Book of Heroes

Seismic Slash- PvP · page 3

Ilyana wrote:Seismic isn't broken and comparing it smoke bomb in this debate is pointless. Smoke exists because without it a SW couldn't do enough damage to remain competitive.
just lol Illy!!!!!!! I've seen a quick attack dealing 5K crit...that's as equivalent of BS or SMITE in some occasions.......now add every hit riposte,as it happens 99/100 and speed buff on top of that...do the math
Nightfang_in_a_Gold_Tutu wrote:
Ceka_Pogba wrote:
EricM wrote:Seismic has the same chance of hitting as any other attack. The only reason it's so noticeable is because it's such a huge game changer when it lands. My SW, for example, has 12% block, 56% dodge. So seismic only has a 32% chance of landing when I don't defend, and a 2% chance of landing if I do defend. But any melee attack has the same % of landing.

Doesnt work like that....


If u have 12% block and 56% dodge that means:
A jc to land his seismic need to overcome ur block and dodge.

So basically: he has 88% chance to overcome your block and 44% chance to overcome your dodge. But he need to overcome both. So he has 88% x 44% = 38,72% chance to success his attack when you dont defend.

And when you defend. Block is +20 and dodge + 10. That become a 32 % block and 66% dodge. So 68% chance to overcome the block and 34% to overcome the dodge. So he has 68% x 34%= 23,12% to success his attack....

You forgot the decimal point; multiplying percentages like that is best done by turning them into decimals in order to avoid mistakes.

The math would actually be 0.88 x 0.44 = 0.3872, which is equal to 38.72%

With defend, it would be 0.68 x 0.34 = 0.2312, which is equal to 23.12%

End result, the Shadow Walker would actually get hit by between one out of every three and one out of every four Seismic Slashes that got thrown at him; and when defending, it'd still only have half the normal effect, less if knockback resist enchantments are involved.
End result to this....to make it easy for you...99/ 100 IT DOESN'T LAND = RIPOSTE, for the ones that know and play few matches a day!
EricM wrote:
Kwennie_Mew_Mew wrote:Dw does not affect sticky bomb dmg I can't explain this enough I've tested it. Think sticky always does 200 something the number gahhh I can't explain Ericm help me out pls

Death Wish intentionally doesn't affect sticky. I think the devs felt that sticky would be too overpowered if it gained +50% damage from death wish (kinda how smite is overpowered with three stacks spirit and 3 stacks vengeance lol- go figure).

But smite does gain the bonus power from 3 stacks of spirit and 3 stacks of Vengeance currently right?
DjCleric wrote:

But smite does gain the bonus power from 3 stacks of spirit and 3 stacks of Vengeance currently right?


I believe so.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Mar 23, 2015 8:37 am
Lol back...wrote that in August 2014...

It does Eric, I've done 20k smite crits on occasion if everything lines up correctly for my 36k Spiricar (more likely 30-32k might when most of them happened).
I've been hit by a 54k smite.

I tried my best....but couldn't win that fight. Started with the classic punch attack (of course vengeance strikes!) then I manages to hit him twice without vengeance procing... perfect right? By this time I had the misfortune of having 3 wraths against me. So in a last ditch effort to win the game, 0.12 s before smite was to land, I pull the snappunch! BAM!!!! IT LANDS!!! And you guessed it, I was only 16k shy of killing him. with my 2k hp left.... was hoping for a dodge...but you know how that goes against smite.... 0.12s later.... 54K crit!
EricM wrote:
DjCleric wrote:

But smite does gain the bonus power from 3 stacks of spirit and 3 stacks of Vengeance currently right?


I believe so.

Then grenade is at a HUGE disadvantage since it's damage output does not increase with SW 's DW and Shadow Veil..
DjCleric wrote:
EricM wrote:
DjCleric wrote:

But smite does gain the bonus power from 3 stacks of spirit and 3 stacks of Vengeance currently right?


I believe so.

Then grenade is at a HUGE disadvantage since it's damage output does not increase with SW 's DW and Shadow Veil..




Maybe the grenade is a disadvantage against wm but win chance against sw is already super low for justicar ss tends to land on block if its not dodged I'm not sure how many times I've hit HW to SS and feel like a idiot when it misses
True DJ. I've never understood why grenade isn't affected dw and sv except for possible balance.

I mean, smite hits significantly harder and can't be dodged or blocked (same as grenade). If anything, smite is a significantly lower cast time as well (if you include the 2s as part of the grenade cast).

Only explanation I have for it is that sw have higher crits, so if grenade worked with dw and sv, much higher chance of damage being higher.
Are DOT from poison cloud and caltrops affected by DW? I think venan might be treating it as a DOT. (on that note is bleed affected by vengeance?)