Book of Heroes

Energy Regeneration Rates · page 2

True that might is really where it's at but that's not what I meant. When I was saying the disadvantage I was speaking in the context of this thread with regards to raids as one example. A person who can still level could go up 1-2 levels in a give raid, getting that much more energy than a person who is at lvl 25 and has to slowly wait for the energy to return. Venan is looking to change raids I know so might would factor in more making this less of an issue if not moot.

My point was going back to the beginning that I thought energy should regenerate at a % for the reasons originally mentioned, raids being only one place it would be useful to get more energy faster based on current raid model. Some disagree with this so Im asking the question... Why would it be bad or harmful to the game to regenerate at a different rate as I suggested? I'd honestly like to know if there is a reason. If its to make people play slower like one person said then why would it be harmful for some to play a little faster or more frequently than others?
aantiix wrote:True that might is really where it's at but that's not what I meant. When I was saying the disadvantage I was speaking in the context of this thread with regards to raids as one example. A person who can still level could go up 1-2 levels in a give raid, getting that much more energy than a person who is at lvl 25 and has to slowly wait for the energy to return. Venan is looking to change raids I know so might would factor in more making this less of an issue if not moot.

My point was going back to the beginning that I thought energy should regenerate at a % for the reasons originally mentioned, raids being only one place it would be useful to get more energy faster based on current raid model. Some disagree with this so Im asking the question... Why would it be bad or harmful to the game to regenerate at a different rate as I suggested? I'd honestly like to know if there is a reason. If its to make people play slower like one person said then why would it be harmful for some to play a little faster or more frequently than others?

You sound like you haven't reached Knight's Valor raids. Wait until you hit Cursed Keep or above that gives knight's valor, everyone's at Lv25 by then. So there is no advantage or disadvantage at that point. As for gaining level during a raid, you may be able to gain more RPP than those who's at Lv25, but eventually you'll hit the cap and get same amount of RPP like everyone else. What you are asking is 15 minutes less of waiting time. You still have to wait for 60 minutes regen. 75 vs. 60, it is shorter but you still have to wait. You want play more? Come back before regen fills your en completely. And we don't have to give a reason why your suggestion is bad the same reason why we don't need a reason why our suggestion is good.
Junky1180 wrote:

You sound like you haven't reached Knight's Valor raids. Wait until you hit Cursed Keep or above that gives knight's valor, everyone's at Lv25 by then. So there is no advantage or disadvantage at that point. As for gaining level during a raid, you may be able to gain more RPP than those who's at Lv25, but eventually you'll hit the cap and get same amount of RPP like everyone else. What you are asking is 15 minutes less of waiting time. You still have to wait for 60 minutes regen. 75 vs. 60, it is shorter but you still have to wait. You want play more? Come back before regen fills your en completely. And we don't have to give a reason why your suggestion is bad the same reason why we don't need a reason why our suggestion is good.

You are completely missing the point. First off the lower levels going up was just a comparison showing that there are cases people regain energy faster and it causes no adverse affects. Yes people can do more because of more energy, so why is it bad to regen that faster?

This is the feedback section, I submitted a suggestion and provided why I thought it was a good idea and yes I do need to provide that information as I have otherwise no point in a suggestion.

Working in various aspects of software development there are a few factors to determine what is implemented. The first is would it be detrimental or cause any negative effects to the product? The second is would this cause benefit to any users? There are a few other considerations such as cost, value add, etc but those all lie with Venan to determine and out of our control. The first two though fall on users primarily. Since I provided reason why this was good, nobody has yet shown why it is bad so this should be considered as an improvement.

For the record I do come back long before my energy refills. Obviously people have to wait and that's my point, my suggestion that instead of 75 min wait for 30 energry it's decreased by 25 min down to 50 min. It's not about waitin to get full but the rate of regen so when I come back in 30 min for example I have more energy to work with than I do based on current rate.

So relax a little dude, this is the place in the forums for people to make a suggestion which is what I did, not to pick a fight because you don't like it. I was trying to be fair and genuinely wanted to know if I was missing something since I saw reason for this change but no reason why it was bad.
Hello Mr.Why, I think it is bad because it hurts Venan's pocket. You say you make suggestion but you sound rather asking for more when more has already been provided. It's also bad because I love being able to play do real life stuff while waiting for en to fill. I certain don't want play this game none stop because that's not what this game suppose to work. And you are talking about 15 min less making 75 min to 60 min. Hell there might be another you asking for 15 min less after after your idea if it's ever been granted. Then another 15 min. Guess what? Venan might as well dump the GS en refill completely
DevilPrada wrote:Hello Mr.Why, I think it is bad because it hurts Venan's pocket. You say you make suggestion but you sound rather asking for more when more has already been provided. It's also bad because I love being able to play do real life stuff while waiting for en to fill. I certain don't want play this game none stop because that's not what this game suppose to work. And you are talking about 15 min less making 75 min to 60 min. Hell there might be another you asking for 15 min less after after your idea if it's ever been granted. Then another 15 min. Guess what? Venan might as well dump the GS en refill completely

Actually 25 min less and Ive made one suggestion not a series asking for reductions in anything else so enough with the sarcasm please. I'm being civil and I honestly wanted to know if I was missing a reason it hurts the game, if people want to play slower they still can, this wouldn't force anyone to play more, just gives some the option to if they wanted.

