Book of Heroes

Initiative in PvP

OK so posting what I know about how iniative works in PvP, some of it is a little strange and not intuitive...

If both fighters have equal initiative its probably random who starts with the 0.15s advantage (do post if you think otherwise). However to explain how it works I will take the example of somebody with 16 levels of initiative enchant (P1) versus 0 initiative (P2)....

P1 starts fight while P2 waits for (0.15+0.16=0.31s).

For abilities with initial 1s cd, P1 only has 0.69s cd. So eg. A justi P1 can do an action for 0.69 and then immediately do a seismic or stun. (At this point P2 has only had 0.38s of actions).

For P2, as well as starting 0.31s later, the initial cd for him is still 1s from the start of the fight (for abilities with 1s cd) so it will be 0.31 later than P1 before he can do seismic/stun. However he also needs only 0.69s of actions before seismic/stun is available as he had to wait the first 0.31.

This explains why SWs have been able to use smoke bomb to me earlier than I thought possible - similar for justis and seismic/stun.

Its perfectly possible for somebody with 15+ levels of initiative more than you to stun you before you can even select stun or seismic.

I don't know what happens if P2 had some initiative enchant, whether it works identically if P1 had 16 levels and P2 zero or P1 21 levels and P2 5 levels. Prob same but would be interesting if people can post confirmation or otherwise.

Hope this helps people understand how the enchant works, please do post here if you have more insight - thanks!
One extra point. The starting cd effect works the same even if both players have 0 initiative:

So P1 has 0.15s head start, and can use 1s cd abilities after 0.85s.

This means you will only need to wait a max of 0.85s before using abilities with 1s cd like seismic/stun whatever level your initiative is. (And whether you are P1 or P2).
Yes, this is what frustrated me SO MUCH in PVP so much. P2 doesn't have their cooldowns start timing away until the initiative is gone. It makes it extremely difficult to beat stun effects when you can't match the opponent because your timers start later.

This is why I bought initiative and increase it when I can.

Of course what's going to happen is they are going to change initiative in the future, and it will suck....thus anyone with the enchant having wasted materials for it.

beekeo

Site AdminSun Jul 20, 2014 2:19 pm
If both parties have Initiative enchantments, the player w more levels goes first. They get 0.15s plus 0.01s for every level difference.

A has 3 levels of Init, B has 1 level.
0.15s + (2*0.01) = 0.17s

Player A's 1.0s starting cool down on stuns begins 0.17s sooner than Player B's.
I tried a matchup like that today. And seen replays where the 1sec warmup is shorter than intended. My example was: enemy = 4% ini. Me = 3%. He starts with a 0.16 sec lead. His 1sec warmup sould be (1-0.04) 0.96sec. He casts for exatly 0.88 sec and then he started his seismic to my big surprise. Is my understanding wrong of how initiative works or is it a bug?

beekeo

Site AdminFri Aug 1, 2014 2:32 pm
Initiative is better than how I first described it.

Player A has 1 point of Initiative, Player B has 0.

Player A goes first, Player B is waiting 0.16s (Base 0.15 + 0.01 for the 1 point difference)

Player A also has their starting cooldown on stuns reduced by 0.16s, from 1.0 to 0.84, 0.32s before Player B can select a stun.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Aug 1, 2014 5:42 pm
beekeo wrote:Initiative is better than how I first described it.

Player A has 1 point of Initiative, Player B has 0.

Player A goes first, Player B is waiting 0.16s (Base 0.15 + 0.01 for the 1 point difference)

Player A also has their starting cooldown on stuns reduced by 0.16s, from 1.0 to 0.84, 0.32s before Player B can select a stun.

Why is the base 0.15? What meant that this was the magic number? I'm just curious. A 0.15 base swing one way or the other is much bigger than people think.

beekeo

Site AdminSat Aug 2, 2014 11:00 am
0.15s was chosen for the base advantage to make Initiative worthwhile in PvP.

PvE Initiative is the % chance to surprise the monsters.
Initiative is more than fantastic, but it's too powerful with the 1 sec cd timer advance. In pve, even when surprised the timers advance. Is losing horribly to the first throw not enough? My sw can caltrop before jugger can pop. Sticky, then smoke bomb. Their jugger falls off, stun. Game over. Every time, every time, every time. Make it good AND fair, cuz after a stun, sw's can drop 500% damage and a slow.with initiative. Almost able to open with it.