Book of Heroes

Fixed auto generated raids! · page 3

Ilyana wrote:
There's really no guild that raids at any time in a 24h period that you can raid with? At no time on the clock?

Sure I can get one raid in, but that's not the goal. 3 or 4 are really needed to be competitive for Top 25/100. Last time I looked, there isn't a guild that has more than 2 useful raids per day on weekdays that I can make.

System raids really aren't something that's been asked for. It's similar to GL in that respect. As long as they can't be abused (like auto-completion) and people learn to actually hit in them prior to their precious OS phases, then I guess it's something that will be useful to a few people.

First, System raids are not new. They have been around at the low levels for months and I guess that has been successful in Venan's view (I wouldn't know). There has been numerous people upset about not being able to raid when they are available to play. Venan took a stab at this but this solution doesn't work. Unlike GL, it is 100% optional and can be ignored by those who don't like it with no harm done. Nobody give me the GL is optional line - the benefits are too much to ignore.

KFS is no problem in my main guild. Most people have alts - we use them to push P1 though.
Ah there are still a few they help SOS raids. Whenever i see a call for them i always jump in no matter the raid. Not uncommon to see my 5 toons in a kraken, aad, etc just rather not burn unless its needed since one cant opt out of the rewards anymore :/
Public Raid has a New Name: Solo Raids (really only yourself can be trusted to a finish)
Purpose: help newbs/low toons
Issue: failed raids
Reason: lack of faith, order, commitment, negative perspective, everyone expects the other to finish it and most of all, planning and communication.

Wants: no timer (raids now become pointless, randomly toss energy and expects reward)
Wants: cap raised (pointless, caps are never reached to begin with)
Wants: unknown hero finishes (pointless, same as no timer you want goods with no effort)
---You will no longer need to spend cash and that defeats the purpose of the game yes?--

Example of Possible Failure: A great leader of a guild raid depends on mercs as a supplement, not as a means to an end. I have been to a few HitM where guild members [a true example] contribute 37% and mercs 63% and I had to gs a few times to save a bronze raid.

Possible Solution: upon entering said raid (high end raids), a chat room or some kind of planning appears until enough agrees to give it a try. After all no guild just decides to open a raid of 5 players and expects to finish a VG or GK. A successful raid depends on how many online and amount of contributions... if someone wants to burn $100 worth of gs, great! This way everyone can form bounds and know who is good or bad (you really need to know who you can depend on after all, everyone is a merc with no obligations or consequences). Story at end as an example.

This way it is similar to a guild raid, except everyone in public raid knows who each is (so if someone always hit 2x and leeches off the effort of others can be controlled by other members voted by x% to boot out [behavioral enforcement]).

No Public Raids should have onslaught phases, or the game will be imbalanced due to the same players always taking advantage and not moving after or before or barely. You know who you are, as I will not name [7 + 2 and counting], you only live in os phrases and nowhere else.

Once upon a time, there was a tyrant warlord and other lesser warlords hope to overthrow him from his throne. So all the lesser warlords gathered at one point in hopes of strategizing, but each hopes to obtain glory for himself. After many battles, it was not the strategy that failed, but each to his own selfish gain. Each warlord tries to withhold troops and rations. This is an example of a Public Raid - unreliable and undependable with fear of losing.

I will not give more example of Means to an End [reinforcement] (guild depending on mercs, do you like chances?) nor successful raids [leadership] (merc supplements, yea like vitamins, good to have)
Venan really needs to have someone on the development team who plays regularly to prevent this kind of debacle. There was never the slightest chance that it could work in its current form, and that was glaringly obvious to anyone who understood the game from the day it was announced.

I like the game very much, even if I have occasional disagreements with Venan's approach (I.e., nerfing tunes that took a long time, money and effort to build up to balance' PvP). But the auto-generated raids are a real embarrassment and I notice that Venan has not owned up to that to this point.

beekeo

Site AdminMon Aug 11, 2014 6:35 pm
Darkhorse wrote:We're aware of many of the concerns in both directions regarding this topic. We'll be addressing them as time goes on.

The main idea is to make sure that individuals have opportunities to run the raids they want while there's still a good incentive to run raids with your guild.

We're working on a few ideas here which you'll be hearing more about in the future.
Quoted from two other threads about public raids.
Fair enough, you had not responded to this thread but I missed those comments elsewhere. I do note, however, that you did not respond to my basic point which was that even a casual knowledge of the game from a player's perspective would have prevented the debacle in the first place.
Lowering the might requirements for the raids is the worst move I have seen Venan make to date. I hope this was not done to "balance" the public raids by providing them with a bigger pool of potential raiders. It screws up raid schedules and entrance requirements, and will screw up guild raids by allowing low might tunes into difficult raids (e.g., a tune with 7000 might against Direhorn). It also makes it way too easy to progress

Anytime Venan starts balancing anything it is never helpful. I am really starting to dislike updates.
public crypt is nice to pull gold.. anyway give venan some time to collect data and rework the publics, thats what they goin to too in future imo
Yes, public raids are certainly going to be a great success. I just looked at a gk public raid out of curiosity. Two hours into the raid, there are two members and the raid is 0.0% complete. How exactly do you "balance" that?

Meanwhile, the balance of the rest if the game was tampered with for something that no one uses. And the changes to CoC are extremely unpopular with lower might players, and the raid is run far less than it was.

The whole last update was a mistake and it would be great for the game if Venan admitted that and took a mulligan.