Book of Heroes

T17 sword hits less damage than T16 Axe - NOT A BUG · page 2

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorSat Sep 20, 2014 11:01 pm
Actually even with the lower than expected damage I believe I ended up better. My damage went down approx 2.8% but attack speed went up by approx 8.4% (from 0.71 secs to 0.65 secs). I havnt tried doing onslaught yet because of the event but I will share my results once I do a couple.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Sep 22, 2014 10:45 am
Celestial_Cavalier wrote:Actually even with the lower than expected damage I believe I ended up better. My damage went down approx 2.8% but attack speed went up by approx 8.4% (from 0.71 secs to 0.65 secs). I havnt tried doing onslaught yet because of the event but I will share my results once I do a couple.

Axe's biggest contribution to Onslaught Phases is Knockback and Periodic Damage (DOT). Its biggest contribution to Pop Phases is one hit, one kill Mobs.

Cleave rank 3 now does the same damage (160% Base Weapon Damage), and same casting time (100% Basic Attack Speed), as Brutal Strike to help with characters committed to 2h Sword. Heavenly Wave was improved, but the cool down is still too long for anything except PvP or Crypt. People can update any of the old posts about weapon choices:

Justicar Boss Rotation Comparison- 2h Axe (R= Expert+)
Sword vs Axe Pt 1 & Pt 2 (R= Expert+)

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 22, 2014 11:19 am
Bj_Knows wrote:
Celestial_Cavalier wrote:Actually even with the lower than expected damage I believe I ended up better. My damage went down approx 2.8% but attack speed went up by approx 8.4% (from 0.71 secs to 0.65 secs). I havnt tried doing onslaught yet because of the event but I will share my results once I do a couple.

Axe's biggest contribution to Onslaught Phases is Knockback and Periodic Damage (DOT). Its biggest contribution to Pop Phases is one hit, one kill Mobs.

Cleave rank 3 now does the same damage (160% Base Weapon Damage), and same casting time (100% Basic Attack Speed), as Brutal Strike to help with characters committed to 2h Sword. Heavenly Wave was improved, but the cool down is still too long for anything except PvP or Crypt. People can update any of the old posts about weapon choices:

Justicar Boss Rotation Comparison- 2h Axe (R= Expert+)
Sword vs Axe Pt 1 & Pt 2 (R= Expert+)

I find heavenly wave quite useful in high level onslaught, it has decent damage but mainly because its another spirit attack for a magic-focused Justicar. I end up rotating condemn with smite, wave and brutal depending on what's on cooldown and whether heroic will is available.
Celestial_Cavalier wrote:Actually even with the lower than expected damage I believe I ended up better. My damage went down approx 2.8% but attack speed went up by approx 8.4% (from 0.71 secs to 0.65 secs). I havnt tried doing onslaught yet because of the event but I will share my results once I do a couple.

I'm not doing SW onslaught anymore (starting up DW is too much a PITA) and was an SW sword user already. However, even if you are 8.4% faster, the key is whether or not you can OHK. Even if you are faster, if you miss a kill slightly, you have to waste time with an additional action and end up effectively slower.

For 1H sword and 2H users, the new weapon was all win. For axe users, there are tradeoffs unfortunately.