Book of Heroes

Energy Regeneration Rates

Energy should regenerate at a % of total energy instead of flat 2 points every 5 min. So for example

19 or less - 1 every 5 min
20-29 - 2 every 5 min
30-39 - 3 every 5 min

This would give people more incentive and bonus for having higher total energy, especially during raids after everyone has burned all their crew and waiting to get more. At 30 total energy it takes 75 min to regain it all which seems a bit high.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorWed Jul 11, 2012 8:26 pm
aantiix wrote:Energy should regenerate at a % of total energy instead of flat 2 points every 5 min. So for example

19 or less - 1 every 5 min
20-29 - 2 every 5 min
30-39 - 3 every 5 min

This would give people more incentive and bonus for having higher total energy, especially during raids after everyone has burned all their crew and waiting to get more. At 30 total energy it takes 75 min to regain it all which seems a bit high.

Definitely a big no to this. The benefit of higher energy is just that "higher energy". Also you can rest more between max energy regen.
Bojun wrote:
Definitely a big no to this. The benefit of higher energy is just that "higher energy". Also you can rest more between max energy regen.

Just because you can rest longer, I'm not seeing why it should be mandatory that everyone actually rest at the rate that you would chose, you always have the option to still rest longer regardless. You didn't provide a reason why you believe this would be a bad thing despite being emphatically against it. I'd be interested in hearing why you believe that way in case there is something I'm missing. Just seems logical to use the same regeneration method for energy as is currently in place for health.

One advantage of greater total health is that you regenerate at a faster rate, what would be the harm in the same being true for energy? I see only positives as this would actually make higher energy more worthwhile.

Hotasfire0Coolasice

Wed Jul 11, 2012 10:21 pm
I'm not sure about your values, but this would help extremely in raids. What's the point of having 40 energy if you have to wait 1 hr and 40 minutes to get it all back?
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:I'm not sure about your values, but this would help extremely in raids. What's the point of having 40 energy if you have to wait 1 hr and 40 minutes to get it all back?

This is my point exactly. Useful in raids to actually give people with higher energy an advantage over those with 15, right now after the first rush everyone is even which doesn't seem right. A lvl 25 with 30 energy is at a disadvantage vs a lvl 15 with 15 energy who levels 2x during the same raid.

Faster regeneration of energy would provide useful for quests as well weather farming gems, earning silver etc.
If you want faster energy regeneration than just get the blessing from the temple. You can't expect to get everything for free. Also I don't understand how people with higher energy are at a disadvantage compared to people with less energy.
aantiix wrote:Energy should regenerate at a % of total energy instead of flat 2 points every 5 min. So for example

19 or less - 1 every 5 min
20-29 - 2 every 5 min
30-39 - 3 every 5 min

This would give people more incentive and bonus for having higher total energy, especially during raids after everyone has burned all their crew and waiting to get more. At 30 total energy it takes 75 min to regain it all which seems a bit high.

There is a reason why blessing of stamina exists in the shop. Venan already doubled the regen speed since the 1.3 patch and that's a huge boost already.

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorWed Jul 11, 2012 11:08 pm
As I said earlier the main benefit of higher energy is just that "having higher energy". For me that is benefit enough and Iet me rephrase the thing about longer rest. What I wanted to say was that you lessen the possibility of wasted energy with higher energy because you can only play the game so much.

You cannot equate health and energy because they are simply not worth the same in this game. I actually missed one of the more important reason but thanks to knagrim for mentioning it. Energy can be brought with GS which in turn can be brought with real money. Those purchases make it possible for Venan to make this game for us and give regular updates. You can't expect everything in a free game.
I didn't say people with higher energy are at a disadvantage. What I said is during a raid a higher level is currently at a disadvantage because they don't level. The lower levels will go up 1-2 levels in one raid alone getting more energy with a level up. Regenerating at a % would help offset that as lower levels aren't as likely to have 30-40 energy.

There are also blessings that equate to faster health regeneration (or less loss) so I guess I'm missing the point there. Nobody ever said anything about expecting everything from a free game, this is the feedback section so Im giving my input on one aspect that i belive to be flawed, nothing more.

Just because the rate of regeneration recently went up doesn't mean it's still a good formula. Venan may agree or not, so be it either way. I'm sure there's people on both sides of this argument. So far I haven't seen any real reason why it would be bad. I just see reasons why some people don't think it's necessary (already better than it was, blessings, cant expect everything) If I'm missing this then please reply so myself and others can see the reason because I'm still interested to know why this would be a negative thing.
aantiix wrote:I didn't say people with higher energy are at a disadvantage. What I said is during a raid a higher level is currently at a disadvantage because they don't level. The lower levels will go up 1-2 levels in one raid alone getting more energy with a level up. Regenerating at a % would help offset that as lower levels aren't as likely to have 30-40 energy.

There are also blessings that equate to faster health regeneration (or less loss) so I guess I'm missing the point there. Nobody ever said anything about expecting everything from a free game, this is the feedback section so Im giving my input on one aspect that i belive to be flawed, nothing more.

Just because the rate of regeneration recently went up doesn't mean it's still a good formula. Venan may agree or not, so be it either way. I'm sure there's people on both sides of this argument. So far I haven't seen any real reason why it would be bad. I just see reasons why some people don't think it's necessary (already better than it was, blessings, cant expect everything) If I'm missing this then please reply so myself and others can see the reason because I'm still interested to know why this would be a negative thing.

On the contrary, I don't feel I'm at a disadvantage for being at Lv25. Level doesn't define anything in this game. Anyone can reach Lv25 within a week or two if you put your time into it. It's the Might one ought to seek for for end game content, at least for now until things change in future updates. The higher Might I get by doing raids after raids gives me better equipments, better gems and better Might so I can do harder raids. That along gives me and any others who think the same as I do the advantage of being able to do harder raids and get better items. According to your argument, it would only work if there is no level limit like Mafia War on facebook, for example. But many games do have level limit, especially RPG games. Eventually you'll hit the cap, then what? Still thinks you are at disadvantage just because you hit Lv99 and you can no longer level up? This is just my 2 cents.