Book of Heroes

Why are Justies so OP??? · page 3

I have a hard time countering juggernaut. I agree that the knockback justie spin cycle is very damaging but it wouldn't be so bad if I had some buffs on them. The 0.06s cast time makes it impossible for me to get grasp on them for over 2s oof the fight. By then my 35k hp os down to 8k.... And I spend the rest of the time catching up. If I luckily Dodge a seismic and a brutal I have a chance otherwise I have no idea what to do.. I think I'm missing something but I suck against justies. I love my fights against Wm and sw though.... They seem less luck based(although that never hurts!)
Jumper wrote:I have a hard time countering juggernaut. I agree that the knockback justie spin cycle is very damaging but it wouldn't be so bad if I had some buffs on them. The 0.06s cast time makes it impossible for me to get grasp on them for over 2s oof the fight. By then my 35k hp os down to 8k.... And I spend the rest of the time catching up. If I luckily Dodge a seismic and a brutal I have a chance otherwise I have no idea what to do.. I think I'm missing something but I suck against justies. I love my fights against Wm and sw though.... They seem less luck based(although that never hurts!)

That is exactly how I feel.

If Venan looked at my player data they'd see my win loss ratio vs JC is 1:5

Vs Wm and Sw it's 4:3...

Clearly something is very very broken....
agreed. I don't even bother playing against Jusi anymore. I just hit staff until I die cause I'm so so pissed on how OP they are.
Here are the Mage vs Justie issues:

1. The Mage is all about doing debuffs and burn. Juggernaut eliminates that.
2. It is nearly impossible to ever stun a Justie. Because the HW3 and Juggernaut cast times are too quick, so they can resist your stun most of the time if they know what they are doing as long as HW is held in reserve.
3. The knockbacks are insane. I have had Justies do 8 actions in a row thanks to knockbacks, stuns and HW.
4. Stagger is much more potent than Arcane Shield.

I do win some percentage of the time but most of the time it is due to might imbalance, poor justie play, or pure luck (dodging slash is just about the only real hope against a well played justie). Oddly enough, I have more wins against Justie than SW, but that's only because I meet 3-4 times the number of them. So I haven't met enough SWs to form an opinion and I do not do PvP with my SW to know the SW-Justie situation.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jul 27, 2014 12:56 pm
Bbbb wrote:Here are the Mage vs Justie issues:

1. The Mage is all about doing debuffs and burn. Juggernaut eliminates that.
2. It is nearly impossible to ever stun a Justie. Because the HW3 and Juggernaut cast times are too quick, so they can resist your stun most of the time if they know what they are doing as long as HW is held in reserve.
3. The knockbacks are insane. I have had Justies do 8 actions in a row thanks to knockbacks, stuns and HW.
4. Stagger is much more potent than Arcane Shield.

I do win some percentage of the time but most of the time it is due to might imbalance, poor justie play, or pure luck (dodging slash is just about the only real hope against a well played justie). Oddly enough, I have more wins against Justie than SW, but that's only because I meet 3-4 times the number of them. So I haven't met enough SWs to form an opinion and I do not do PvP with my SW to know the SW-Justie situation.

I'd suggest getting to know when Juggernaut is going to pop up. For example most of the time my Justicar opponents pop it at the start of the fight, so with SW you have to avoid wasting your Caltrops. But fighting them with SW is a different kettle of fish entirely. Grenade can go through Juggernaut (there are good reasons for it to) and isn't modified by Urgency so it's a good chance to apply it early on.

Defends are for stuns and seismic, though sometimes resisting a stun just gets you the seismic in the face. Watch carefully for them wasting their HW too early to go for early seismic - this will open up a chance or two later on.

With mages, you have the fastest stun so see where you can get it in. That gives you a free hit as should snap...they have to use their defend somewhere. Also, if you've managed to apply some burn/fracture already, Jugger doesn't stop anyone taking 8,000 damage from your Incinerate or 4-5k from fire blast (I've seen this myself).

If well-played you can't do a heck of a lot against a good Justicar build but pray for dodges, and lots of them. That does however open you up to lots (and lots) of Backswing damage. There are problems with backswing and its tendency to do a lot more damage than you'd reasonably expect (and seemingly ignore the normal defend/block damage rules).

Bottom line is, I win more against WM and other SWs than Justicars too...don't know how reliable that data is, given that on average since PvP official start the average might of my opponent is 13k higher than mine.

