Book of Heroes

Two PvP Leagues · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Feb 9, 2015 8:43 am
EricM wrote:If the conspiracy theory held any weight, I wouldn't be able to win 30+ matches in a row. If the game is forcing you to lose or screw up rolls, huge win streaks shouldn't be possible. As every 20k might who has beat me knows, sometimes the math just works against you. But it is just math, no conspiracy.

Else If there is one, it only affects certain players ;)

That's because you're good Eric ;)

But seriously I don't buy it and many others don't. Maybe the issues don't affect Masters, or at the very top these little things don't affect the best pvpers because they are the best and their builds/gear/rotation/enchants are that solid. For most though, the 'it's just math/luck' effect seems to strike that bit too often. We're not saying the game forces you to lose, just that if you hit a certain mark, everything starts going against you. It happens all the time to multiple players. At first I thought it ridiculous but after hundreds of bouts, I began to suspect something weird was going on. Not necessarily a 'conspiracy'. Even just now, I beat a toon one league below and gained +5 rating. I lost to a Masters where the rating difference was similar and got -14 for the trouble. I don't see consistency in whatever drives the minigame from the back end.
Ilyana wrote:Problem is, there are still people blundering about with high might in say Gold I, who come up against lower toons and have an automatic edge against them. Their winrate however stays near .5 because they can't beat better Gold Is or Plat IIIs. Having 62k might in anything below platinum is an advantage. In lower leagues people have worse gear and gems on average. I'd like to see some kind of might modifier applied to the rewards and +/- rating moves afterward, so that when the 62k blitzes the 26k who is really good at PvP (hence Gold I) but can't take two 12k crits from even a bad PvP player, their losses reflect that.

As for the conspiracy theory, there's no proof either way unfortunately. We have zero way of knowing how the 'backend' of Venan's software works and thus no way to confirm or deny it. In theory you'd assume the system doesn't do what Acid suggests, but it's been observed by so many people it's kept the issue going in the community. So many people with high resists for example regularly get matches where they resist 0-2 status effects and their opponent with fewer gets virtually all their resist checks come up as successes. All it takes is a few resists to come up in some matches for it to throw the bout completely the other way.

If a 26k might player is in gold 1, it means he is very good, ofc he cant get to plat 1 with that might(cause there is too many players that are good at pvp too and have more might), but once he raise his might a bit(which is going pretty fast in that might range) he will be in plat 2 in no time, while the one with 62k might will be stuck there forever(cause he is not good at pvp). This is where we can see that skill in pvp is important too. Its like this in every mmorpg, to get higher you need equip and skill. If you have good equip, but dont have skill, you get stuck in middle(gold 2), if you have skill, but dont have equip, you get stuck in middle too. Once the equiped dude improves his skill, he can move higher and once the skilled dude gets better equip, he move higher.

As for the conspiracy theory, this is nothing more than selective memory, its easier to remember unlucky loose than lucky win. And as for the winning/loosing streak, its like that everywhere, take live poker, once you are on good wave, you can play every hand and board hits you hard and you suck out other players, once you are down, you loose every hand... And venan is not controling that :)
EricM wrote:If the conspiracy theory held any weight, I wouldn't be able to win 30+ matches in a row. If the game is forcing you to lose or screw up rolls, huge win streaks shouldn't be possible.


That's cause you're lucky and don't get matched up against Slick very often!

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Feb 9, 2015 10:55 am
svako wrote:
Ilyana wrote:Problem is, there are still people blundering about with high might in say Gold I, who come up against lower toons and have an automatic edge against them. Their winrate however stays near .5 because they can't beat better Gold Is or Plat IIIs. Having 62k might in anything below platinum is an advantage. In lower leagues people have worse gear and gems on average. I'd like to see some kind of might modifier applied to the rewards and +/- rating moves afterward, so that when the 62k blitzes the 26k who is really good at PvP (hence Gold I) but can't take two 12k crits from even a bad PvP player, their losses reflect that.

