Book of Heroes

Caltrops · page 2

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Wed Dec 17, 2014 1:53 pm
KoD_Entropy wrote:Only if caltrops, etc also stops triggering ice armor...

I would have to agree. However, when caltrops would tick "retaliation" dmg should proc as well. Same as a flame tick or a bleed.

Maybe just the definitions need to be evaluated, as someone brought that up. I see inconsistencies, that's all.
iOption wrote:[
Maybe just the definitions need to be evaluated, as someone brought that up. I see inconsistencies, that's all.


agreed. seems like what things say is not what they do
Jumper wrote:And then which abilities should proc urgency? the list of questions goes on.....

ANY active ability that does > 0 damage.
Same thing should be applied to Spike Armor, Vengeance and Arcane Shield.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Dec 17, 2014 5:06 pm
Tbh it's an even approach from Venan regarding which abilities proc others.

Eg Ice Spike Armour always procs. Doesn't matter if it's something that causes damage. Would it do enough damage to be worth the points if not?

Urgency can be procced from pretty much any ability that affects the character. This makes sense as it has such a low proc rate to begin with. Same with Arcane Shield. Virtually anything can proc it but also almost anything can drop it. Pretty fair. If it were changed, arcane shield would either be dropped pretty quickly from most PvP builds as it would not proc often enough to make the 3 points worth it, or it would be up all the time. Same goes for urgency. Things that don't proc often need to have a chance to trigger from almost anything.

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Wed Dec 17, 2014 5:45 pm
I can only disagree.

The proc of AS would be determined by being "hit" according to the description on the passive ability. If caltrops does not hit, then the ability is incorrectly described. However, if they do hit then a stun should be negated. Same would go for the grenade - if it is sticking to me and I'm stunned then it should disrupt the stun. Or since I'm in a net (ensnare) the grenade can't be put on while stunned since It would be on the net and technically not on myself.

I don't want to get to crazy on it but there needs to be some twerking with the text on the descriptions. Personally I feel there needs to be heavy balancing involved in PvP. Across the board.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Dec 17, 2014 8:13 pm
iOption wrote:I can only disagree.

The proc of AS would be determined by being "hit" according to the description on the passive ability. If caltrops does not hit, then the ability is incorrectly described. However, if they do hit then a stun should be negated. Same would go for the grenade - if it is sticking to me and I'm stunned then it should disrupt the stun. Or since I'm in a net (ensnare) the grenade can't be put on while stunned since It would be on the net and technically not on myself.

I don't want to get to crazy on it but there needs to be some twerking with the text on the descriptions. Personally I feel there needs to be heavy balancing involved in PvP. Across the board.

Just to clarify - the ability descriptions have needed a rework for a while. A lot of them don't 100% match how the abilities work in PvP. It's a slightly different question as to whether (for example) caltrops should proc wrath or arcane shield. To solve both, they need to look at which abilities proc which abilities, whether those need to be changed (unlikely) or whether they need to update the ability descriptions to accurately affect how the actually work (more likely). I suspect the majority of mechanical effects are as designed and it's simply the text that is throwing things off.

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Thu Dec 18, 2014 3:50 pm
You might have me onto something. It might not be caltrops that needs the work done to it.

The time spent while stunned might need to be looked into as a whole - Justi, Mage and SW.

Love these type of discussions. Appreciate the back and forth.