Book of Heroes

Big changes in the abilities

I would suggest a revision of the abilities. I would see 2 big changes.

1. Do not force the 4 first rank abilities. Some are useless and this or these point(s) could be spend in another ability.

2. Make a last rank ability a little bit more powerful, but they would require a "specialisation". Like for the war mage an ability that activate Combustion instantly but require like at least 10 points in fire abilities ahead.

This game is really great though, but this ability section definitly bothers me :)

Hope I will be heard :p

Little_Mike

Site AdminMon Jul 9, 2012 7:37 pm
We have already addressed #1 in the next client build. For easing new players along, it will still force the first four ranks when you level up. However, if you respec, you will be able to move those points to other abilities.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Mon Jul 9, 2012 11:27 pm
Perhaps what your saying is more of an ultimate ability, the king upon the knights, etc...

I agree, my war Mage basically only uses tier 1, besides maybe fracture, the tier 3 abilities have NO damage capabilities, and tier 2 is only a minor output. Yes yes, debuffs can do a whole lot (I noticed in final fantasy) but the fact that the first few abilities you learn should not be what you are using for the later parts.

Anyway.. I'm done ranting, suggestion time.

The mastery tier, the fourth and final display of power. This tier introduces 3 new abilities, usually 2 DPS and one buff/debuff. You must be at least level 15, and have a certain amount of ability points put toward a single idea of mastery. This will prove dedication and possibly add a goal to abilities, or form more of a skill tree. You may only learn one ability from this tier.

Icy Orb

Mastery Tier

Requires 7 points spent in Ice, 15 spent altogether.

Create a large mist of cold, taking shape of a small ball which periodically launches shards of ice at an enemy, dealing 75/100/125% Weapon Damage per second to a single enemy for 3 seconds. DOES NOT STACK! 1.4 second use, 5 second cooldown.


Fiery Funnel

Mastery Tier

Requires 7 points spent in fire spells, 15 altogether.

Summon a large pillar of fire to consume your enemies. Blazes all enemies for 150/200/250% Weapon Damage. 1.3 second use, 5 second cooldown.

Static Charge

Mastery Tier

Requires max haste, max arcane barrier, and max of the magic damage buff, 15 points spent altogether.

Supercharge yourself into an utterly stronger being, increasing attack speed by 15%, damage by 25%, dodge chance by 10%, and defense by 50% for 3/4/5 seconds. 0.9 second use, 10 second cooldown.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:I agree, my war Mage basically only uses tier 1, besides maybe fracture, the tier 3 abilities have NO damage capabilities, and tier 2 is only a minor output. Yes yes, debuffs can do a whole lot (I noticed in final fantasy) but the fact that the first few abilities you learn should not be what you are using for the later parts.
I disagree. If "the first few abilities you learn" became outdated as levels are gained, the respec mechanism would be a necessity, rather than a tool to optimize a character. Vanilla Diablo II was particularly bad about this, as it deliberately excluded any possibility of respec, forcing people to shop-hunt for +3 glacial spike staffs, for example, because it was unquestionably better to reserve points for frozen orb 12 levels later.

In BoH, damage-dealing abilities are learned early, as they must be, but are later enhanced by debuffs (Fractures) and buffs (Inner Power, Haste). The combat system lends itself to this; status effects are usually more useful than raw damage, especially those that affect timing. This isn't a flaw in the game; it's a design choice far superior to the one you're proposing - and which all too many other games, unfortunately, do follow.

I prefer skills to be unique, rather than repetitive. There's no need for an Improved Incinerate more powerful than Incinerate3, or some such.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Tue Jul 10, 2012 8:22 pm
Marney wrote:
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:I agree, my war Mage basically only uses tier 1, besides maybe fracture, the tier 3 abilities have NO damage capabilities, and tier 2 is only a minor output. Yes yes, debuffs can do a whole lot (I noticed in final fantasy) but the fact that the first few abilities you learn should not be what you are using for the later parts.
I disagree. If "the first few abilities you learn" became outdated as levels are gained, the respec mechanism would be a necessity, rather than a tool to optimize a character. Vanilla Diablo II was particularly bad about this, as it deliberately excluded any possibility of respec, forcing people to shop-hunt for +3 glacial spike staffs, for example, because it was unquestionably better to reserve points for frozen orb 12 levels later.

In BoH, damage-dealing abilities are learned early, as they must be, but are later enhanced by debuffs (Fractures) and buffs (Inner Power, Haste). The combat system lends itself to this; status effects are usually more useful than raw damage, especially those that affect timing. This isn't a flaw in the game; it's a design choice far superior to the one you're proposing - and which all too many other games, unfortunately, do follow.

I prefer skills to be unique, rather than repetitive. There's no need for an Improved Incinerate more powerful than Incinerate3, or some such.

I understand, fellow Diablo 2 player.

But would you rather Lightning and above to be debuffs? This way you could be stuck using static field and charged bolt at level 70?


And as a Necromancer, teeth, or bone spirit? I'm just saying there is little damage output of tier 2 and 3, maybe there could be at least ONE Dmg spell in tier 3 :/

Many have suggested the fractures be combined, which would leave a damage slot.


Arnt you glad when you unlock a new spell, to test it out and watch your enemies fall?
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:But would you rather Lightning and above to be debuffs? This way you could be stuck using static field and charged bolt at level 70?
Bad example. Didn't you ever hear of the Sparkler build? That was, well, Static Field and Charged Bolt. Quite effective too. And no one used plain ol' Lightning to attack.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:And as a Necromancer, teeth, or bone spirit?
Another bad example, given that those became synergies in LoD, along with the rest of the bone spells.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:I'm just saying there is little damage output of tier 2 and 3, maybe there could be at least ONE Dmg spell in tier 3
No, not if it made earlier spells obsolete. It would have to be substantively different in function in some way, not the same thing with higher damage and a separate cooldown.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:Many have suggested the fractures be combined, which would leave a damage slot.
Yeah, that would have been me, here. Add an R and an E to your "many" and you'd be right. ;)
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:Arnt you glad when you unlock a new spell, to test it out and watch your enemies fall?
Depends. Is it actually new, or just an old spell with a new name and bigger numbers?