Book of Heroes

1hand spirit justi build · page 2

How viable is a 1h spirit build in onslaught, phlip?

When my justi was growing, I tried it way back at like 20k might, but it was nowhere near as good as 2h spirit or 2h melee. Both performed significantly better.
Hi Eric
Not sure, I haven't tried it.
I think for LoB,KFS onslaught 2H will always be better since 1H is more about defence, which doesn't help your RPP. (CoC 1H is better once you can one-shot them).
Since Zaneybaby was specifically asking about a 1H spirit build I gave him my suggested one - won't break any onslaught records but should work fine.
I may try a 1H spirit build similar to this for pvp with more specs in next update. I have a feeling 1H is way to go for spirit justis in pvp.
Phlip

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jun 21, 2014 8:26 am
Nightcrawler13 wrote:"As usually, skip Weapon Focus after you get Tier 12 Gear."

Is that because of diminishing returns, and points could be spent elsewhere that give you a better return on investment?

Yes, see BoH v2.0 of this recurring discussion:
Bj_Knows wrote:
Spending 3 ability points for a 3% increase in damage is a poor choice for most Builds. After you get Tier 12 Gear, I would recommend changing your build to remove Weapon Focus.
Weapon Focus and Inner Focus

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jun 21, 2014 8:42 am
NBW_Phlip wrote:A couple of comments on BJs post:

Elder Fury only works for 2H weapons so not an option for a 1H build.

Backswing only works for physical attacks so no good for spirit ones.

So no point in a 1H Spirit justi investing in those abilities.

The Original Post asked for people's thoughts. Really, it was sort of vague.

Elder Fury is to compare and contrast, 2h with Elder Fury versus 1h with Light Shield and 1h with Heavy Sheild. Experiments have show 2h Axe seems to rule for PvE Physical/ Spirit/ Physical & Spirit Justicars, so 1h Justicars seem to be a PvP Build. 2h Spritit Justicars do well in PvP, so 1h with Light Shield gives little advantage. The comparison seems to suggest the most viable 1h Justicar is with Heavy Shield and a Spirit/ Physical/ Spirit & Physical Justicar in PvP.

CJ has had a lot of luck with a 1h Spirit Justicar in PvP. Pure Spirit until Level 16, then eventually adding Brutal Strike 2, Seismic Slash 2, Backswing 3 by the time you reach Level 30. Backswing is for Brutal Strike, Seismic Slash and the rare Basic Attack. If you have any points in Brutal Strike and Seismic Slash for PvP, Backswing makes a *huge* difference in Win Loss ratio.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jun 21, 2014 9:01 am
Subject
1h Justicar in PvE, including Crypt
NBW_Phlip wrote:
Not sure, I haven't tried it.
I think for LoB,KFS onslaught 2H will always be better since 1H is more about defence, which doesn't help your RPP. (CoC 1H is better once you can one-shot them).

Hi Eric and Phlip,

Phlip and I have been analyzing 2h Weapons in Onslaught (Note 1). In my experience Minor Fire Runes for a Burn Stack 3, significantly increase my RPP in Boss Onslaught. Since Periodic Damage (DOT), both Bleed and Burn, is based off Weapon Speed, a 2h Axe (1.4 Speed) does +25% to +40% more damage than a 1h Sword (1.0 Speed). Plus 2h Weapons general do +50% Damage Per Second over similar 1h Weapons for a total of 75% to 110% increase in Bleed and Burn damage, less of an impact if you prefer Minor Spirit Runes.

Spirit Justicars use a lot of Smite and Heavenly Wave, which have terrible cool downs. For PvE, Heavenly Wave sucks compared to Cleanse Potions and Juggernaut, especially Heavenly Wave rank 2 or rank 3. Better to get just Heavenly Wave rank 1 (even my mostly Physical Build has it) and put the points elsewhere.

1h Spirit Justicar with Heavy Shield seems to excel at PvP (see CJ's 1h Spirit Justicar), but 2h Axe Justicar seems to rule PvE, whether Physical/ Spirit/ Physical & Spirit.

