Book of Heroes

Guild alliances · page 2

japster

ModeratorSat Apr 13, 2013 4:00 pm
Rauhede wrote:

First off, I do believe "clan tags" as far as online gaming is concerned, started, as far as my knowledge goes, way back at the turn of the millennium with "Halo" sorry bro BoH was nowhere in those days...

You do understand when I say my guild started it...I meant we started it in BoH right -.-" Context my friend, context.

Halo didn't start clan tags. I can assure you clan tags started way long before the turn of the millennium.
TCG_japster wrote:
Rauhede wrote:

First off, I do believe "clan tags" as far as online gaming is concerned, started, as far as my knowledge goes, way back at the turn of the millennium with "Halo" sorry bro BoH was nowhere in those days...

You do understand when I say my guild started it...I meant we started it in BoH right -.-" Context my friend, context.

Halo didn't start clan tags. I can assure you clan tags started way long before the turn of the millennium.

Context yes, I understand Crimson warrior, please forgive me, I meant no disrespect...

And yes halo was one of the earliest to produce clans,.. Do you remember "Red vs Blue?"

And if we are getting real technical,.. "Phantasy Star on-line" was one of the earliest to produce the online real time based game... And I do believe players were forced into clans to bolster their own protection... Lol! In that game, you die, you're done, gotta start a lv1 avatar all over again! I don't care if you're level 206,.. You just got "rat packed" by a clan and now your monster Mage is no more! Forever!

Talking about ways to lose more gamers, lmao, they were the best at it... Lol
Hey japster,... Now that I've looked through your section again, I am starting to realize just what you are saying...

Perhaps this guild loyalty is not such a bad idea after all?... Only time will tell...

All I am asking is if there were possible ways to limit the amount of mercenary work to a specific list of allies without losing your bonus,.. Hence, "coalition force."

Please forgive my opinions earlier,.. So much speculation..!
Completely against coalitions. Each person I know who has a home guild and mercs has their personal favorite guilds to merc in and they are different. One guild I have been a member in, the GM had a favorite guild to merc in and meanwhile I couldn't stand the people in that guild.

Currently, my home guild is KOTOR and my preferred merc location is Kingdom. However, I'm the only person who shows up in both of those guilds on a regular basis. I don't want to lose that.
Rauhede wrote:Hey japster,... Now that I've looked through your section again, I am starting to realize just what you are saying...

Perhaps this guild loyalty is not such a bad idea after all?... Only time will tell...

All I am asking is if there were possible ways to limit the amount of mercenary work to a specific list of allies without losing your bonus,.. Hence, "coalition force."

Please forgive my opinions earlier,.. So much speculation..!

Yeah Rau, I really don't think this will be a bad change either - I'm excited for the update. I think that Venan didn't like the ever-growing 'merc' mentality, and decided to try to find a way to take away the incentive for players to act as mercenaries. However, I think they are inadvertently (or possibly purposely) punishing the more 'progressive' guilds that 'outsource' many of their raids to mercenaries. These guilds will need to bolster their ranks with higher might players or risk failing; so we may see another round of mergers/acquisitions taking place between guilds. This will also be a great opportunity for up-and-coming players to get into the top-tier guild of their choice...

I think we'll just have to wait and see how Venan executes...

-IMO|Dave
Tcg_japster, I'd have to disagree with you. Your tone and points sound very disapproving of mercing, but continually say you don't mind one way or another ;) Though, there's still plenty of pride in being associated with a guild. Sure, my clan tag is an identification, but its more than that. Although I merc 75% of my raids, I definitely associate myself as part of the Odan guilds. Guild loyalty and mercing aren't mutually exclusive. I still show up to the raids at my guild when I'm online, and fill the down time helping out other guilds.

I have faith thus far that venan will do a good job to preserve at least some form of mercing, but I'm really hoping that idea of "mercy mercing" is still viable in some form. The mercing community is/was one of my favorite aspects of this game.

Though more interestingly, InMyOffice, you're right, there may be a new wave of mergers and migrations to top guilds depending on how things work. Kind of excited to see where the game will lead in that direction.

japster

ModeratorSun Apr 14, 2013 1:43 am
To set the record straight.

There are two kinds of mercing in my eyes.

1. Mercing to help genuinely help guilds out who need help/helping friends whose raids are suffering/mercing sociably just to catch up with friends (although in this last case global chat/whisper/or even Kik and whatsapp works...).

2. Mercing because it's the most convenient way to gain might/valor etc. Guilds and loyalty don't really matter, but only about where a gold-raid is about to occur.

I strongly disapprove mercenaries in the 2nd type category. I have no issues with mercing in category 1. However my view is that mercing in category 1 can be solved with the 100 guild size limit. Assuming Venan does not make raiders any harder, having 100 members would mean being able to consolidate all your friends in one big happy guild to raid together as you always enjoy. If that's your purpose of mercing and raiding, 100 limit guild size + some coordination and management would solve this to a large extent.

But then you might go...but hey, I want to help my friends, but we only can find 2-3 common times to raid a day. I want more valor!

If you wanted/needed more valor, then you fall into category 2, because you want more valor than your guild/friends can possibly give you. This is clearly mercing not because you want to help others, but because you have your own personal, selfish wants.

As I stated in my post, mercing originated from category 1 but spawned the unhealthy (IMO it just reeks of selfishness and individualism) trend where some people no longer bothered about guilds or loyalty. Simultaneously, player in category 1 type started developing streaks of individualism too because they saw a chance to gain advantages for themselves. It starts with loyal guild members heading out to merc during down times, and because of such behavior, it allows merc-guilds to thrive, i.e. guilds that are more of raid-rooms than loyalty-based, capitalizing on the fact that everybody wants convenient valor.

