Book of Heroes

Seismic Slash- PvP · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Aug 16, 2014 7:57 pm
Bango2004 wrote:
Ilyana wrote:Seismic isn't broken and comparing it smoke bomb in this debate is pointless. Smoke exists because without it a SW couldn't do enough damage to remain competitive.

DW Sticky bomb answerd the "non competative" remark.

No, it doesn't. Having a sticky bomb go off while you are in Death Wish is hard to time because you must ensure your bomb will go off near the end of the match. You also have to rely on yourself being on low health...which is the opposite of what your goal is in PvP (avoiding damage to have enough time to inflict more on your opponent). I have a high level SW and this tactic isn't something anyone can rely on. So smoke bomb is quite an integral part of the SW build as it not only gives good kb, but cools abilities down quicker to re-use so we can keep up with the very high damage outputs WM and Justicar are capable of.

Nightfang_in_a_Gold_Tutu

Sat Aug 23, 2014 12:47 pm
Ceka_Pogba wrote:
EricM wrote:Seismic has the same chance of hitting as any other attack. The only reason it's so noticeable is because it's such a huge game changer when it lands. My SW, for example, has 12% block, 56% dodge. So seismic only has a 32% chance of landing when I don't defend, and a 2% chance of landing if I do defend. But any melee attack has the same % of landing.

Doesnt work like that....


If u have 12% block and 56% dodge that means:
A jc to land his seismic need to overcome ur block and dodge.

So basically: he has 88% chance to overcome your block and 44% chance to overcome your dodge. But he need to overcome both. So he has 88% x 44% = 38,72% chance to success his attack when you dont defend.

And when you defend. Block is +20 and dodge + 10. That become a 32 % block and 66% dodge. So 68% chance to overcome the block and 34% to overcome the dodge. So he has 68% x 34%= 23,12% to success his attack....

You forgot the decimal point; multiplying percentages like that is best done by turning them into decimals in order to avoid mistakes.

The math would actually be 0.88 x 0.44 = 0.3872, which is equal to 38.72%

With defend, it would be 0.68 x 0.34 = 0.2312, which is equal to 23.12%

End result, the Shadow Walker would actually get hit by between one out of every three and one out of every four Seismic Slashes that got thrown at him; and when defending, it'd still only have half the normal effect, less if knockback resist enchantments are involved.
Nightfang_Shadowsoul wrote:
Ceka_Pogba wrote:
EricM wrote:Seismic has the same chance of hitting as any other attack. The only reason it's so noticeable is because it's such a huge game changer when it lands. My SW, for example, has 12% block, 56% dodge. So seismic only has a 32% chance of landing when I don't defend, and a 2% chance of landing if I do defend. But any melee attack has the same % of landing.

Doesnt work like that....


If u have 12% block and 56% dodge that means:
A jc to land his seismic need to overcome ur block and dodge.

So basically: he has 88% chance to overcome your block and 44% chance to overcome your dodge. But he need to overcome both. So he has 88% x 44% = 38,72% chance to success his attack when you dont defend.

And when you defend. Block is +20 and dodge + 10. That become a 32 % block and 66% dodge. So 68% chance to overcome the block and 34% to overcome the dodge. So he has 68% x 34%= 23,12% to success his attack....

You forgot the decimal point; multiplying percentages like that is best done by turning them into decimals in order to avoid mistakes.

The math would actually be 0.88 x 0.44 = 0.3872, which is equal to 38.72%

With defend, it would be 0.68 x 0.34 = 0.2312, which is equal to 23.12%

End result, the Shadow Walker would actually get hit by between one out of every three and one out of every four Seismic Slashes that got thrown at him; and when defending, it'd still only have half the normal effect, less if knockback resist enchantments are involved.


Actually, many countries use commas instead of decimals to separate whole numbers from fractional remainders. Your answer is the exact same as his lol.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Aug 23, 2014 4:26 pm
In the UK we use points and US do too...but most of Europe uses commas to denote decimal points, so I'm surprised it still looks unusual to some people (perhaps more so that they can't see that xx,xx is the same as xx.xx).
Ilyana wrote:In the UK we use points and US do too...but most of Europe uses commas to denote decimal points, so I'm surprised it still looks unusual to some people (perhaps more so that they can't see that xx,xx is the same as xx.xx).

Yeah, thats wierd to say the least lol

Capricorn_Rainbucket

Sun Mar 22, 2015 2:59 pm
Dw does not affect sticky bomb dmg I can't explain this enough I've tested it. Think sticky always does 200 something the number gahhh I can't explain Ericm help me out pls
Kwennie_Mew_Mew wrote:Dw does not affect sticky bomb dmg I can't explain this enough I've tested it. Think sticky always does 200 something the number gahhh I can't explain Ericm help me out pls

Death Wish intentionally doesn't affect sticky. I think the devs felt that sticky would be too overpowered if it gained +50% damage from death wish (kinda how smite is overpowered with three stacks spirit and 3 stacks vengeance lol- go figure).