Book of Heroes

Regarding the letter to community · page 4

Haven't played much for the last three weeks and I can see a difference in that short period of time in player numbers.
Can we have some sort of update about new future developments if not a date at least some idea about what we can expect.
I and others are being patient but the numbers are continuing to go down please stay true to your word and keep us informed.
So. Now I've not been paying much attention over the last 2 months or so (longer, in fact), but I thought I'd see how these things were progressing. Taking the list Derrin posted as a guide...
  • There are behind the scenes publishing issues which have affected the pace of updates
    - And the more I've seen of R2 in other areas, the worse a move this seems. The number of Google Play refunds for non-delivery of premium currency, and complaints of misrepresentation seem to be accelerating where R2 are concerned. Their forums are full of complaints about bugs, failure to deliver paid-for items, server crashes and unavailability, lack of responses from support and / or stupid support. By comparison, this forum is Disneyland.
  • There are plans to add fresh players to the game
    - Player numbers seem to be continuing to decline, if anything. I have seen no promotional material for BoH anywhere, including on R2 platforms.
  • There are plans to add fresh content to the game
    - Nothing implemented or shared with players regds nature of content or timescale.
  • There are plans to update events in the game
    - Nothing implemented or shared with players regds nature of content or timescale.
  • There are plans to otherwise improve the game
    - Nothing implemented or shared with players regds nature of content or timescale.
  • There will be an update in June, although we shouldn't expect much at first
    - Aside from content for a reoccurring yearly seasonal event, I didn't see anything there? Did I miss anything?
  • Players using a language other than English will soon see improved translations
    - Can't comment. Can any non-English speakers advise?
  • We were promised that the developers would "keep the community aware of our future developments and pave a new road map for" BoH
    - Communication has maintained at pretty consistent. Y'know, non-existent. Certainly no sign of a roadmap.
Looking at some other metrics:
  • The Book of Heroes Twitter account has made 13 posts since July 1st - 3 of these have been related to Space Miner. The other 10 were event notifications (werechef, double gems etc). No "original" content.
  • The Venan Twitter account has made no posts about BoH since April - all (non-reply) posts are related to Space Miner. The posts that were made were weekend double gems/valour announcements only.
  • The Venan website has no mention of BoH on its frontpage*, only Space Miner.
*Aside from a mention in the Space Miner post which implies BoH is being put on the back burner from Feb: "While the Venan crew has been prioritizing our free-to-play RPG Book of Heroes for the last several years, a change is sweeping the office — a change that sounds an awful lot like banjos."

Meanwhile, the issues that consistently come up over and over - transfer costs for enchants, lack of OS high level raids, Justi incompetence in OS compared to WM /SW, deadbeat mercs and keeping them out, Guild Loyalty... All ignored or expressly denied as being an issue. I may not agree with all of the issues being raised (I quite like GL), but I acknowledge that they are valid concerns for many. Yet Venan do an ostrich and hope people will keep playing and paying.

I can't help but wonder whether there is anything approaching a plan going on. We've seen a number of "we know we haven't really been communicating, but we triple-promise we're going to try harder" posts over the last few years, but every time we see one, there's pretty much nothing more until the next one saying the same a few months later.
There's a line between keeping the faith and self-delusion where one hopes for change despite the evidence that it ain't coming. I believe that line has now been crossed for most players.
DreamingDæmon wrote:
- And the more I've seen of R2 in other areas, the worse a move this seems. The number of Google Play refunds for non-delivery of premium currency, and complaints of misrepresentation seem to be accelerating where R2 are concerned. Their forums are full of complaints about bugs, failure to deliver paid-for items, server crashes and unavailability, lack of responses from support and / or stupid support. By comparison, this forum is Disneyland.

Venan is in control of operations not R2 so this is not an issue.

[*]There are plans to add fresh players to the game
- Player numbers seem to be continuing to decline, if anything. I have seen no promotional material for BoH anywhere, including on R2 platforms.

The numbers are trending down (about 8% comparing the two previous weeks) and unless they are reversed, I expect no content beyond the usual events. Even worse is that the gold/silver/bronze/fail-or-cancel rates on PM are horrid. I expect the usual "our guild always golds it" response by someone - that will be a flat out lie. All the high end guilds depend on mercs these days - the guild concept is largely dead and we have raid hosts.

[*]Players using a language other than English will soon see improved translations
- Can't comment. Can any non-English speakers advise?

(Edited this part) Okay, we have an announcement that it will come with PvP Season 3.