I stress the word, CONVENIENT valor/rewards. I dislike that, because it goes against the notion of being rewarded for loyalty.

That's why I see v1.6 as a hope to balance and bridge the HUGE divide between mercing and staying put. Right now there's almost NO reason to stay put in a guild and every reason to leave your guild to merc the moment you have the opportunity.

As a final note, I do merc almost all the time, but under the category 1 situation (which explains why my alts are not even VG ready despite playing them for over 9 months because I help all sorts of weird low level guilds/raids). I use my alts to help out guilds that are in need of help whenever I have spare time to do so. I just don't talk or make my presence known in most guild chats besides my home guild (and a couple of other guilds where I am friendly with their core members), so it isn't surprising if there's a perception that I don't merc, when in fact I actually merc a lot with my alts.
Japster, most of us want to play when we have time with people we like. No more no less.

I think you are just as greedy as the mercs you rail against - it is just your greed is defined by guild standing and getting people to be loyal to your guild. You have the right to run your guild whatever way you see fit though.

Consolidate all my friends in one guild? That's laughable. Somehow since my friends are spread across 6-7 guilds and involve multiple GMs, I don't think they are going to get together in one place. Ok, I am taking Badd and Gin from TCG if that is how it is going to work. :lol:
Oda_tc5k_Idaten wrote: Guild loyalty and mercing aren't mutually exclusive. I still show up to the raids at my guild when I'm online, and fill the down time helping out other guilds.

I have faith thus far that venan will do a good job to preserve at least some form of mercing, but I'm really hoping that idea of "mercy mercing" is still viable in some form. The mercing community is/was one of my favorite aspects of this game.

Though more interestingly, InMyOffice, you're right, there may be a new wave of mergers and migrations to top guilds depending on how things work. Kind of excited to see where the game will lead in that direction.
I agree with Oda_Tc5k_Idaten on this, and am again happy my post has brought about the discussion it has, as this, along with the answers DH has 'hinted' at have been more than anything that has been heard in a long while.

Some may think my posts precipitously alarmist but I believe most have realized that by asking these 'devil's advocate' questions, which quite a few folks have been thinking about, the answers have more quickly fallen out for all to see.
-M

japster

ModeratorMon Apr 15, 2013 3:45 am
Bbbb wrote:Japster, most of us want to play when we have time with people we like. No more no less.

I think you are just as greedy as the mercs you rail against - it is just your greed is defined by guild standing and getting people to be loyal to your guild. You have the right to run your guild whatever way you see fit though.

Consolidate all my friends in one guild? That's laughable. Somehow since my friends are spread across 6-7 guilds and involve multiple GMs, I don't think they are going to get together in one place. Ok, I am taking Badd and Gin from TCG if that is how it is going to work. :lol:

To be honest I wouldn't mind a big happy merger if all my friends are onboard. I have a lot less ego than some other GMs in this game than they would care to admit ;)

And that's what I see the game as. It isn't so much the "name of the guild", but the people you are with. If the guild size has limited the friends I can raid together with, then increasing guild size should allow me to bring all my friends from across various guilds to come together. I honestly don't see why some other players or GMs are so stuck up to a guild name and refuse to breach that barrier to come together to raid with their friends. In fact I see the size increase as a perfect opportunity now to try to find like-minded GMs or players to merge and come together to form even bigger families.

A guild name is important, but it can be built up. But to build it up, what's more important are the players and friendships in there that make the name unique. I would forsake a tree for the forest, if that is what it takes.

Unfortunately I think the problem right now is that people are unable to set aside pride and ego and come together to work as a team. Hence the need for "mercing". If your friends are truly spread across 6 to 7 guilds and enjoy raiding together, why not join up in 1 guild when the limit increases? =)

I'm not greedy, I just believe in loyalty. But I'm not loyal to an empty and hollow guild name; I am loyal to my friends who are coincidentally my guild mates. We raid to help each other achieve their goals. Neither am I selfish, in the sense that I let my members merc anytime when my guild isn't raiding. Helping others is always a good thing to do. So don't turn the table around on me. If I were greedy you would see me jumping from place to place at every down time with my main, and ignore GK raids with my main and merc only VG raids when my guild does GK. The truth is some players do "ignore GK" because it's simply "not worth it" and go only for VG once they qualify.

In fact it's almost so contrived you're calling me greedy because I want people to be loyal. How does greed equate to loyalty? That leap of logic confounds me. And I am not greedy for guild standing. Because if I were, I would make a super merc-friendly guild and run raids literally back to back to get to the top. So I have no clue where you're coming from with regard to your allegations of me being greedy. In fact I am cutting down on raids this week onwards to give my guildies breathing space, and time to farm portals. If I was single-mindedly focused on chasing power and prestige for the guild, there's no way I would step down on raids as a reaction to the guild stress. I would have implemented an aggressive merc-recruitment strategy instead.

As you can read, I've already laid my cards on the table and what I work for is to build a real environment where I raid with friends. Not an environment where people come and go on the pretext of friendship, when they are actually harboring other selfish intentions.

Lastly I dislike your tone of "taking Badd and Gin". Friends are friends. They aren't for "taking" or "going". That was rather disrespectful towards them honestly. You'd be thankful they don't read the forums that often. It's almost disappointing how you're here mentioning my guild mates as though they were property for the "taking" in the context of mergers; I think you need to do some reflection on how you really value friendship. I would have thought the better view point was to see how everyone and their friends can be brought together happily, and hey, make new friends.