Book of Heroes

Why are Justies so OP??? · page 4

SWs smoke bomb also reduces the cool down of abilities. It also can't be blocked or dodged just like their ensnare. Although as a small consulation it doesn't do damage.

If it can be avoided one should avoid a slow opening move vs JCs imo. In my experience that leads to a seismic chain of hurt that I personally have a hard time overcoming.

I for one don't feel them OP as the thread title implies. Of the three classes they require the least luck for me to beat. If a fellow SW resists my caltrops and spawns haste while I get slowed I can pretty much kiss that match good bye. With WMs I can't resist their abilities nearly so well as I'd like and they have snapcast to snipe me at opertune times. With JCs I can work around their abilities most of the time.

I think I'll agree with the recent talk about even more health, or conversely less damage, might make for a better PvP experiance more reliant on skill when facing oppenets of compearable might. It would also accenuate any imbalences between the classes in the long game. So I'd want to try it some before wholeheartedlty deciding one way or the other.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Thu Jul 31, 2014 9:46 am
B_Râd wrote:Come on venan!!! How can you focus on a pvp update and make 1 class be so OP for pvp??? Juggernaut is 100% resist! Seismic Toss completely ends the match for anyone hit by it!!! Brutal Strike then Heroic Will and start over!!! You have got to be kidding me with this bs!!!

Something to balance pvp needs to be done and soon!!!
Lol! What about when WM completely decimated EVERYTHING before the update? Now it's a lot more fair, considering that warmages were able to freeze several times in one match before the update.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jul 31, 2014 6:29 pm
Spriher wrote:I am not saying remove diminishing returns. I am saying increase the starting health coefficient a bit. So stacking too many health gems still wouldn't be beneficial, but everyone would have a bit more health to begin with. And also, why would previous health stacking be considered an abuse? Everyone had the same number of gem slots available and everyone had a choice how to fill them up. Surely a skillful player wouldn't need to do 15k more damage, but instead he would adapt and start stacking health himself.

I also don't agree that shorter matches make for a saner PvP experience. Shorter matches don't promote skill, but luck. Basically, whoever crits/resists/dodges/blocks more, wins. And this is where might discrepancies come into play in the current matchmaking system. If you opening slow move gets resisted (for WMs and maybe SWs), you hardly have time to recover. If anything, shorter matches make for a more annoying experience and leave you feel cheated by RNG. On top of all that, surely if only one class out of three has a reset cooldowns button, that is always gonna be a huge balancing problem for shorter match ups.

What you're saying makes sense in itself, but what you're essentially asking for is to go back to the old levels of health, which wasn't working. You had to stack to 51k health just to be on par with some people.

The way it is now is very good in comparison. Health works like any other gem in your build that you can take to up to around 35k (haven't seem any higher thus far). Some matches in beta were very boring while you tried to chew through their health. At least now it is quite fair.

Either get more health or more defence/resists to survive those crits. It sounds like you aren't building enough health into your spec if you're having trouble.
It seems allmost nothing has been learned from a year beta..
- 1h jc's hit harder then a 2h wm with his longest attack.
- 2h jc's control a game against an ice wm. afaik ice was the control spec where fire is the damage spec.. jcs have both.
- health nerfed (for god sake) but if u dont pack 35k ur still dead when a 2h hits like a truck going 100km.

Kal did a good job on balancing sw compared to the other 2 classes. a tat lower against wm, a tat higher against jc.
Kal screwed up balancing jc/wm's. After a month he needs to step up.

Remarks like: "I'm amused that wm's start with Frozen Shard" only make things look silly..

Either make sword/bored (pun intended) viable for wm's or buff def on gear to an sw level and on a side note nerf def on jc's gear.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Aug 1, 2014 5:54 pm
Bango2004 wrote:It seems allmost nothing has been learned from a year beta..
- 1h jc's hit harder then a 2h wm with his longest attack.
- 2h jc's control a game against an ice wm. afaik ice was the control spec where fire is the damage spec.. jcs have both.
- health nerfed (for god sake) but if u dont pack 35k ur still dead when a 2h hits like a truck going 100km.

Kal did a good job on balancing sw compared to the other 2 classes. a tat lower against wm, a tat higher against jc.
Kal screwed up balancing jc/wm's. After a month he needs to step up.

Remarks like: "I'm amused that wm's start with Frozen Shard" only make things look silly..

Either make sword/bored (pun intended) viable for wm's or buff def on gear to an sw level and on a side note nerf def on jc's gear.

1H Justicar hits harder than 2H WM? In what universe? Some staff mages can remove all your health in two hits...13k crits are not uncommon. I don't think I've ever been hit for 13k by a Justicar in one hit, through my defence. Not even by Purao :-)

I think you need to up your defence and get more resist gems.

Essentially you seem to be saying 'nerf everything that makes things difficult for mages'. I think Kal has a very good handle on the (im)balance of PvP. His comment was probably more that most WM can be expected to cast shard first, not that it's a poor tactic. If you know what your opponent is going to do first, it can be advantageous.

As for the health nerf...it was very necessary. Health just needed to behave like a normal stat.

Speaking of...any chance we can get Backswing to use standard damage calculations instead of the broken formulas it seems to use now?
You obviously don't get my point. Making the "get more resist it will resolve statement" is pretty dumb since 99% of the players arent on max level gems, ht and enchants. I can redo my entire post but if you reread it more carefully you might get it.

Blast_Femur

ModeratorSun Aug 3, 2014 4:45 am
I agree ...overall I think the pvp is fair...I'm a war mage...Snapcaster will kill you...like said above work around it...as a war mage just wait outjugger... it's all in how you build your character..

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Aug 3, 2014 6:54 am
Bango2004 wrote:You obviously don't get my point. Making the "get more resist it will resolve statement" is pretty dumb since 99% of the players arent on max level gems, ht and enchants. I can redo my entire post but if you reread it more carefully you might get it.

Actually I can read and understand your point and also disagree or make suggestions around it, thanks. Disagreeing does not mean the person misunderstood you.

beekeo

Site AdminSun Aug 3, 2014 7:51 pm
At this moment there are 21 Justicars spread out across the top 100.

In a mathematically perfect world there would be at least 33. So..
- are there not enough high might Justicars to compete in Platinum? Plausible
- are most Justicars button-mashing meatheads? Maybe
- are most Justicars playing a long con, trying to convince Venan that they are thin blooded wimps, just waiting for a skill boost so they can strike for glory!? Meh probably not.

The population issue is something I'll ask about, see if we can normalize that against win/loss rates etc. But it's not as if all the Justicars are packed into the top 20.
Just as a snap shot right now, 6 justicars, 8 warmages and 5 shadowwalkers make up the top 20. I think its a bit premature to start bowing down to your justicar overlords (but by all means feel free to do so)...