[*]The Venan website has no mention of BoH on its frontpage*, only Space Miner.[/list]

BoH is under Games and there is a background that switches in (or click the right arrow button) but yeah more SM.

There's a line between keeping the faith and self-delusion where one hopes for change despite the evidence that it ain't coming. I believe that line has now been crossed for most players.

At this point, I do not expect anything different for the rest of the year even if R2 started promoting today and things caught fire. That's the best case. Worst case is that Venan is loosing money keeping the servers running and shuts the whole thing down tomorrow.
The fact that Venan is expanding languages, rebalancing classes, working with a new publisher, and announcing a third season of PvP suggests that they are still working on the game. Reports of its demise are premature.

Many are unhappy that Venan does not limit itself to BoH. I take a different view. Diversification is a sound business strategy, one which will help Venan to survive as a company, and can help keep the lights on, even as revenue drops from this mature FTP game. Does it mean that the developers aren't constantly programming for BoH? Yes; programming resources are finite. But it also means Venan can continue to pay their programmers. I don't begrudge it, at least not when I think about things from a long term perspective.

The new languages and the new publisher both indicate that they are focused on bringing new players into the game. That does not immediately benefit us as end game players. In the long term, however, it does, if it is successful, because it brings a supply of more players (1) to become end game players, and (2) to fuel Venan's interest in providing end game content. That success involves both attracting players to try the game and retaining them as players in the early stages.

The overall HS list (which I may look at more than other people ;) ), suggests that fully 87% (thank you, Daemon) of toons that have started the game have not attained a might of 1000. Ever. That suggests that programming efforts which will improve the "retention" of players, making them want to stay with the game and progress to end game, can pay off handsomely, both for Venan monetarily and for those of us hoping to have more players in our guilds and more raids for our end game toons. I expect Venan to focus attention there, on retention of new players. There's no use attracting players to the game if 6/7 wander away in the early stages. Sound business practices suggest Venan should focus their efforts there, rather than trying to milk the same old cows that are drying up.

If my analysis is correct, and I think it is, programming focus for the game will not be on us at its end. There will still be events and upgrades through events. Season 3 of PvP is coming with some enhancements. But I think we are at least 8 months away (and that's extremely optimistic) from:
  • New end game raids
  • New valor
  • T20 gear
  • T8 gems
  • T12 enchants
Stop asking when "the update" is. There will be updates but they won't have what you're looking for. Eventually, I think we will see most of the things in that list. But not now. Not next month. Not in 2015. And if we all walk away, not ever.
Derrin_Watson wrote:
The overall HS list (which I may look at more than other people ;) ), suggests that fully 72% of toons that have started the game have not attained a might of 1000.

I'd consider 28% of the toons staying around that long a success on their part. 95% or more of all the game apps I've ever launched only got minutes of playtime before I shelved them.....

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jul 31, 2015 2:57 am
Derrin_Watson wrote:The fact that Venan is expanding languages, rebalancing classes, working with a new publisher, and announcing a third season of PvP suggests that they are still working on the game. Reports of its demise are premature.

None of that matters if players continue to leave the game. Getting them back will be very difficult if they move their support onto other games.

I would encourage people to ask when 'the update' is. Currently it has been 9 months since the last major content update. The gap to the one before that was 10 months, so I'm not surprised people are beginning to ask. The game will die without new content, genuinely new content that gives people a reason to keep playing. Venan's current strategy is going to destroy their own game, which would be a shame because this app was very innovative in many areas.
With Venan changing publishers and also working on another project, a delay for a new update makes alot of sense, but i hope it wont take another 8 months, be nice to see it before 2016
__Q__ wrote:With Venan changing publishers and also working on another project, a delay for a new update makes alot of sense, but i hope it wont take another 8 months, be nice to see it before 2016

Instead of a whole new area and such, I think a LOT of players would come back if Venan could just develop a GV level OS raid. That would be a good stopgap release.

DoyleDD

ModeratorFri Jul 31, 2015 2:45 pm
Bbbb wrote:
__Q__ wrote:With Venan changing publishers and also working on another project, a delay for a new update makes alot of sense, but i hope it wont take another 8 months, be nice to see it before 2016

Instead of a whole new area and such, I think a LOT of players would come back if Venan could just develop a GV level OS raid. That would be a goo stopgap release.


+1,000,000
Even if they modified pm and made a phase 2 or 3, or both os, think that would help things feel like like the same old grind