Book of Heroes

arcane shield and abilities

Arcane shield, passive. After being hit, you get a X% chance to gain an arcane shield that absorbs 75% of the next attack.
In battle buff:
Reduces damage of next incoming. attack by 75%
Ice Spike Armor, passive. Magically retaliate X% of weapon damage as ice damage
Sticky Grenade. Attach a sticky grenade to your enemies and after 2.0s, it explodes dealing X% weapon damage. Cannot be resisted.

With all that info stated, here are my questions:

If ice spike armor removes arcane shield, which is not an attack, why does sticky grenade when it explodes not remove it. Wether or not sticky grenade is an attack, it should remove arcane shield and be reduced in damage.

2nd question: if arcane shield is removed to reduce damage from an ability or attack, then why does non damaging abilities remove it. I.e. time void, caltrops. Other effects do not remove it but are similar, bleed for example.

*Mods: please refer to replay #
143209405000*

If everything is working as it should, then the abilites should get some rewording to state what they actually do (because 'next attack' has a totally different meaning than 'when affected by any ability')

If sticky grenade is working correctly, then its new label should have this added: Cannot be dodged, Cannot be blocked, Damage from this ability cannot be reduced by any ability.

If there is an issue with either arcane shield, or sticky grenade, could we get a dev or mod to reply they are looking into it please. Thanks.

Please comment but not flame. Please stay on topic. (Discussing the abilites and interaction thereof)

Thank you for reading this.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri May 22, 2015 3:02 pm
Pretty sure this has been discussed elsewhere - the devs know there are wording issues with some abilities (we've told them enough times).
Also note that these effects (time void, grenade, smoke....etc) that do not give damage will still proc the shield. I think the devs just chose to not discriminate.

So basically sometimes you get a proc when you shouldn't and sometimes maybe it gets removed when it shouldn't. To me it seems fair and it was just a choice as to what is an attack.
Im with jumper. The things that do and do not break arcane balance out and are fair enough. At least its not based on rng and can be figured out with 100% certainty lol. As for sticky, it behaves like a dot and so shouldn't be affected by or break arcane just like bleed, burn, poison and caltrops ticks wont break arcane. Likewise, the damage done by sticky can be reduced by the defend ability, just like the periodic damage from other dots.
Also another question ,which I think needs looked @
Why sticky bomb or Caltrops do not break stun??? You are being attacked so it should break it,
Hope we get all these bugs fixed in next update

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue May 26, 2015 9:59 am
They aren't bugs. Like said above, it's fair to have things like shield removed by caltrops etc. Melee SWs rely on DoTs for a big chunk of damage and slows. Just because they make it difficult for a justicar doesn't mean they're bugged. There are many other things that make life difficult for other classes vs justicars.
I'm with Dimo.... the problem is not in the wording it's that they can launch 3 attacks and a defend without breaking stun