Book of Heroes

pvp is a total joke right now, Keep it civil

I dont know about you, but im fed up with pvp in its current state. there us literally 0 skill involved. every game is the same as a shadow walker vs justi/war mage. open caltrops they open time void into frozen shard into fiery lash into icy grasp into snap cast into incin and then MAYBE youll see the first deviation. its literally just a luck role and I want to know when will there finally be a total 100% overhaul of pvp so that skilled players actually shine out from the rest? First you could start by doubling the life we have, second you could allow for deviation by actually changing up skills a bit so it isnt the same thing over and over again, third actually change 2 hand classes so they dont ridiculously outclass 1 hand variants. pvp is a joke atm, you lose 200 rating you get 200 rating and ultimately you couldnt do anything about it.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Feb 12, 2015 10:01 am
Happiness wrote:I dont know about you, but im fed up with pvp in its current state. there us literally 0 skill involved. every game is the same as a shadow walker vs justi/war mage. open caltrops they open time void into frozen shard into fiery lash into icy grasp into snap cast into incin and then MAYBE youll see the first deviation. its literally just a luck role and I want to know when will there finally be a total 100% overhaul of pvp so that skilled players actually shine out from the rest? First you could start by doubling the life we have, second you could allow for deviation by actually changing up skills a bit so it isnt the same thing over and over again, third actually change 2 hand classes so they dont ridiculously outclass 1 hand variants. pvp is a joke atm, you lose 200 rating you get 200 rating and ultimately you couldnt do anything about it.

Q: I thinks PvP should be 100% Skill.
A: Tic Tac Toe is 100% Skill. But it is boring once both players have mastered its skills. Other games use increasingly complex rules to restrict your options. BoH rules say, you have to earn, or buy, Tier 17/ 18 Gear, Enchants Rank 9, Full Tomes and Tier 7 Gems before you can use them in any combat, including PvP.
Bj's PvP FAQ (improved)

Several people have suggested a version of PvP where all players use a copy of the #1 Justicar, Shadow Walker, and War Mage in PvP Ratings. Venan has so far declined to implement this option.

see below for the rest of your questions:

PvP is growing on me since realized Gear>Enchants>Gems>Skill>Available Opponents (so stealing that Macrene). so Cassidy just chilling in Bronze I.
Bj's PvP FAQ (improved)

In my experience it is currently it is impossible to Tank in PvP. This goes back to the problem of Monster Health/ Defense versus Player Health/ Defense that hurts the Shadow Walker (Note 2). The problem is most easily seen in the Health Multiplier for PvP versus PvE combat.

The situation is further aggravated by all the Enchants that enhance damage (1H, 2H, Fire, Ice, Spirit, Nature, AP, Initiative, Accuracy, etc) and the three Enchants that enhance Defense (Defense, Block & Block Power). Block Power is pretty useless by itself, since Block has the better numbers (Note 3). Even the Coliseum Gear set give the equivalent of a +20% 1H or 2H Enchant.

I no longer use Stagger in PvP since you cannot Tank. I use Neurotoxic Stab rank 1 for its Damage Per Second, so I never use rank 2- 3. I use Blight Runes to finish off a group of Mobs with low Health, not to reduce their damage, so I only buy Spirit, Frost and Fire Runes (depending on character).

Current version of BoH appears to be all about the DPS (see Elixir of Speed popularity).
Justicar 1h vs 2h. Play Nice.

Q: I lost a huge amount of Ratings, but when I won, I only got a little back.
A: You should only look at your PvP Rating after each Weekly Reward mail from Venan. After each single PvP Bout your rating can fluctuate a huge amount, since it depends entirely on the outcome of the Bout, the two ratings before the Bout, and Statistics.

It is similar to the way your *exact* weigh fluctuates. After you eat or drink or put on clothing, your exact weight will go up. After you use the toilet, take off clothing, your exact weight will go down.

To demonstrate this, weigh yourself every 15 minutes for a week.

Q: I don’t have that time.
A: Weigh yourself every 15 minutes for 4 hours.

