Book of Heroes

Fixed auto generated raids! · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 6, 2014 9:32 am
Bbbb wrote:
Ilyana wrote:I don't understand why system-generated raids need to exist. It's not difficult to find a guild and get rewards...don't waste your time with these, especially KFS.

You are apparently living in a different universe than the rest of us (unless you are a SqV level player). I can't count the number of times I have logged in, my guild (who does run at least 5 raids a day) isn't raiding and I can't find a single useful mercable raid. It is not uncommon for the highest mercable raid to be Kraken.

The real solution is to blow up guild loyalty and go back to the old system. Back then you could almost always find a raid and well if you couldn't, there weren't enough people around for it to be successful anyway.

Given that I don't think Venan will ever give up on GL, either the Unknown Hero or unlimit the bronze timer are the solutions. Also, why not make the cap 99? If gold/silver is too easy is the issue, then increase the cap when the silver timer expires. With the current limit, I could see a KFS being stuck for hours/days due to people not hitting P1.

So many people opening counter-arguments or refutations with insults these days...oh well.

System raids didn't exist for many many iterations of the game, so the argument that they are necessary is highly debatable. So no, I doubt it's me that is living in their own private universe....find out when your guild raids and be on when they do. It's a fairly foolproof (at least theoretically) arrangement that almost all guilds do. If you're not on when your guild is raiding that isn't a reason to demand a system-generated raid that is just going to fail anyway. Find a guild that raids when you can...or merc with a guild that does. If you like that guild, join it because they clearly raid when you do.

A system-generated raid that is auto-completed is crazy. People wouldn't need to be in guilds. Just pile into a system raid and burn your e, then sit back and watch Venan complete it for you...is this really where we want raiding to go? Guilds are suffering enough already in these huge barren periods between updates (I don't include PvP as a genuine update, since it's to a minigame and many many people dislike it intensely).

Personally I agree about GL. Didn't need to exist and still doesn't. The guild favours are great but we had those before. We didn't have to be locked away. Now, we see so many closed raids because a bonus was introduced for not using mercs...further dissuading guilds from using mercs where they can get away with if. Add in merc caps, which created the problem of sabotage/skunk mercs, and GL ended up being pretty counter-productive. Maybe one day we'll get back the spirit of 1.5, which I always remember fondly partly because I started playing during those times, partly because the raid system worked so well.
Ilyana wrote:
Bbbb wrote:
Ilyana wrote:I don't understand why system-generated raids need to exist. It's not difficult to find a guild and get rewards...don't waste your time with these, especially KFS.

You are apparently living in a different universe than the rest of us (unless you are a SqV level player). I can't count the number of times I have logged in, my guild (who does run at least 5 raids a day) isn't raiding and I can't find a single useful mercable raid. It is not uncommon for the highest mercable raid to be Kraken.

The real solution is to blow up guild loyalty and go back to the old system. Back then you could almost always find a raid and well if you couldn't, there weren't enough people around for it to be successful anyway.

Given that I don't think Venan will ever give up on GL, either the Unknown Hero or unlimit the bronze timer are the solutions. Also, why not make the cap 99? If gold/silver is too easy is the issue, then increase the cap when the silver timer expires. With the current limit, I could see a KFS being stuck for hours/days due to people not hitting P1.

So many people opening counter-arguments or refutations with insults these days...oh well.

System raids didn't exist for many many iterations of the game, so the argument that they are necessary is highly debatable. So no, I doubt it's me that is living in their own private universe....find out when your guild raids and be on when they do. It's a fairly foolproof (at least theoretically) arrangement that almost all guilds do. If you're not on when your guild is raiding that isn't a reason to demand a system-generated raid that is just going to fail anyway. Find a guild that raids when you can...or merc with a guild that does. If you like that guild, join it because they clearly raid when you do.

A system-generated raid that is auto-completed is crazy. People wouldn't need to be in guilds. Just pile into a system raid and burn your e, then sit back and watch Venan complete it for you...is this really where we want raiding to go? Guilds are suffering enough already in these huge barren periods between updates (I don't include PvP as a genuine update, since it's to a minigame and many many people dislike it intensely).

