Book of Heroes

snapcast · page 2

Eric beats me... He is one of the ones I go back and forth with. The other is purao.

Eric dodges or blocks a majority of my ice lances
NightRaven wrote:
As of this date, no player, including EricM, have offered up detailed information on how a remotely even odds chance can be obtained against such. There have been claims, there have been anecdotes, there have been conjectures, but where are the details, substantiated by testing of even limited proportions?

I think the reason many of the high might swers have been... loathe to share too much is because If you share too much strategy, then everyone starts to copy it... and the entire metagame shifts towards your build. Which tends to be frustrating since already, everything is available to see since you can inspect builds. One of the reasons I do so well at the moment is that I play an unorthodox shadow warrior. It's similar enough to what most play, but has enough little tweaks here and there to counter warmages.
NightRaven wrote:
The combo of Icy Grasp, followed by Shatter, Snap Cast, Ice Lance, and Frozen Shard Is almost unable to be defended against unless one has high level resist enchantments, and when combined with Ice Mastery, and the Ice Damage Enchantments, results in numerous pvp players experiencing the yet to be corrected oversight (one hopes) of trying to convert pve corrections into pvp scenarios, and almost guaranteed defeat.

I don't see how this combo is any better than the swer combo of stun - defend - grenade - caltrops - piercing. Every class has its' share of good combos (if any are lacking, then it'd be justis - but even there it's a very slight lack). One doesn't need status resist either to combat a warmage. I use defense, for example, and do just fine for the most part.
NightRaven wrote:I would concur with Sanguin, that the use of snap cast should entail a immediate selection of what ability the wm is going to use. The timer should then switch back to the opponent and they should have opportunity to choose an action, be it defend, or some other ability. Virtually every wm I have encountered knows that the defend option of their opponent is bypassed by defending themselves. Thus using the defend option against snap cast is effectively useless at best.
If the wm select defend as the next ability after activating snap cast, then defend is what should be triggered by snap cast, period.
The combo of Icy Grasp, followed by Shatter, Snap Cast, Ice Lance, and Frozen Shard Is almost unable to be defended against unless one has high level resist enchantments, and when combined with Ice Mastery, and the Ice Damage Enchantments, results in numerous pvp players experiencing the yet to be corrected oversight (one hopes) of trying to convert pve corrections into pvp scenarios, and almost guaranteed defeat.

As of this date, no player, including EricM, have offered up detailed information on how a remotely even odds chance can be obtained against such. There have been claims, there have been anecdotes, there have been conjectures, but where are the details, substantiated by testing of even limited proportions?

If one knows how the game works and keep track of ties, one can counter snap casts better.

One might argue that I'm biased since I am a war mage myself, but remember that I have to face snap casts when fighting other war mages.
Observing that there are only three classes, with three general build structures for each, the odds are very high that builds will be similar to each other rather than the potential elaborate differences one might observe in games with greater depth. Limit this further by having the pvp portion of the game mechanics favor an even smaller group of skill sets and character variation becomes even less. That the update has brought new imbalance to pvp in an effort to resolve pve balance is not a point of serious contention. WM players and Justi players are well heard voicing whether the timer bypassing heroic will is worse than the un defendable snap cast, or vice versa.
EriM, your voice is the first SW voice suggesting that there is a strategy, a build that can at least offer something approximating even odds. What is heard is of desiring to remain original (in a very limited game). The desire and inclination to not help in order to maintain ranking or originality is the right of each player who so chooses. Your reply in a different section here is appreciated, that of stacking gems, but also obvious, and as you know but are not stating, not quite that simple. Your stated win record I'll not question, and is quite impressive. If your desire, and that of other players, is to try and maintain originality and/or ranking by refraining from mentoring or assisting fellow players, that is your right. The perception however can quickly sour, especially in light of the game mechanics defects, when one, or a few, do this, and then come about and rather than help, just tell players who are struggling that they are doing it wrong.
Personally, as a guild officer, I share all that I can, both to guild members, and those not in the guild. If I find a strategy or build that works for pve or pvp, I share it. For me the experience is more about the interaction, helping fellow players succeed, and having friendly fair competitions rather than being the best, taking top spots, or holding the keys to success and begrudgingly doling them out. It's not about being better, more righteous, or anything else.
Nevia,