As for the conspiracy theory, there's no proof either way unfortunately. We have zero way of knowing how the 'backend' of Venan's software works and thus no way to confirm or deny it. In theory you'd assume the system doesn't do what Acid suggests, but it's been observed by so many people it's kept the issue going in the community. So many people with high resists for example regularly get matches where they resist 0-2 status effects and their opponent with fewer gets virtually all their resist checks come up as successes. All it takes is a few resists to come up in some matches for it to throw the bout completely the other way.

If a 26k might player is in gold 1, it means he is very good, ofc he cant get to plat 1 with that might(cause there is too many players that are good at pvp too and have more might), but once he raise his might a bit(which is going pretty fast in that might range) he will be in plat 2 in no time, while the one with 62k might will be stuck there forever(cause he is not good at pvp). This is where we can see that skill in pvp is important too. Its like this in every mmorpg, to get higher you need equip and skill. If you have good equip, but dont have skill, you get stuck in middle(gold 2), if you have skill, but dont have equip, you get stuck in middle too. Once the equiped dude improves his skill, he can move higher and once the skilled dude gets better equip, he move higher.

As for the conspiracy theory, this is nothing more than selective memory, its easier to remember unlucky loose than lucky win. And as for the winning/loosing streak, its like that everywhere, take live poker, once you are on good wave, you can play every hand and board hits you hard and you suck out other players, once you are down, you loose every hand... And venan is not controling that :)

Correct, you need both gear and skill. But where the 62k has an advantage is that his attacks will always hit harder and help get him out of trouble. It happens up and down PvP. People in masters don't often see it.

Selective memory...hmm debatable. I remember my lucky wins and acknowledge them as such. So I understand what you're saying but it's not the case that everyone is just not remembering their lucky wins. Give people some credit.
I have 200 matches of analyzed data that says that the RNG does a very poor job of keeping the "math" at where it's supposed to be. I don't even look at wins/losses. Anytime the RNG puts your averages back to where they should be in 3-4 matches after going 20-30 matches well below average, you have an enormous problem, as I have seen with my data. Facts trump blind loyalty any day.
EricM wrote:

One could be max level with 8000 might.... or with 70,000 might. How would that be a fair match up?

Also, if the 50% win rate was removed, people who lose more than 50% of the time would slowly stop pvping - thus leading to even less people pvping.... which is the exact opposite of what venan's trying to accomplish.


Because there wouldn't be a might difference in the one league call it pvp training everyone would have the same might from gems and equipment.

The main league would run the same as it does now. The other would give people a chance to play something closer to what masters are playing now with more people involved.
pvp is just fine at it is.
enchants could be reworked to define more clearly pvp-enchants and pve-enchant. well and the thing that we have to transfer enchants to new pvp set every seasons is such a b*tchmove of venan..

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Feb 10, 2015 8:23 am
Frozensoul wrote:pvp is just fine at it is.
enchants could be reworked to define more clearly pvp-enchants and pve-enchant. well and the thing that we have to transfer enchants to new pvp set every seasons is such a b*tchmove of venan..

It's really not fine.

However I agree about the enchants. I always thought double enchants plus PvP gear was a bit of a step too far. But then they came up with 'Arcane Transfer' so you can see the thought processes behind that one. Transferring enchants should be free. They cost enough materials as it is.

Shë_Wølf_Ãrî

Wed Feb 11, 2015 3:06 pm
I have to say first. This is the only game that I have played where I like PvP.

Now I would like to say I would like to see a second PvP. My thoughts was as simple as that the other PvP enchants and PvP bonus would be canceled out. That all that would count would be gear and gems. I think itself be fun to see how far you can get with just regular might and skill. For me I think it would be interesting and fun enough I wouldn't care about any rewards, they could be far lower or even a different type than regular PvP.

For regular PvP, I think the only thing it really lacks is a way to keep people from losing down on purpose to get easy wins as they go back up. Imo that I admit I could be wrong. But them doing that knocks other players down that they are then knocking other players down to win back up, add in the players that don't play that often and you have an ugly cycle that has become never ending.

Pretty much I no longer enjoy PvP, as I once did. Not when in season 1 I got to gold 2, and in season 2 with better gear and enchants and such I get run up and down from gold 3 to barely touch into gold 1. From my perspective I feel as if I wasted time and marks as well as enchanting materials to get better gear to only be at a stand still or doing worse at PvP.