I play a lot with Spirit Justicar too, but only around 15k might so can't tell from the other POV. I need better enchants and gear with that one.

japster

ModeratorMon Jul 28, 2014 6:14 am
Ilyana wrote:
I'd suggest getting to know when Juggernaut is going to pop up. For example most of the time my Justicar opponents pop it at the start of the fight, so with SW you have to avoid wasting your Caltrops. But fighting them with SW is a different kettle of fish entirely. Grenade can go through Juggernaut (there are good reasons for it to) and isn't modified by Urgency so it's a good chance to apply it early on.

Just want to point out that all of a WM attacks are focused on landing debuffs. The strength of a WM comes from a synergy of debuffs with the actual attacks (e.g. fractures with magma, chill/stun with shattering, burning with fireblast). Without landing the debuff, the non-debuff attack becomes average. Hence the difficulty in playing against a JC as a WM. Sure, Incinerate is powerful, but without debuffs it's nothing more painful than a Brutal Strike with no added effect. Sure, it can be snapcasted, but it doesn't do the insane damage without debuffs (and seriously, it can always be dodged or blocked like any normal attack) and it generally isn't used more than once per fight, especially when everyone is packing status resist/defense at high levels once above 45,000 might.

There's nothing to pre-empt about a Jugg that is coming up. We all know when a competent JC is going to use Juggernaut. Right at the start of the fight, UNLESS you use a long cast attack. Let's play out some common scenarios.

If you use a long cast attack that has no debuff (e.g. ice lance/incinerate), you're going to get knocked back instantly. Or, the JC, depending on initiative and haste, will simply trade you with a wound followed by Jugg to pre-empt your next move (and you are now bleeding, and he has Jugg up so you can't stun or land any debuffs anyway), because face it, after a WM uses Incinerate/Ice Lance, his next few moves are limited to the debuffing moves. If it's Incinerate to Ice Lance or vice versa, the WM is asking to be knockbacked for using two long casts in a row.

If you use a faster cast debuff skill (lash/shard/grasp), jugger gets thrown out instantly (0.06s Jugg at level 3, it's almost impossible to not waste your move unless the JC screws up his own game bad). Use your fastest cast moves (fireblast, shattering force) and you deal weak damage unless a debuff is on the JC first (which is unlikely because of Jugg, as stated above). A JC would be more than willing to trade those weak but fast WM attacks for a Wound. Admittedly, sometimes there's a chance for fireblast to land ignite if the JC decides to not Juggernaut pre-emptively against an opening short cast. This is one of the most ideal starts for a WM, but doesn't happen often since most JCs will pre-emptively Juggernaut anyway.

No matter what a WM does, he is at a major disadvantage until 2 Juggernauts and 1 stunning blow ends. Don't forget, a JC can always block with a 2handed weapon with Elder Fury, thus making the WM attacks during Juggernaut even less effective if blocked. In any properly-played JC v WM fight, the WM only gets to retaliate properly (i.e. land the debuffs) only after 2 Juggernauts. There's only ONE window of opportunity to stun and slow the JC before the 3rd Juggernaut comes up. Yes, it's totally possible for a WM to win a JC in this one window by landing magma, chill, burning, and stun in this one opportunity. But with high status resist and defense that all the top PvPers has, the margin for error is extremely small. If the JC resists the slow or stun without Juggernaut (which happens fairly often), it's almost a sure-loss for the WM. From experience, the WM-JC matchup is slanted 70-30 in favor of the JC.

On the other hand, once the JC lands one bleed on you (which is almost always a JC's first offensive attack after Jugg), his physical damage gets augmented by rend. And as you land ineffectual hits on the JC across 2 Juggernauts and Stunning Blow rotation, he gets 3 stacks of Vengeance. By the time the WM gets the chance to land debuffs to augment his damage, he is more often than not (unless the WM himself gets lucky on his rolls for 2 seconds, dodging and resisting everything), far behind the JC in terms of health and damage.

Hope that clears things up about the WM v JC matchup at high might (more than 45,000). Is it severely imbalanced? No. Is it imbalanced in favor of the JC? Yes. Will Venan do anything about it? I don't know. Simple because, WMs are way strong at low might.

Are WMs >> JC at mid and low might? YES. Because at those might levels, people don't carry enough defensive stats and health, so debuffing isn't crucial. Snapcast Incinerate (instant damage) is single-handedly more than sufficient to turn the tides of any fight.