If it hurts Venans pocket that would fall in the area of them determining the cost analysis as I just mentioned. Users never determine anything to do with costs, the developer does. Users input why from a game play perspective it would be good or bad, that's it.

This thread is getting off course anyone else want to pick a fight with me then send me a private message. If anyone wants to give genuine civil responses, that's what the thread is here for.
aantiix wrote:
DevilPrada wrote:Hello Mr.Why, I think it is bad because it hurts Venan's pocket. You say you make suggestion but you sound rather asking for more when more has already been provided. It's also bad because I love being able to play do real life stuff while waiting for en to fill. I certain don't want play this game none stop because that's not what this game suppose to work. And you are talking about 15 min less making 75 min to 60 min. Hell there might be another you asking for 15 min less after after your idea if it's ever been granted. Then another 15 min. Guess what? Venan might as well dump the GS en refill completely

Actually 25 min less. Enough with the sarcasm too, seriously. I'm being civil and I honestly wanted to know if I was missing a reason it hurts the game, if people want to play slower they still can, this wouldn't force anyone to play more, just gives some the option to if they wanted.

If it hurts Venans pocket that would fall in the area of them determining the cost analysis as I just mentioned. Users never determine anything to do with costs, the developer does. Users input why from a game play perspective it would be good or bad, that's it.

What makes you think I'm not being civil? I'm just making my augument, is arguing someone not civil? I never offended you in any form, if u feel offended because I criticized you, that's too bad
DevilPrada wrote:
What makes you think I'm not being civil? I'm just making my augument, is arguing someone not civil? I never offended you in any form, if u feel offended because I criticized you, that's too bad

Dude read the post I said enough with the sarcasm, and startin off your post with "Mr Why" clearly is just that. You didn't criticize me at all you just wrote exactly what I said in the previous post isn't our responsibility as users and that's determining cost analysis. Assuming I'm requesting change after change is just flat out wrong as is your math, so no you didn't criticize me at all. If you want to keep arguing send me a PM and lets not hijack this thread as its getting way off course.

I'm done posting in this thread. I've said my peace and not going to argue with anyone. Venan will decide what's in the best interest of the game in the end.

When Venan increased energy regeneration from 1 to 2 did people get so bent out of shape saying it hurt Venan and people trying to get too much for free? No they favored it. My suggestion decreases the amount for some, keeps it same for some and raises for some. This gives more incentive to purchase sigils as well.
aantiix wrote:
DevilPrada wrote:
What makes you think I'm not being civil? I'm just making my augument, is arguing someone not civil? I never offended you in any form, if u feel offended because I criticized you, that's too bad

Dude read the post I said enough with the sarcasm, and startin off your post with "Mr Why" clearly is just that. You didn't criticize me at all you just wrote exactly what I said in the previous post isn't our responsibility as users and that's determining cost analysis. Assuming I'm requesting change after change is just flat out wrong as is your math, so no you didn't criticize me at all. If you want to keep arguing send me a PM and lets not hijack this thread as its getting way off course.

I'm done posting in this thread. I've said my peace and not going to argue with anyone. Venan will decide what's in the best interest of the game in the end.

When Venan increased energy regeneration from 1 to 2 did people get so bent out of shape saying it hurt Venan and people trying to get too much for free? No they favored it. My suggestion decreases the amount for some, keeps it same for some and raises for some. This gives more incentive to purchase sigils as well.

No disrespect but you did ask a lot why's :) I guess I shouldn've to put a smilie next to Mr.Why since I was trying to be funny. I guess you take things too serious. :(

Lord_Venan

Site AdminThu Jul 12, 2012 10:25 am
Hi Aantix,

I follow your argument. That model is certainly one that we looked at. However, one thing we care about that isn't necessarily covered well is player fatigue and the requirements necessary to play the game "optimally." I think the point Hai5 and Bojun were making was that it's nice that they can put the game down for awhile without having to feel like they are losing progress versus other people. In a sense right now sigils not only provide an initial boost to energy but also allow players the convenience to check the game less often without penalty. If we were to normalize regen, that convenience would go away and players would be forced into longer and longer play sessions as they attempt to burn all their energy.

I think it's an interesting question and definitely debatable. Like everything else in game design there aren't really "right" answers just answers that seem to work, and at this point I think we're satisfied with the current system.