Book of Heroes

T17 sword hits less damage than T16 Axe - NOT A BUG

I'm the kind of a person that constantly and consistently monitors the amount if damage done in all the raids (especially onslaught) and to my amazement once I bought the T17 sword and transferred all my enchantments from my T16 Axe, I actually started to inflict less damage (about 10% less than what I used to)
This is very frustrating since it is expected to do more damage and not less.
My physical SW with all lvl 9 enchantments is now not doing as well in onslaught as it used to do with the T 16 Axe....
Both my 1h justi and my SW appear to be doing more damage with the T17 sword than they were with the T16 sword. Nothing scientific; just casual observation.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Thu Sep 18, 2014 10:34 am
Kìng_Ôz wrote:I'm the kind of a person that constantly and consistently monitors the amount if damage done in all the raids (especially onslaught) and to my amazement once I bought the T17 sword and transferred all my enchantments from my T16 Axe, I actually started to inflict less damage (about 10% less than what I used to)
This is very frustrating since it is expected to do more damage and not less.
My physical SW with all lvl 9 enchantments is now not doing as well in onslaught as it used to do with the T 16 Axe....
Axes do more damage, and I believe that is still true even is the axe is a tier lower? I might be wrong, but eh.
The t17 sword has 137 higher min damage and 21 higher max damage. So more or less the same as the axe, not worse at least. So the sword should in theory be min 10% better or there about.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorThu Sep 18, 2014 10:32 pm
Looks like King Oz might be on to something. I just got the tier 17 2 hand sword earlier and immediately transferrred the enchants from my tier 16 axe. I checked the damage range for my brutal strike and saw 8948-9980. I was surprised because max damage using my tier 16 was over 10,000 already. I was expecting it to be higher than that because of the stats below:

T16 Axe
1822-2465 (1531.07 dps)
Speed 1.4

T17 Sword
2090-2554(1786.15 dps)
Speed 1.3

I equipped my old now enchantless tier 16 axe and saw it to be dealing 8233-9592 brutal strike damage. My 2 hand damage enchant is level 7 so if I add 7% theoretically the damage range would be 8809-10263. I honestly cannot remember if that was my max damage before but it was definitely over 10,000.

If this is not a bug then can someone explain it. Thanks
I'm pretty sure Oz is talking about the SW Axe, whereas Celestial is talking about the Justicar Axe. But I think the same thing is coming into play. For the SW, the Cutlass has a speed of 1.0 vs a speed of 1.1 for the SW Axe. For the Justi, the Anchor as a speed of 1.3 vs a speed of 1.4 for the Justicar Axe.

If memory serves me right, the speed of the weapon comes into play during the damage calculation (I can't remember if it's applied to the base damage or the bonus damage, but you get the drift). Since the resulting extra-damage-from-speed is less, the final damage will likely be less. In both cases, the loss of damage is 0.1% (against whatever speed is being multiplied against).

Nightcrawler

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorFri Sep 19, 2014 8:07 pm
Sorry to bump this up but can any devs shed a light into this. I know weapon speed is a factor is determining dps but in what way.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Sep 20, 2014 11:32 am
Kìng_Ôz wrote:I'm the kind of a person that constantly and consistently monitors the amount if damage done in all the raids (especially onslaught) and to my amazement once I bought the T17 sword and transferred all my enchantments from my T16 Axe, I actually started to inflict less damage (about 10% less than what I used to)
This is very frustrating since it is expected to do more damage and not less.
My physical SW with all lvl 9 enchantments is now not doing as well in onslaught as it used to do with the T 16 Axe....

This is not a bug. You changed from an Tier 16 1h Axe to a Tier 17 1h Sword.

Venan could solve this problem by offering non-Weapon Seasonal Gear or Seasonal versions of all four Weapons.

For a smartphone game, BoH is mind boggling complex. This can be good, or bad.

MY PERSONAL OPINION

[rant mode activate]

People complained that Seasonal Events only had 1h Swords. So Venan added 2h Swords. People complained that Venan only has Seasonal Swords. So with Were Chef, Venan added Seasonal Axes. However, it is still *impossible* to buy the Seasonal Weapon of your choice since Venan has never offered all four weapons for a Seasonal Event.

Did you notice that a Justicar takes *more* damage in Onslaught with the Tier 15 Red Holiday Coat than with the Tier 14 Chest Armor? This also happens with Shadow Walkers, but the effect is not as large. Only War Mages have zero drawbacks from using Tier 15 Red Holiday Coat instead of Tier 14 Cloth Chest Armor. Most players missed this since Chest armor is only 1/5 of your armor, and 1/10th of your Gems. However, your Weapon is 100%- 30% of your damage output (depending on Gems, Guild Favors, PvP Set, etc.).

If you fight PvP with a Tier 16 1h Sword, you can get a full PvP Gear Set (+20% All Damage in PvP) and a Tier 17 1h Sword (*1.1663 Weapon Damage, *not* Base Weapon Damage). If you fight PvP with a Tier 6 silver coin Weapon of any kind at level 16, the Tier 17 1h Sword will be a huge improvement (*6.3979 Weapon Damage, *not* Base Weapon Damage).

The Tier 17 1h Sword requires a Level 15 character to use it, but is much better than the Tier 11 1h Sword bought with Gold Shields also available at Level 15. I am tempted to buy the Tier 17 1h Sword for my Level 3 Shadow Walker and save it until Level 15 especially for PvP.

Will more players be pissed if Venan leaves the Tier 17 1h Sword usable at Level 15 or raises it to Level 30 to match the Tier 17 2h Sword, Light Shield and Heavy Shield?

[rant mode deactivate]

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Sep 20, 2014 12:16 pm
Bj_Knows wrote:
If you fight PvP with a Tier 16 1h Sword, you can get a full PvP Gear Set (+20% All Damage in PvP) and a Tier 17 1h Sword (*1.1663 Weapon Damage, *not* Base Weapon Damage). If you fight PvP with a Tier 6 silver coin Weapon of any kind at level 16, the Tier 17 1h Sword will be a huge improvement (*6.3979 Weapon Damage, *not* Base Weapon Damage).

To Clarify.
A PvP character with a 1h Sword has 10 items, but only needs 9 PvP items for the +10% All PvP Damage Bonus. So they can have 9 PvP items plus the T17 1h Pirate Sword.

A PvP character with a 2h Sword has 9 items, and needs all 9 PvP items for the +10% All PvP Damage Bonus. The math for comparing the T16 2h PvP Sword with the T17 2h Pirate Sword is very complex, and based on your individual character.

For a smartphone game, BoH is mind boggling complex. This can be good, or bad.