I agree with Phlip about Crypt (Note 2).

Note 1)
One of many posts

Justicar Boss Rotation Comparison- 2h Axe (R= Expert+)

Note 2)
Crypt Justicar, Magic & Melee, Level 33
Bj_Knows wrote:

Phlip and I have been analyzing 2h Weapons in Onslaught (Note 1). In my experience Minor Fire Runes for a Burn Stack 3, significantly increase my RPP in Boss Onslaught. Since Periodic Damage (DOT), both Bleed and Burn, is based off Weapon Speed, a 2h Axe (1.4 Speed) does +25% to +40% more damage than a 1h Sword (1.0 Speed). Plus 2h Weapons general do +50% Damage Per Second over similar 1h Weapons for a total of 75% to 110% increase in Bleed and Burn damage, less of an impact if you prefer Minor Spirit Runes.

Fire runes, eh? That's a very interesting strategy. I've always preferred spirit runes, but can't say I've ever actually experimented with the others- I'll have to try it out when I get back in a week and a half.
Bj_Knows wrote:
Spirit Justicars use a lot of Smite and Heavenly Wave, which have terrible cool downs. For PvE, Heavenly Wave sucks compared to Cleanse Potions and Juggernaut, especially Heavenly Wave rank 2 or rank 3. Better to get just Heavenly Wave rank 1 (even my mostly Physical Build has it) and put the points elsewhere.

I actually didn't have wave at all on my spirit onslaught build. The damage it did was so low, I preferred cleansing/break rune-ing/etc. Oddly, I didn't have jugg either. Figured if I was getting hit enough that statuses became that much of a problem, I wouldn't be doing well enough in onslaught as is was to even try. It was actually a bit of a hybrid build. Had it set up so I could just alternate condemn and wound, with smite on every fourth strike. It averaged right around 3.6k-4.2k rpp/round at 36-38k (don't remember exactly what I am) might. I think Condemn, Wound, Smite, Stun (1 pt), Seismic were the only attacks I had in it. No Wave, Brutal, Execute, Radiant. Rest were all passives to buff up the stacks.
Bj_Knows wrote:
1h Spirit Justicar with Heavy Shield seems to excel at PvP (see CJ's 1h Spirit Justicar), but 2h Axe Justicar seems to rule PvE, whether Physical/ Spirit/ Physical & Spirit.

1h Spirit Justi w/heavy shield is completely dominant in pvp. It's a bit tough to play, and the combination of enchants force you to create a whole new set of equip unfortunately, but personally, I think it's one of the best when played correctly. My big problem was that my justi was melee all through t16 and t6, complete with phys damage, stat resist/defense, and 2h enchants. If I wanted to make a spirit justi, I would have had to go 1h, block, spirit enchants, and that would have been too costly since I'd need a full set of new equip, pvp gems, and new enchants.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jun 23, 2014 9:59 am
EricM wrote:
Fire runes, eh? That's a very interesting strategy. I've always preferred spirit runes, but can't say I've ever actually experimented with the others- I'll have to try it out when I get back in a week and a half.

With a Burn Stack 3, I am doing for 60% of my 2h Axe Weapon Damage (Zeetha has equal Melee and Magic Gems) for 19 damage Ticks (uses 6 damage Ticks getting to Burn Stack 3).
EricM wrote:
I actually didn't have wave at all on my spirit onslaught build.

Between running the numbers and listening to player experience, I have decided Rend rank 3 and Frenzy rank 3 are best at Onslaught, so a pure Melee Build or a Physical/ Magic Build (like Zeetha). I like the Physical/ Magic Build because of damage from Burn Stack 3 and diminishing returns from Melee Gems.
EricM wrote:
If I wanted to make a spirit justi, I would have had to go 1h, block, spirit enchants, and that would have been too costly since I'd need a full set of new equip, pvp gems, and new enchants.

CJ had more luck building a PvP Jusitcar from Scratch, and then using a 2h Axe in PvE. I have decent luck in PvP with 2h Axe, Elder Fury rank 3 and Spirit/ Melee Build.