Book of Heroes

Caltrops

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Mon Dec 15, 2014 4:09 pm
If caltrops does no damage why does it remove a Mage's shield that is to absorb the next incoming damage? Same goes with the grenade - if no damage is committed then it shouldn't remove the absorb shield. There is nothing to absorb!

You need to fix that.

Or enable the casts of caltrops / gernade to break ensnare stuns, since there is some form of affliction being committed with the act.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Dec 15, 2014 4:59 pm
iOption wrote:If caltrops does no damage why does it remove a Mage's shield that is to absorb the next incoming damage? Same goes with the grenade - if no damage is committed then it shouldn't remove the absorb shield. There is nothing to absorb!

You need to fix that.

Or enable the casts of caltrops / gernade to break ensnare stuns, since there is some form of affliction being committed with the act.

So long as they also take away the ability for arcane shield to proc when non-damaging abilities are used. I suspect this is why they've never done what you ask - most passive powers proc when another ability is actively used (like smoke, stun, caltrops etc). For shield to remain up when you use caltrops, they would have to remove its ability to be procced by caltrops too. Otherwise it's proc rate would be too heavily skewed one way or another.
I still dont like the fact that if an arcane is up and you defend it cancels the defend... Well it used to havent used mage recently
NBW_Tyler wrote:I still dont like the fact that if an arcane is up and you defend it cancels the defend... Well it used to havent used mage recently

Latest update notes said that this was due to be fixed. I've not pvp'd since, so can't confirm, but it's worth trying.

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Mon Dec 15, 2014 6:45 pm
You don't take damage therefore not being "hit" in accordance with the term used on the ability. It shouldn't proc with those skills being thrown at it. When caltrops is thrown it shouldn't proc the shield nor take it away.
iOption wrote:You don't take damage therefore not being "hit" in accordance with the term used on the ability. It shouldn't proc with those skills being thrown at it. When caltrops is thrown it shouldn't proc the shield nor take it away.

When was being hit defined as taking damage? It you remove the ability of the SW to place caltrops and grenade while the opponent is stunned you might as well remove the SW class. Each class has plus and minus and each ability doesn't always work as hoped. When placing caltrops on a stunned opponent and arcane pops up it kind of sucks... But that exchange is part of what makes the game unpredictable and to me more entertaining if not a little frustrating at times.
Oden357 wrote:
iOption wrote:You don't take damage therefore not being "hit" in accordance with the term used on the ability. It shouldn't proc with those skills being thrown at it. When caltrops is thrown it shouldn't proc the shield nor take it away.

When was being hit defined as taking damage? It you remove the ability of the SW to place caltrops and grenade while the opponent is stunned you might as well remove the SW class. Each class has plus and minus and each ability doesn't always work as hoped. When placing caltrops on a stunned opponent and arcane pops up it kind of sucks... But that exchange is part of what makes the game unpredictable and to me more entertaining if not a little frustrating at times.

I don't think he is talking about the ability to place them just their ability to proc/remove shield.

As a mage does it even matter as you're so OP!
BaneFirerises wrote:
Oden357 wrote:
iOption wrote:You don't take damage therefore not being "hit" in accordance with the term used on the ability. It shouldn't proc with those skills being thrown at it. When caltrops is thrown it shouldn't proc the shield nor take it away.

When was being hit defined as taking damage? It you remove the ability of the SW to place caltrops and grenade while the opponent is stunned you might as well remove the SW class. Each class has plus and minus and each ability doesn't always work as hoped. When placing caltrops on a stunned opponent and arcane pops up it kind of sucks... But that exchange is part of what makes the game unpredictable and to me more entertaining if not a little frustrating at times.

I don't think he is talking about the ability to place them just their ability to proc/remove shield.

As a mage does it even matter as you're so OP!

His alternate solution was to make placing them break snare. I'm fine with them not procing AS as long as snare goes back to not doing any damage and therefore not procing AS.