I am unsure by what you mean when you state counter snap cast. At the moment, the only ability I know of is Interrupt, which is solely a WM ability. As previously mentioned, if Snap Cast activates, then the WM who knows can initiate a long chain of uninterrupted potentially critical and status inflicting attacks to which there is little defense other than high tier enchantments.
Would this be the same conversation if those involved did not have high level gear and high level enchantments?
I don't even know where to begin. You have a strangely abrasive method of asking for aid. That said, it's incredibly difficult to provide you personalized advice without knowing your might as the metagames differ slightly as might increases. The 40k+ might strategies do not necessarily work at 20 or 30k might. I'll see what I can do to answer your post, and hopefully provide some help.
NightRaven wrote:Observing that there are only three classes, with three general build structures for each, the odds are very high that builds will be similar to each other rather than the potential elaborate differences one might observe in games with greater depth. Limit this further by having the pvp portion of the game mechanics favor an even smaller group of skill sets and character variation becomes even less.

This is a very generalized statement. I don't know anything about warmages, but Shadow Warriors (and Justi's) have three completely viable pvp builds (Full Melee, Full Magic, Hybrid), each with its' own build. And even within each subtype, there are differences (Enchant choice, 1h vs. shield for sw, Gem configurations). All of this is public knowledge upon character inspection...
NightRaven wrote: EricM, your voice is the first SW voice suggesting that there is a strategy, a build that can at least offer something approximating even odds. But the voice you bring up is the voice not of promoting the betterment and improvement of the game and game experience for players. Instead we hear of desiring to remain original (in a very limited game). The desire and inclination to not help in order to maintain ranking or originality is the right of each player who so chooses. One asks then why participate in discussions where to distillation of such is, there is a way, I know it, you don't, and I'm not sharing other than to tell you that you are in error? Is this your intent?

Firstly, I'm far from the first successful Shadow Warrior in pvp. I've fought many that do very well for themselves. (Example: Ceka in Shadow Walker UP ) Honestly, I didn't even start pvping until two weeks ago due to preferring pve content to pvp. I do seem to be one of the few that is willing to talk about my strategy however. Is it wrong to wish to retain some originality? Not at all. That said, I've sent my pvp build with full specs and gems to anyone who has asked (30+ people and counting). I really have nothing to hide in terms of build or strategy. Like I've repeated over and over... a quick inspection of any of the top 25 pvp shadow warriors will tell you 90% of what you need to know. The game inherently has very limited privacy on our gem/enchant choices, so I really don't appreciate being called out on "not sharing". However, if you expect me to coach you on exactly what attacks to use play-by-play, I'm not "promoting the betterment and improvement of the game and game experience for players" as you put it, but rather just turning you into a copy of me. I've always felt the best competition thrives on discovering strategies on your own (Take DaK vs. Me... the reason we've gone back and forth and done so well in pvp is because we're constantly tweaking our builds through practice).
NightRaven wrote: Personally, as a guild officer, I share all that I can, both to guild members, and those not in the guild. If I find a strategy or build that works for pve or pvp, I share it. For me the experience is more about the interaction, helping fellow players succeed, and having friendly fair competitions rather than being the best, taking top spots, or holding the keys to success and begrudgingly doling them out. That is my choice.

I applaud you for doing your duty as a guild officer, but not sure why you feel the need to again call me out. I've never seen you in pvp chat before, nor have I intentionally attempted to be contemptuous towards you (I apologize if I came across that way). I'm more than happy to answer any pvp or pve questions you may have; feel free and come merc a raid with us sometime and we can have an extended talk (DaK and I are co-GMs of Fizzbears - excuse the shameless plug lol)... or just whisper me (EricM in game).


With that out of the way, I'll repeat the same pvp advice I usually give.

With the way stats work in this game, every stat except Health has diminishing returns. What that means is that past a certain point, you're not getting as much benefit by continuing to invest in that stat. Additionally, a balance of all stats is significantly better for pvp (depending on your particular metagame), rather than solely focusing on magic/melee like many do in pve. For example, up until 2040ish magic/melee, each increase of 2.5 in the stat increases bonus damage by 1. After 2040, it takes an increase of 12.5 in the stat to increase bonus damage. (See Stat Calculations and Diminishing Returns for more information on diminishing returns)

So step one in a pvp build is deciding what is going to benefit you the most in combating a particular class or build. For me, at high might... Warmages are what I have the most trouble with. Why do they give ME trouble? Because my extremely quick attacks may hit fast, but in return I take ice damage. Stacks tend not to be as huge of a problem unless I let them get out of hand. So the faster and more I hit with quick strikes, the more damage I end up taking inevitably. Therefore, the solution is twofold. Firstly, I beef up magic resist gems. Secondly, I try and maximize my damage per attack while remaining under the diminishing returns caps (More piercing strikes and less garrotes). This works for me, but only because I'm combating the issues I'm facing. It all depends on your might, build, and what you need to spec against.

