CheMClarc wrote:What makes Shadow Walkers an underdog in a battle with a War Mage is the triggering of Ice Spike Armor and Arcane Shield.
When I did do pvp with an SW (up to Plat2), Arcane was never an issue. The 2 main factors (based on my experience with my SW and WM, and on conversations with others) were:
1. SWs rely on Dodge as a Defence, as their armour is light. Against magic (all WM attacks), a dodged attack still does 50% damage and generally includes a status as well that has to be resisted separately. Most WM attacks inflict very high damage, and a dodged WM attack can often inflict more direct damage than an undodged SW attack.
2. Ice Spike Armour as Chem described.
What this meant in practice was that with every action I take, I take damage. With every action the WM takes, I take damage and frequently a status as well. Added to the 1h-only lower damage output from an SW, meaning more hits are necessary (which can be dodged if Physical), hence more Ice Spike.
Unless Dodge is amended vs Magic attacks, SWs will continue to be easy prey for WMs in particular (Magic Justis and SWs don't have the double-whammy of damaging you every time you hit them, so are slightly easier to handle than a WM).
It may well be different in the heights of Masters, but most of us weren't / aren't in Masters, so what happens there is kinda irrelevant to the majority.