Brilliant! +1
One part struck me - your numbers.
Derrin_Watson wrote:
The overall HS list (which I may look at more than other people), suggests that fully 72% of toons that have started the game have not attained a might of 1000. Ever.
Looking at the overall Might table, there are 1,580,710 created toons.
Of these:
202,107 achieved 1k (12.8%)
54,288 achieved 5k (3.4%)
25,461 achieved 10k (1.6%)
9,846 achieved 20k (0.6%)
5,229 achieved 30k (0.3%)
2,980 achieved 40k (0.2%)
1,428 achieved 50k (<0.1%)
This says that your idea about retention is perhaps more right than you realised (though why the tables differ, I couldn't say), considering that 1k is easily achieved in a few hours of play, and that 87% of created toons don't manage that. Especially considering the fact that many of the ones that do "get there" are subsidiary toons for existing players who have already invested in the game and are more likely to advance. Hell, I personally account for 0.2% of the 50k+ toons...
More tellingly, perhaps, I looked at last week's HS table (wc Tue 21/07).
12,345 were listed.
5,903 attained 1k+ HS in the week - the bare minimum that I would consider could count as "active", easily obtained in a few raids or dungeons - much less than a single session a day through the week.
1,219 toons made more than 10kHS - what could be classed as a "regular" - multiple sign ins per day, or a little burning.
It'll be interesting to see how those numbers progress. I may even set up a spreadsheet...
I know you're approaching this from a different perspective. Quite honestly, if Venan introduced a mini-game to play on entering a raid, you'd praise it whilst I hated it. That's part of what makes you a good GM, where I'd make a lousy one.
Believe me, I understand resource scarcity and prioritisation. I'm personally working on 3 major projects, where all the contacts are regularly chasing and demanding updates - I spend more time emailing and on the phone than coding!
The difference, however, is that customers deserve transparency, honesty, and open lines of communication. These things have not been forthcoming from Venan, and it's that lack of accurate information which forms the biggest gripe I have, and from what I see when I do log in or look at Line groups, I'm not alone in that.
I now look at BoH as a restaurant I really used to like, but where the standard of food and service has really taken a hit. The owners keep vaguely promising a refurb with a new menu, but somehow it never seems to actually happen. I have fond memories, but I don't really want to eat there until changes are made to bring it back up to standard. And in the meantime, I'm finding other places to eat that I prefer.