes that are long overdue come into play for pve. My bet is pvp will be all sorts of whacky all over again.
I would concur with Sanguin, that the use of snap cast should entail a immediate selection of what ability the wm is going to use. The timer should then switch back to the opponent and they should have opportunity to choose an action, be it defend, or some other ability. Virtually every wm I have encountered knows that the defend option of their opponent is bypassed by defending themselves. Thus using the defend option against snap cast is effectively useless at best.
If the wm select defend as the next ability after activating snap cast, then defend is what should be triggered by snap cast, period.
The combo of Icy Grasp, followed by Shatter, Snap Cast, Ice Lance, and Frozen Shard Is almost unable to be defended against unless one has high level resist enchantments, and when combined with Ice Mastery, and the Ice Damage Enchantments, results in numerous pvp players experiencing the yet to be corrected oversight (one hopes) of trying to convert pve corrections into pvp scenarios, and almost guaranteed defeat.

As of this date, no player, including EricM, have offered up detailed information on how a remotely even odds chance can be obtained against such. There have been claims, there have been anecdotes, there have been conjectures, but where are the details, substantiated by testing of even limited proportions?