Personally I agree about GL. Didn't need to exist and still doesn't. The guild favours are great but we had those before. We didn't have to be locked away. Now, we see so many closed raids because a bonus was introduced for not using mercs...further dissuading guilds from using mercs where they can get away with if. Add in merc caps, which created the problem of sabotage/skunk mercs, and GL ended up being pretty counter-productive. Maybe one day we'll get back the spirit of 1.5, which I always remember fondly partly because I started playing during those times, partly because the raid system worked so well.

I agree completely. :)
Considering its a public raid and unplanned, the chances of a lot of people joining is slim. Plus the tiny amount of spots. Personally i believe the raids should be shortened. This way they will more likely to finish for those who need the rewards. The rewards could be a smaller amount. Because a person after HS or silver arent going to care if a raid finishes or not. They can just join a pub raid and solo burn it 24/7 if they like. Lol
Ilyana wrote:Find a guild that raids when you can...or merc with a guild that does.

Doesn't exist. The whole point of the auto-raid is to merc when there isn't an open raid.

A system-generated raid that is auto-completed is crazy. People wouldn't need to be in guilds. Just pile into a system raid and burn your e, then sit back and watch Venan complete it for you...is this really where we want raiding to go?

I'd prefer it to the current system. 1.4 was where things worked the best.
Ceka_Pogba wrote:Possible to put directly for kfs onslaught phase? Its always stuck at p1.

I would love to see that haha. Would be there 24/7 for silver as mats. Doubtful that will happen tho. Would have crazy high HS scores like when coc handed out HS
Ceka_Pogba wrote:Possible to put directly for kfs onslaught phase? Its always stuck at p1.

This is exactly the problem with people now. No one actually wants to put in the work to get to onslaught. All of the HS/silver farmers just expect the lower might toons to so the work for them. Well guess what, that's a terrible way to expect to play the game, and honestly I have no idea how those people are able to last in a guild.

With that said, public raids should not exist for raids with OS(except CoC which is all OS, so squatting does not usually occur) as they will just fail because people are lazy and don't want to put the effort into getting to OS.
Lol, well thankfully i put forth the effort to get there. And well the little people need the os squatters in order to finish the raids 90% of the time. Each need the other, like cohabitation in nature :) There is a fish that keeps lookout for a shrimp, makes sure he doesn't get eaten. So that the shrimp can dig a hole for both of them to live in. :) same idea. Each depends on the other for survival. Forget their names, been to many moons. Lol could look up if needed later.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 6, 2014 3:03 pm
ñôtållthâtfãt wrote:Lol, well thankfully i put forth the effort to get there. And well the little people need the os squatters in order to finish the raids 90% of the time. Each need the other, like cohabitation in nature :) There is a fish that keeps lookout for a shrimp, makes sure he doesn't get eaten. So that the shrimp can dig a hole for both of them to live in. :) same idea. Each depends on the other for survival. Forget their names, been to many moons. Lol could look up if needed later.

Believe it or not, there are people that do both of these things when the need arises. :-)

Don't people help a raid, whether guild/mercing or these unneeded system ones? If you see P1 of KFS is nowhere near onslaught, help it! I guess altruism really is dead.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 6, 2014 3:08 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Ilyana wrote:Find a guild that raids when you can...or merc with a guild that does.

Doesn't exist. The whole point of the auto-raid is to merc when there isn't an open raid.

A system-generated raid that is auto-completed is crazy. People wouldn't need to be in guilds. Just pile into a system raid and burn your e, then sit back and watch Venan complete it for you...is this really where we want raiding to go?

I'd prefer it to the current system. 1.4 was where things worked the best.

There's really no guild that raids at any time in a 24h period that you can raid with? At no time on the clock?

System raids really aren't something that's been asked for. It's similar to GL in that respect. As long as they can't be abused (like auto-completion) and people learn to actually hit in them prior to their precious OS phases, then I guess it's something that will be useful to a few people.