Ilyana wrote:
I'd suggest getting to know when Juggernaut is going to pop up. For example most of the time my Justicar opponents pop it at the start of the fight, so with SW you have to avoid wasting your Caltrops. But fighting them with SW is a different kettle of fish entirely. Grenade can go through Juggernaut (there are good reasons for it to) and isn't modified by Urgency so it's a good chance to apply it early on.
Just want to point out that all of a WM attacks are focused on landing debuffs. The strength of a WM comes from a synergy of debuffs with the actual attacks (e.g. fractures with magma, chill/stun with shattering, burning with fireblast). Without landing the debuff, the non-debuff attack becomes average. Hence the difficulty in playing against a JC as a WM. Sure, Incinerate is powerful, but without debuffs it's nothing more painful than a Brutal Strike with no added effect. Sure, it can be snapcasted, but it doesn't do the insane damage without debuffs (and seriously, it can always be dodged or blocked like any normal attack) and it generally isn't used more than once per fight, especially when everyone is packing status resist/defense at high levels once above 45,000 might.
There's nothing to pre-empt about a Jugg that is coming up. We all know when a competent JC is going to use Juggernaut. Right at the start of the fight, UNLESS you use a long cast attack. Let's play out some common scenarios.
If you use a long cast attack that has no debuff (e.g. ice lance/incinerate), you're going to get knocked back instantly. Or, the JC, depending on initiative and haste, will simply trade you with a wound followed by Jugg to pre-empt your next move (and you are now bleeding, and he has Jugg up so you can't stun or land any debuffs anyway), because face it, after a WM uses Incinerate/Ice Lance, his next few moves are limited to the debuffing moves. If it's Incinerate to Ice Lance or vice versa, the WM is asking to be knockbacked for using two long casts in a row.
If you use a faster cast debuff skill (lash/shard/grasp), jugger gets thrown out instantly (0.06s Jugg at level 3, it's almost impossible to not waste your move unless the JC screws up his own game bad). Use your fastest cast moves (fireblast, shattering force) and you deal weak damage unless a debuff is on the JC first (which is unlikely because of Jugg, as stated above). A JC would be more than willing to trade those weak but fast WM attacks for a Wound. Admittedly, sometimes there's a chance for fireblast to land ignite if the JC decides to not Juggernaut pre-emptively against an opening short cast. This is one of the most ideal starts for a WM, but doesn't happen often since most JCs will pre-emptively Juggernaut anyway.
No matter what a WM does, he is at a major disadvantage until 2 Juggernauts and 1 stunning blow ends. Don't forget, a JC can always block with a 2handed weapon with Elder Fury, thus making the WM attacks during Juggernaut even less effective if blocked. In any properly-played JC v WM fight, the WM only gets to retaliate properly (i.e. land the debuffs) only after 2 Juggernauts. There's only ONE window of opportunity to stun and slow the JC before the 3rd Juggernaut comes up. Yes, it's totally possible for a WM to win a JC in this one window by landing magma, chill, burning, and stun in this one opportunity. But with high status resist and defense that all the top PvPers has, the margin for error is extremely small. If the JC resists the slow or stun without Juggernaut (which happens fairly often), it's almost a sure-loss for the WM. From experience, the WM-JC matchup is slanted 70-30 in favor of the JC.
On the other hand, once the JC lands one bleed on you (which is almost always a JC's first offensive attack after Jugg), his physical damage gets augmented by rend. And as you land ineffectual hits on the JC across 2 Juggernauts and Stunning Blow rotation, he gets 3 stacks of Vengeance. By the time the WM gets the chance to land debuffs to augment his damage, he is more often than not (unless the WM himself gets lucky on his rolls for 2 seconds, dodging and resisting everything), far behind the JC in terms of health and damage.
Hope that clears things up about the WM v JC matchup at
high might (more than 45,000). Is it severely imbalanced? No. Is it imbalanced in favor of the JC? Yes. Will Venan do anything about it? I don't know. Simple because, WMs are way strong at low might.
Are WMs >> JC at mid and low might? YES. Because at those might levels, people don't carry enough defensive stats and health, so debuffing isn't crucial. Snapcast Incinerate (instant damage) is single-handedly more than sufficient to turn the tides of any fight.
I don't envy Venan's job, but it still must be said that there's still lots of work for class balancing that is necessary, both in PvP and PvE.