If you're being knockbacked alot... consider increasing block or dodge... potentially even grabbing a knockback resist enchant (thought I'd caution against that last one). If you're being hit by a huge damage combo... consider increasing your resists, defense, dodge, etc. If you're being outpaced, consider investing in haste gems.

We're Shadow Warriors. We're the class with the most control over the field. We have the quickest moves, the highest dodge potential, and riposte. Use all of that to your advantage when gemming up. It took me one week to come up with a reasonable pvp build that performs well and I'm nowhere near the smartest tool in the shed. Feel free to inspect me or any of the other players in the leaderboards or just whisper asking for advice rather than publicly calling out one of the few willing to help ;)
Included in your reply was my call out of you, which I posted, then edited as I had yet to observe your response in the other thread. So I will publicly state here that I, as well as other I'm sure, very much appreciate your input and suggestions. I apologize for any implication that you engage in sanctimonious or hypocritical behavior. Abrasive? Yes, there is some of that from digging for help, and encountering either silence or the previously mentioned behavior.

Looking at the top rank pvp players, obviously abilities and hero point assignments are unavailable for observation, as is strategy unless one happens to have an encounter. Personally, I am not looking to be led by the hand, nor duplicate every nuance of another player. However, as pre patch rankings and builds very well demonstrated with the Melee SW, variation was reduced to hero point assignment with equipment, gems, and even enchants all being the same. I would offer that post patch, this will occur again with a natural progression towards what offers the best chance of success. Indeed, your SW character is still very much the typical Melee build of pre patch in most respects. Tacita is another High ranked SW player, who like yourself, opened up about their experiences and shared thoughts. Tacita's experience was markedly different than yours however, and suggested that until someone could find a new build, engaging on pvp with WM characters was best viewed as an automatic loss. You, Eric, are the first to offer any credible refutation, and some guidance.

Crucial to this is what you and I both mention however, that the issues we are discussing and potential avenues of resolution are entirely germane only to higher might rankings with the associated gear and enchantments. As one of the characters of highest might and gear in my guild, just this one character is many months, or more, from achieving the build status of anyone in the top 250, let alone the top 100. The guild members and other players I encounter and try to encourage to participate in pvp are even more removed from these capabilities. The challenges here are dealing with these issues when one has limited capabilities. This is where the inequities of the game mechanics hit the hardest, especially when issues such as farming by higher ranked players is added in. Other threads have mentioned the lack of participation in pvp which is ironic given the self billing of the game. The primary complaint and reason for lack of participation that I field is the inequity of the game mechanics. This game has been on for how long? Other gaming systems offer better pvp matchup with their second or third revision. It's difficult to get any enthusiasm for pvp participation other than a grudging need to complete the obligatory quests, and even then, the quests get saved until near last. Several players, including myself, have made suggestions as to how the pvp portion of the game could attract and maintain as large a group as the pve portion of the game. To date, next to none have been implemented.

I will gratefully share what you have, and look forward to any further insights that you, or other players, may have regarding improving not just individual play, but the game as a whole.

Thank you
NightRaven wrote:Tacita is another high ranked SW player, who like yourself, opened up about their experiences and shared thoughts. Tacita's experience was markedly different than yours however, and suggested that until someone could find a new build, engaging on pvp with WM characters was best viewed as an automatic loss.

Indeed, this is what I wrote in my post. However I made it a week before 2.0.2 was released where SW got significantly buffed. I haven't changed the part about WMs after this update which doesn't mean that I still think the same about them, although there are a few WMs I couldn't beat since 2.0 (Ceka, Zerium, japster; Podval only once).
Snap cast saves so many WM at the end of the battle It gives them a free, instant attack that no other race had. Keep it but lengthen its cool down. It would even things up