Q: Still don’t have the time.
A: Then you will have to take my word for it.
Bj's PvP FAQ (improved)

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Thu Feb 12, 2015 10:10 am
Happiness wrote:I dont know about you, but im fed up with pvp in its current state. there us literally 0 skill involved. every game is the same as a shadow walker vs justi/war mage. open caltrops they open time void into frozen shard into fiery lash into icy grasp into snap cast into incin and then MAYBE youll see the first deviation. its literally just a luck role and I want to know when will there finally be a total 100% overhaul of pvp so that skilled players actually shine out from the rest? First you could start by doubling the life we have, second you could allow for deviation by actually changing up skills a bit so it isnt the same thing over and over again, third actually change 2 hand classes so they dont ridiculously outclass 1 hand variants. pvp is a joke atm, you lose 200 rating you get 200 rating and ultimately you couldnt do anything about it.
YES! DOUBLE OUR HP! That way, i have 48k hp, while one of my guildies would have nearly 90k in pvp. ABSOLUTELY GENIUS IDEA! If they increase health, they're gonna increase damage, then you'll keep complaining. Just grow a pair and take your losses like a man. And in ways of 2h out-classing 1h, we lose A LOT of speed in exchange for damage. We lose a huge portion of block chance because we don't have shields. Yes, 2h definitely outclasses 1h because we hit harder and have high kb. Again, grow a pair and take your losses like a man.
I have always thought that if they got rid of the ability timers it would be more skill based rather than time based
Part of the issue is that to infuse more "skill" into pvp would require a significant overhaul of the game with significantly more tiers of abilities per class. Something like 7 tiers of 5 abilities each, with a tier unlocked every 5 levels up through 35. Outside of that, with 35 skill points and only 20 abilities to choose from, every class has virtually two builds (poison/melee sw, spirit/melee justi, reg wm/op wm).

Balancing all that with pve would be a nightmare. That said though, one simpler solution to make pvp less luck based, would be to simply return defense enchants to their pre-nerfed state and refocus the next few updates on defense rather than offense.

Multiplying hp by any number only serves to create longer matches all around, which would remove an element of luck true, but would increase match times significantly which isn't very popular either.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Feb 12, 2015 2:26 pm
Bj_Knows wrote:Guys, keep it civil and avoid ad hominem attacks, straw man arguments, etc.

Lol those are de rigeur for these forums.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Feb 12, 2015 2:29 pm
EricM wrote:Part of the issue is that to infuse more "skill" into pvp would require a significant overhaul of the game with significantly more tiers of abilities per class. Something like 7 tiers of 5 abilities each, with a tier unlocked every 5 levels up through 35. Outside of that, with 35 skill points and only 20 abilities to choose from, every class has virtually two builds (poison/melee sw, spirit/melee justi, reg wm/op wm).

Balancing all that with pve would be a nightmare. That said though, one simpler solution to make pvp less luck based, would be to simply return defense enchants to their pre-nerfed state and refocus the next few updates on defense rather than offense.

Multiplying hp by any number only serves to create longer matches all around, which would remove an element of luck true, but would increase match times significantly which isn't very popular either.

There have been calls to separate PvE and PvP abilities for (probably) years now. That way they could mess about with either as much as they wanted and it wouldn't affect overall balance in the other.

But they didn't do that. PvP will always have the huge luck component by the looks of it. It was promising in beta but the final implementation didn't impress many folk.
Zombie_Princess_Kenny wrote:
Happiness wrote:I dont know about you, but im fed up with pvp in its current state. there us literally 0 skill involved. every game is the same as a shadow walker vs justi/war mage. open caltrops they open time void into frozen shard into fiery lash into icy grasp into snap cast into incin and then MAYBE youll see the first deviation. its literally just a luck role and I want to know when will there finally be a total 100% overhaul of pvp so that skilled players actually shine out from the rest? First you could start by doubling the life we have, second you could allow for deviation by actually changing up skills a bit so it isnt the same thing over and over again, third actually change 2 hand classes so they dont ridiculously outclass 1 hand variants. pvp is a joke atm, you lose 200 rating you get 200 rating and ultimately you couldnt do anything about it.
YES! DOUBLE OUR HP! That way, i have 48k hp, while one of my guildies would have nearly 90k in pvp. ABSOLUTELY GENIUS IDEA! If they increase health, they're gonna increase damage, then you'll keep complaining. Just grow a pair and take your losses like a man. And in ways of 2h out-classing 1h, we lose A LOT of speed in exchange for damage. We lose a huge portion of block chance because we don't have shields. Yes, 2h definitely outclasses 1h because we hit harder and have high kb. Again, grow a pair and take your losses like a man.
thats the point.... damage would stay the same with double health so people would stop going full yolo 18 magic/melee gems and then its just rng if you crit/dodge/resist 3 moves. that has to go
Happiness wrote:
thats the point.... damage would stay the same with double health so people would stop going full yolo 18 magic/melee gems and then its just rng if you crit/dodge/resist 3 moves. that has to go

Just to play devil's advocate for the moment - in the absence of larger balancing implementations, letting people go "full yolo" can be construed as a separate build thus providing increased build-variety. If "full-yolo-ing" no longer became possible, without further ability tiers, everyone would have literally the same build.