Book of Heroes

Initiative in PvP · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 1, 2014 7:40 am
backward wrote:Initiative is more than fantastic, but it's too powerful with the 1 sec cd timer advance. In pve, even when surprised the timers advance. Is losing horribly to the first throw not enough? My sw can caltrop before jugger can pop. Sticky, then smoke bomb. Their jugger falls off, stun. Game over. Every time, every time, every time. Make it good AND fair, cuz after a stun, sw's can drop 500% damage and a slow.with initiative. Almost able to open with it.

1 sec? I've never seen more than around .3 difference in initiative at the beginning of a fight in over 600 matches on two toons. I think we need more background on your circumstances, might etc.

Also, juggernaut has a .06 cast time at 3 points in it (on my 17k Justicar anyway - don't know about lower mights).
Ceka_Pogba wrote:I think the 0.15 start its too huge. Maybe to put at 0.10 or 0.05?
15? I get mine up .21+ needs to be removed an enchantments need to be refunded.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 1, 2014 7:08 pm
I'm not hearing any details or any real arguments for initiative somehow being bad.
Ilyana wrote:I'm not hearing any details or any real arguments for initiative somehow being bad.
you are probably one of those guys with maxed out enchantments. So you never seen people with the same initiative bonus. One match 1 goes first an the other guy doesn't stand a chance, an then the next match the other guy goes first an the 1 guy doesn't stand a chance. It's like flipping a coin who goes first wins. This isn't football and even in football just because you receive the ball first doesn't mean you are going to win. Therefore it should be removed from the game an both players should start at the same dang time = chance of winning. How's that?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Sep 2, 2014 3:16 am
Super_GM wrote:
Ilyana wrote:I'm not hearing any details or any real arguments for initiative somehow being bad.
you are probably one of those guys with maxed out enchantments. So you never seen people with the same initiative bonus. One match 1 goes first an the other guy doesn't stand a chance, an then the next match the other guy goes first an the 1 guy doesn't stand a chance. It's like flipping a coin who goes first wins. This isn't football and even in football just because you receive the ball first doesn't mean you are going to win. Therefore it should be removed from the game an both players should start at the same dang time = chance of winning. How's that?

Actually my max enchantment level is VII. I have Initiative on both my PvP toons. I am a $0 player.

Sometimes you go first because your level of initiative compares favourably with your opponents'. Other times you don't. It's very strange that you consider going first to be the decider in a match. It isn't. This isn't opinion, it's a fact. What may be happening is that you aren't adapting your strategy to circumstances beyond your control. In PvP you must be flexible. What do you do if your stun is resisted, or your opponent defends your knockback or your big spell doesn't do much damage through a defend/block? SW have to assess what to do if their caltrops get resisted or the opponent dodges their pierce.

Learn your toon's abilities well so you can adapt to what happens when one or more of them doesn't work. Adapt to what happens when you go second and maybe add some initiative enchants. Also bear in mind that if you go second, you will automatically win the first tie, which can be very useful.
Lol! Just read through this thread. The purpose of this thread originally was just to make it clear how initiative works in pvp.

Personally I don't use initiative but I definitely wanted to understand how it works since I fight people who do so often. The effect on initial cd on actions is very important.

I actually think its fair enough, its a nice mechanism once you understand it. Although the 0.15s kicker is a big swing at the start of a fight, I think a smaller amount would be better.
Ilyana wrote:
backward wrote:Initiative is more than fantastic, but it's too powerful with the 1 sec cd timer advance. In pve, even when surprised the timers advance. Is losing horribly to the first throw not enough? My sw can caltrop before jugger can pop. Sticky, then smoke bomb. Their jugger falls off, stun. Game over. Every time, every time, every time. Make it good AND fair, cuz after a stun, sw's can drop 500% damage and a slow.with initiative. Almost able to open with it.

1 sec? I've never seen more than around .3 difference in initiative at the beginning of a fight in over 600 matches on two toons. I think we need more background on your circumstances, might etc.

Also, juggernaut has a .06 cast time at 3 points in it (on my 17k Justicar anyway - don't know about lower mights).

I meant the advance on the 1 sec cd timers. You can jugger but if haste and initiative place caltrops less than the .06 your jugger is too late. Followed by a sticky then smoke bomb (seismic and stun still have .2 to cd on your bar)<--that's what i find unfair with initiative. You're done. You might get a swing in by the time two grenades and poison cloud roll you for 700% damage before crits.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Sep 3, 2014 4:30 am
You are doing something seriously wrong if this is happening every time. Like I said I have never seen anyone get more than a (roughly) .3 sec initiative advantage on me with either 37k SW or 17k Justicar. I think this strongly suggests that you badly need the enchant yourself. Initiative is one of those 'arms race' enchants. You need it simply because your rivals will have it and if you don't you will regularly see massive initiative swings.