I don't envy Venan's job, but it still must be said that there's still lots of work for class balancing that is necessary, both in PvP and PvE.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Jul 28, 2014 7:37 pm
There's some work to be done. However I've seen WM do 6k damage off the bat, (with no fractures) with Frozen Shard through 19% worth of Defence enchant. Incinerate still does crazy damage. You are still launching a reasonably high damage attack at them, which generally they will let hit as it's the debuff they want to avoid, not the damage.

The main problem is that mages seem designed to do stupidly high damage via debuffs and the Justicar has a way to avoid those debuffs for a period. All goes back to those crazy abilities introduced for mages back in 2.0 which broke the game for six months. Now they have to made to work in actual PvP rather than beta, things are more complex than they probably appeared.
From my experience so far (around 500 matches) WM is having a horrible time vs JS. I am talking about 2h WM, havent tried 1h shield yet.

The main issues have already been said. WM depends on debuffs. JS is immune to debuffs. And since matches last really short these days (at least on plat 3), JS has immunity to debuffs for almost whole match.

So WM will be doing some dmg sure, but not as close as it potential allows. At the same time, JS just pumps wounds or smites and WM musnt defend them because of seismic/brutal.

One more thing that shifted this match up heavily in JS favor in my opinion is that JS gets to land seismic on non defended attack ALL the time. Was a bit different during beta iirc.

And finally, in general i think with huge damage that is flying around these days, Venan should really buff health coefficient. Matches last too short. So WM and SW pretty much get to use their big CDs (stuns, snap cast, smoke bomb) only once, while JS gets 2 seismics, 2 stuns, 2 to 3 jags. Also WM mirror matches usually dont last more than like 6-7 moves which is insane. Health needs to go up in PvP and then we might start seeing more interesting match ups imo.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Jul 30, 2014 6:21 pm
Spriher wrote:From my experience so far (around 500 matches) WM is having a horrible time vs JS. I am talking about 2h WM, havent tried 1h shield yet.

The main issues have already been said. WM depends on debuffs. JS is immune to debuffs. And since matches last really short these days (at least on plat 3), JS has immunity to debuffs for almost whole match.

So WM will be doing some dmg sure, but not as close as it potential allows. At the same time, JS just pumps wounds or smites and WM musnt defend them because of seismic/brutal.

One more thing that shifted this match up heavily in JS favor in my opinion is that JS gets to land seismic on non defended attack ALL the time. Was a bit different during beta iirc.

And finally, in general i think with huge damage that is flying around these days, Venan should really buff health coefficient. Matches last too short. So WM and SW pretty much get to use their big CDs (stuns, snap cast, smoke bomb) only once, while JS gets 2 seismics, 2 stuns, 2 to 3 jags. Also WM mirror matches usually dont last more than like 6-7 moves which is insane. Health needs to go up in PvP and then we might start seeing more interesting match ups imo.

Health was moved to a diminishing return curve like all other stats. This was because some folk were stacking up to 51,000 HP in some cases. So a skilled pvper could in some cases have to do 15k more damage just to make things a fair match. Seriously, HP abuse was drawing out matches and getting people a lot more wins than they perhaps should have been getting.

Things are more sane now. Matches don't last overly long even at the high end...even 31-35k health can vanish quickly if the opponent plays well, and you don't get the feeling that people are hiding behind huge amounts of health.

Btw, Justicars are not immune to debuffs. Jugger has a very specific length and can be worked around - I'd say backswing is as much or more of a problem since the damage applied from it doesn't follow the standard damage patterns (its been claimed this isn't the case but a lot of people are not convinced). Even through defend, backswing can do more damage than brutal.

Weird thing is, Justicar abilities have hardly changed...jugger was the same before. Opponents worked around it before. Against SW at least, WM are absolutely fine, given the damage capability I see very regularly.
I am not saying remove diminishing returns. I am saying increase the starting health coefficient a bit. So stacking too many health gems still wouldn't be beneficial, but everyone would have a bit more health to begin with. And also, why would previous health stacking be considered an abuse? Everyone had the same number of gem slots available and everyone had a choice how to fill them up. Surely a skillful player wouldn't need to do 15k more damage, but instead he would adapt and start stacking health himself.

I also don't agree that shorter matches make for a saner PvP experience. Shorter matches don't promote skill, but luck. Basically, whoever crits/resists/dodges/blocks more, wins. And this is where might discrepancies come into play in the current matchmaking system. If you opening slow move gets resisted (for WMs and maybe SWs), you hardly have time to recover. If anything, shorter matches make for a more annoying experience and leave you feel cheated by RNG. On top of all that, surely if only one class out of three has a reset cooldowns button, that is always gonna be a huge balancing problem for shorter match ups.