Book of Heroes

Two PvP Leagues

Just wondering if it would be plausible to add a second league to PvP next season. One in which the level of your equipment, gems and enchants do not matter. This would allow for everyone to have matches on a somewhat even playing field. If you used a separate energy system and had rewards win based but less than the regular PvP people would likely still play both. You could even have daily and/or weekly rewards for most wins, highest win percentage etc.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Feb 8, 2015 4:54 pm
Vilteran wrote:Just wondering if it would be plausible to add a second league to PvP next season. One in which the level of your equipment, gems and enchants do not matter. This would allow for everyone to have matches on a somewhat even playing field. If you used a separate energy system and had rewards win based but less than the regular PvP people would likely still play both. You could even have daily and/or weekly rewards for most wins, highest win percentage etc.

One where matches weren't decided on coin flips would be attractive to a lot of people.
Vilteran wrote:Just wondering if it would be plausible to add a second league to PvP next season. One in which the level of your equipment, gems and enchants do not matter. This would allow for everyone to have matches on a somewhat even playing field. If you used a separate energy system and had rewards win based but less than the regular PvP people would likely still play both. You could even have daily and/or weekly rewards for most wins, highest win percentage etc.

If nothing mattered in matchmaking, matching would be utterly random.... which would mean every fight would be extremely mismatched. Wouldn't that lead to more complaints?
The worst thing is when you're forced to lose when you outplay someone just to balance the books. May as well just auto attack every time. If it's to be "within 50% win lose with a +-5% tolerance" then by that logic I can do that and still win and stay plat
Types of gems would still matter as would types of enchants. It just wouldn't matter if it was tier 2 or 6. Mismatches would be because of poor play or build not because you get matched up against someone double your might. It would make for a cheaper way to test new builds and strategies. Hopefully the 50% win would be removed because technically everyone would be on a level playing field if level was taken into account.
Vilteran wrote:Types of gems would still matter as would types of enchants. It just wouldn't matter if it was tier 2 or 6. Mismatches would be because of poor play or build not because you get matched up against someone double your might. It would make for a cheaper way to test new builds and strategies. Hopefully the 50% win would be removed because technically everyone would be on a level playing field if level was taken into account.

One could be max level with 8000 might.... or with 70,000 might. How would that be a fair match up?

Also, if the 50% win rate was removed, people who lose more than 50% of the time would slowly stop pvping - thus leading to even less people pvping.... which is the exact opposite of what venan's trying to accomplish.
If we have two PvP leagues, can we have a regular pace one and a speed one (5 second timer)? I might actually do a tiny bit of PvP then.
If you have a league where equipment doesnt matter, why should anyone try to get better one? About those "missmatches", if you fight twice your might opponent in your league, there must be a reason for that. For example if someone is 60k might and still stuck in gold 2 league, it means he is doing something wrong and you have good chance to beat him. Same is for opposite, if you are 42k might in plat 1, it means you are good and you will get matched with higher might opponents in same league.
_ACID_ wrote:The worst thing is when you're forced to lose when you outplay someone just to balance the books. May as well just auto attack every time. If it's to be "within 50% win lose with a +-5% tolerance" then by that logic I can do that and still win and stay plat

This is just conspiration theory. You cant loose fight just because venan wants it that way. Once the match starts, its all about RNG. There is no such thing as coin flip in match. For example if i catch my opponent with undefended seismic and he have 25% dodge and 12% block chance, he has 34% chance to avoid it by procing one of them. Chance to do it 2 times in a row(two matches in a row) is 11,56%. Its all about math...
Other example: if I have 27% status resist and my opponent have only 21% status resist it doesnt mean I will resist more in one match. He can still resist my stun and land his stun on me in the same match...
The point is, you cant win every match, but not because venan dont want you to, but because math wont allow it.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Feb 9, 2015 8:02 am
svako wrote:If you have a league where equipment doesnt matter, why should anyone try to get better one? About those "missmatches", if you fight twice your might opponent in your league, there must be a reason for that. For example if someone is 60k might and still stuck in gold 2 league, it means he is doing something wrong and you have good chance to beat him. Same is for opposite, if you are 42k might in plat 1, it means you are good and you will get matched with higher might opponents in same league.
_ACID_ wrote:The worst thing is when you're forced to lose when you outplay someone just to balance the books. May as well just auto attack every time. If it's to be "within 50% win lose with a +-5% tolerance" then by that logic I can do that and still win and stay plat

This is just conspiration theory. You cant loose fight just because venan wants it that way. Once the match starts, its all about RNG. There is no such thing as coin flip in match. For example if i catch my opponent with undefended seismic and he have 25% dodge and 12% block chance, he has 34% chance to avoid it by procing one of them. Chance to do it 2 times in a row(two matches in a row) is 11,56%. Its all about math...
Other example: if I have 27% status resist and my opponent have only 21% status resist it doesnt mean I will resist more in one match. He can still resist my stun and land his stun on me in the same match...
The point is, you cant win every match, but not because venan dont want you to, but because math wont allow it.

Problem is, there are still people blundering about with high might in say Gold I, who come up against lower toons and have an automatic edge against them. Their winrate however stays near .5 because they can't beat better Gold Is or Plat IIIs. Having 62k might in anything below platinum is an advantage. In lower leagues people have worse gear and gems on average. I'd like to see some kind of might modifier applied to the rewards and +/- rating moves afterward, so that when the 62k blitzes the 26k who is really good at PvP (hence Gold I) but can't take two 12k crits from even a bad PvP player, their losses reflect that.

As for the conspiracy theory, there's no proof either way unfortunately. We have zero way of knowing how the 'backend' of Venan's software works and thus no way to confirm or deny it. In theory you'd assume the system doesn't do what Acid suggests, but it's been observed by so many people it's kept the issue going in the community. So many people with high resists for example regularly get matches where they resist 0-2 status effects and their opponent with fewer gets virtually all their resist checks come up as successes. All it takes is a few resists to come up in some matches for it to throw the bout completely the other way.
If the conspiracy theory held any weight, I wouldn't be able to win 30+ matches in a row. If the game is forcing you to lose or screw up rolls, huge win streaks shouldn't be possible. As every 20k might who has beat me knows, sometimes the math just works against you. But it is just math, no conspiracy.

Else If there is one, it only affects certain players ;)