Book of Heroes

Sw damage in PvE · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Apr 1, 2015 5:33 am
EricM wrote:
Saraa wrote:Poison cloud on DW combined with Assassinate does just about the same thing in roughly the same amt of time as a WM or Justi AoE atk. Just saying,

I'm with b4 on this one. It's really not even close. Assassinate is a whole separate pop up, while cleave and wave are done with the opening strike. Even with DW and a maxed SW, it's not a guaranteed one hit kill with axe, whereas cleave starts consistently one hitting well before 50k might.

One potential idea might be to introduce a new weapon like Fara said. A 1h heavy axe or w/e it's called with a 1.2 weapon speed. That's all it would take for a SW to start consistently one hitting.

Agree. DW is also starting to become a problem as end-game enemies do more and more damage. Even way below max might you had survivability in LoB on DW, you just had to be careful.

In PM even the P1 mob can kill you, even if you have initiative enchants, if you get surprised. The P2 bosses can OHK you even through three level VII defence enchants, if they get on the lucky side with damage rolls. Even without bad luck, if you get surprised in P3 he just hits you twice and you're dead. He can also OHK you if he gets lucky. This is at 58k might...far from maxed but not exactly just above the might req either.
Ilyana wrote:
In PM even the P1 mob can kill you, even if you have initiative enchants, if you get surprised. The P2 bosses can OHK you even through three level VII defence enchants, if they get on the lucky side with damage rolls. Even without bad luck, if you get surprised in P3 he just hits you twice and you're dead. He can also OHK you if he gets lucky. This is at 58k might...far from maxed but not exactly just above the might req either.

I took some advice for the mighty and powerful King Oz and traded out a couple crit power gems for physical and magic resist gems. I was concerned about the power loss but I don't even notice it. But, it did up my survival when getting surprise attacked. Not gonna say I never get killed but if I make sure to keep my health as high as I can (without breaking DW) between waves I usually survive the surprise. Give it a try. I do have 61k Might in my PvE spec however... But thats not too far ahead of you.
I've found Poison Cloud to be just as fast, if not faster, than my mage. Here are some stats:

SW w/DW: 66927 (no Power elixir): Poison Cloud: 13857, .42 Piercing: 15103; Basic: 7818+5620 (13438) both .41
Mage: 68216 (with Power elixir): Pyre: 14271, .61; Ice Storm: 111562 .49
Justi: 66832 (no Power elixir): Cleave: 15177, .49 Heavenly Wave: 13192, .39

From a purely stat point of view, the Cloud damage (with DW) is relatively close to both Flaming Pyre and Heavenly Wave. Both Poison Cloud and Heavenly Wave have a couple advantages over Cleave and a SW's Piercing Strike/Basic Attack: they won't miss for no damage. So even if the magic damage is resisted and there isn't a one-hit-kill, you can clean things up with a quick Acid Storm or Radiant Light. The melee Justi, if he misses on Cleave and doesn't Backswing, either has to go with a non-melee skill to clean up (with potentially bad damage, and the need for another attack to finish), or it has to do Heroic Might+SS/Cleave to finish (assuming multiple monsters are left). SS may not finish them off, and Cleave is another .49 seconds. The mage's Pyre has a horrendous .61 time when compared to the others. Ice Storm doesn't have the pop to consistently one-hit-kill (at least at my might).

Nightcrawler
I think NightCarwler has a point. Less damage but WAY faster. I'd love a OHK with storm but it doesn't for me :(
@Night, Are you using a 1h justi? Why is cleave so much faster than pyre?

Also jump, cast speed is relatively insignificant when comparing one hitting vs. two hitting.
My Justi uses the two-handed Sorrow's Embrace weapon. My haste rating is 41.44/57.09 with Speed elixir. I can get Flaming Pyre down to around .57 if I drop 4 magic gems for haste gems, but then my one-hit-kill rate drops.

I've found that Poison Cloud one-hit-kills just as much as the other skills for Mages and Justis. If it doesn't, it still has Assassinate there to clean up. Granted, it adds a little time, but it doesn't require a button press. But as was hinted at in the original thread, there is no equivelant on the SW's melee side. In the higher dungeons/raids, I've found that the melee SW just can't one-hit-kill very often, even on DW. It's missing a high-damage area-of-attack.
EricM wrote:@Night, Are you using a 1h justi? Why is cleave so much faster than pyre?

Also jump, cast speed is relatively insignificant when comparing one hitting vs. two hitting.


how many 2 hits do you have vs mobs in p1 pm? Also it is slower (rl time) to get hit by 1 mob member (god forbid all three!!!) than two hitting. The SW poison/Acid is faster than the WM pyre/any other mob attack combo. Lots of times the mob hits me so the animations slow me..... hence slow rl speed ;) That's my story and I'm sticking to it!!!

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Apr 1, 2015 11:45 am
Nightcrawler13 wrote:My Justi uses the two-handed Sorrow's Embrace weapon. My haste rating is 41.44/57.09 with Speed elixir. I can get Flaming Pyre down to around .57 if I drop 4 magic gems for haste gems, but then my one-hit-kill rate drops.

I've found that Poison Cloud one-hit-kills just as much as the other skills for Mages and Justis. If it doesn't, it still has Assassinate there to clean up. Granted, it adds a little time, but it doesn't require a button press. But as was hinted at in the original thread, there is no equivelant on the SW's melee side. In the higher dungeons/raids, I've found that the melee SW just can't one-hit-kill very often, even on DW. It's missing a high-damage area-of-attack.

My spiricar often (but not always by any means) OHKs the mobs in P1 PM @ 36k might.

My SW, in poison spec, very rarely OHKs the same mobs at 50k might even in Death Wish.

Both toons have a similar magic stat (my SW is melee primarily so hasn't finished the magic training) and similar gem bonuses. The SW has more crit and crit power and far better gems. Both have T18/19 gear. Both are using swords rather than axes.

The primary issue is that the damage is down due to 1H and causes you to either need assassinate or another ability to clear the group. I'd say a Justicar isn't maximised for damage if near max they don't OHK mobs, same for WM.
EricM wrote:
Also jump, cast speed is relatively insignificant when comparing one hitting vs. two hitting.

Yup exactly. Also, animations matter a LOT. Cleave and Wave have fast animations compared to Pyre.

A non-DW SW is not OHK unless they crit every opponent. Since I'm often dumping 3-4 toons in a raid, I am not going to spend effort into setting up and maintaining DW.