Shadow walkers are vastly underpowered in pve ( don't know about pvp ). I'm trying a magic build and it seems to be quicker against the mobs in pm phase1. Using a sw in pm phase2 is one of the only challenges left in the game, I've more confidence in my justicar with 20k less might.
@ rez
I switched to magic in pve cause I was tired of being melee and I agree p1 it works great! P2 and p3 that's a toss up its so much less consistent then melee. Plus that tree guy is my kryptonite xD he sneaks on bs and mid attack while im in Dw and kills me. Im not geared pve that's def a huge factor( as I use pvp gear) but im decent might I usually always die it's just a given for me. I think most Sw will die just cause the baddies get initiative at the start and one shot you. But you really can't do pve without Dw unless you are 70k might or you want take forever and a day to kill something. I ramble anyways for p2 I've been doing this and it seems to work ok
Acid spray, poison cloud, smoke, acid spray, poison cloud, toxic blade, piercing strike <~~~ kills one guy then I snare the other and toxic blade if it doesn't stick then just toxic blade it's fine you gotta use purge runes to do any dmg and just maintain Dw with large or extra large hp pots not the purple ones
Outside of 3 monster OS, it seems to me that the choice between DW or 1h is really a wash. Both are better in some circumstances, but over 3 SW at different levels, neither stands out. True the chance of 1h kills is less one handed, but block on top of dodge seems to be marginally the better performer overall in non OS raids including p2 of PM.
DW is really far too diluted. I would support fixing that, but I understand that, like a lot of things that would improve PVE, playing experiences, that will fall to the needs of PVP balance.
Therefore kill it and give PVE SWs something to make them attractive to play again.
Cleave is 11k hits at 30k might, incin is 9k at 32k might, with a 29k sw poison cloud doesn't get anywhere near even with crits etc, but that's made up with their speed and constant crits
Fact of the matter is high level SW is slower in pm p1. Without a t19 axe SW has lost some power in p3 but I still think it's the fastest class in that phase of pm. While it can be frustrating staying in DW all of the time, it's certainly more exciting playing. Who cares if you die sometimes? Rpp reset.... Big deal, just means less currency to convert down the road if t20 ever comes out. Each class needs to be different. If they weren't then why have more than one?
I dunno i have no problems wth my sw, 1 hit enough in ph1 to be happy. The spiders are the only ones i really have to use 2 attacks if i dont crit. The rest if i get any t7 magic gems see that being 100% one hit unless they dodge. He's fairly even with my wm.