Book of Heroes

Guild alliances · page 3

Taking "gin" and "badd" was a joke at your suggestion that someone can get all their friends in one place. Notice the Laughing emoticon at the end - I did that to make it EXTRA obvious and you still missed it. That is why you don't see there are many kinds of greed.

Not an environment where people come and go on the pretext of friendship, when they are actually harboring other selfish intentions.

In my experience, the vast majority of players who are going for max valor are rather honest about their intentions. I'm sorry that's your world view. I don't live in that world and I don't think most of the other players/GMs do either. It explains your stance.

Japster, go luck with that and I wish you the best.
Bbbb wrote:Completely against coalitions. Each person I know who has a home guild and mercs has their personal favorite guilds to merc in and they are different. One guild I have been a member in, the GM had a favorite guild to merc in and meanwhile I couldn't stand the people in that guild.

Currently, my home guild is KOTOR and my preferred merc location is Kingdom. However, I'm the only person who shows up in both of those guilds on a regular basis. I don't want to lose that.

Kind sir,.. You do realize that the essence of your post supports the idea of a coalition? The whole idea of being able to co-operate with a list of alliance, and yet retain the hard earned bonus! If you have a favorite guild, do you realize that mercenary work there have the intentions of reseting your loyalty bonus?

Curious as to why you would not like to retain your loyalty bonus when you decide to help your select few "friend" guilds or allies?

Thanks for your opinion, Rau
Rauhede wrote:

Kind sir,.. You do realize that the essence of your post supports the idea of a coalition? The whole idea of being able to co-operate with a list of alliance, and yet retain the hard earned bonus! If you have a favorite guild, do you realize that mercenary work there have the intentions of reseting your loyalty bonus?

Curious as to why you would not like to retain your loyalty bonus when you decide to help your select few "friend" guilds or allies?

Thanks for your opinion, Rau

You misunderstood my point. It wasn't about loyalty bonus. Also, please read part 2 of the preview - the bonus and mercing may not work the way you are thinking. It was about coalitions which is a different thing.

Let me try an alternative explanation. Alliances are set up at the guild level. Individual players may disagree with the alliance and refuse to help there. The GMs and the members desires on who to help are probably different.

There was an era of informal guild alliances back in the fall especially among the mid-tier guilds. It was rather messy, political, and at times lead to intra-guild hostility. The influx of new players after 1.5 killed off the necessity of that.

japster

ModeratorMon Apr 15, 2013 10:30 pm
Bbbb wrote:Taking "gin" and "badd" was a joke at your suggestion that someone can get all their friends in one place. Notice the Laughing emoticon at the end - I did that to make it EXTRA obvious and you still missed it. That is why you don't see there are many kinds of greed.

I do want to tell you I asked Gin about your opinion on "taking her", joke or not, after receiving your forum reply. And the bottom line is you aren't even close to her to be talking about her in this manner. You aren't one of the friends she has out of TCG.

So get off your high horse about "taking" players. It's a joke in bad taste, just admit it. You said it just to spite me as a personal attack by naming specific members of my guild, when you weren't even close to one of them (I have yet to check with Baddman). An emoticon doesn't make the true intention of a message any less obvious. It isn't a free pass at making a personal attack (in addition to calling me greedy) and passing it off as a joke.
TCG_japster wrote:
I do want to tell you I asked Gin about your opinion on "taking her", joke or not, after receiving your forum reply. And the bottom line is you aren't even close to her to be talking about her in this manner. You aren't one of the friends she has out of TCG.

So get off your high horse about "taking" players. It's a joke in bad taste, just admit it. You said it just to spite me as a personal attack by naming specific members of my guild, when you weren't even close to one of them (I have yet to check with Baddman). An emoticon doesn't make the true intention of a message any less obvious. It isn't a free pass at making a personal attack (in addition to calling me greedy) and passing it off as a joke.

Whoa, let's calm down you two. I think you're taking it too extreme japster, it really did just sound like a joke and maybe a little poke. I doubt bbbb had any malice or was intending to make a personal attack. Let's remember we are just playing a game here. Whether or not he named people in your guild he wasn't close to, I think more important was the point he was trying to make.

And that point is that alot of us have quite a few friends spread out through many guilds but wouldn't necessarily want to congregate in the same place. Magdalene, tiffy, zag for example... all people I enjoy raiding and chatting with in game but none in the same guild. It isn't as easy as just being like "hey everyone, lets join the same guild", since that'd defeat the whole purpose of guilds in the first place.
Oda_tc5k_Idaten wrote:<content removed for space>.

Thank you. BTW I only know 3 TCG members and I couldn't pick Japster to make my point.
Oda_tc5k_Idaten wrote:
TCG_japster wrote:
I do want to tell you I asked Gin about your opinion on "taking her", joke or not, after receiving your forum reply. And the bottom line is you aren't even close to her to be talking about her in this manner. You aren't one of the friends she has out of TCG.

So get off your high horse about "taking" players. It's a joke in bad taste, just admit it. You said it just to spite me as a personal attack by naming specific members of my guild, when you weren't even close to one of them (I have yet to check with Baddman). An emoticon doesn't make the true intention of a message any less obvious. It isn't a free pass at making a personal attack (in addition to calling me greedy) and passing it off as a joke.

Whoa, let's calm down you two. I think you're taking it too extreme japster, it really did just sound like a joke and maybe a little poke. I doubt bbbb had any malice or was intending to make a personal attack. Let's remember we are just playing a game here. Whether or not he named people in your guild he wasn't close to, I think more important was the point he was trying to make.

And that point is that alot of us have quite a few friends spread out through many guilds but wouldn't necessarily want to congregate in the same place. Magdalene, tiffy, zag for example... all people I enjoy raiding and chatting with in game but none in the same guild. It isn't as easy as just being like "hey everyone, lets join the same guild", since that'd defeat the whole purpose of guilds in the first place.


Thank you for saving me from having to type up a long response. 100% agree - Japster you are being a little bit unreasonable here. In the original context of his post, it's obvious (to a reasonable person) what Bbbb was intending, with or without an emoticon...if anything he was paying them a compliment saying that he wouldn't mind being in a guild with them. I'm not sure if you were intentionally trying to change the emphasis of the word "taking" to make it sound like some violent sexual act instead of a casual compliment, but you succeeded in your response post. Im sure if you asked any female player of this game if she would like to be "taken" by InMyOffice/Dave they would have a similar response. Talk about the definition of 'taking' something out of context!

-Dave

Darkhorse

Site AdminTue Apr 16, 2013 5:51 pm
Hey All, I've been watching this one for a while...

I like the ideas put forth here for an "alliance" or "coalition" and there are some well thought out posts here. It is something we may consider in the future (no promises!).

That being said, it is not something that is going to be targeted for 1.6.
Darkhorse wrote:Hey All, I've been watching this one for a while...

I like the ideas put forth here for an "alliance" or "coalition" and there are some well thought out posts here. It is something we may consider in the future (no promises!).

That being said, it is not something that is going to be targeted for 1.6.

Thanks for the attention. It's the thought that counts! if our debate has inspired your thought, there's one thing you Can promise... Chaos.. Lol. Let it ensue?.. Lol

Oh, and as shown above,.. Tensions rise,. Could something like this bring forth more "guild wars",.. All I got was somebody wished this to wish that to wish what? And then who did what to who for how many cookies?... Lol

Dave,.. Thanks for taking the time to look at some of the ideas..

Fellaz, ladies, keep it easy and stay breezy, Rau