Wyntre wrote:
Svako: My enchantments are on my armor, so I don't understand your "isn't mitigated by armor." No, it's not mitigated by the armor stat--never said it was.
My point is simply this: backswing penalizes a high dodging stat.
I think that backswing should be a percentage of the damage if it were to hit (and not crit).
As the system is, I don't have a choice whether to try to dodge; I automatically try to dodge. If I had the choice, I might prefer to let the seismic through (as an example), which does 60 percent weapon damage and knockback--instead of 100 percent weapon damage from the backswing. This is especially true if I've countered with defend, where sometimes extending through countering a seismic or other knockback skill is a strategy. I'm not sure where you're getting 160 percent dmg. For attacks that do low damage, backswing is too high since it can actually do higher damage than if the attack hit.
That's what I mean by "punishes a high dodge stat." It can do more damage than it would if the attack had hit, and that's punishment for a high stat.
I don't understand how this concept could be any clearer. Perhaps I'm not explaining something well.
I thought you mean armor stat, so i wanted to correct you... but thats not what is important here. What you have to realize here is that backswing is the only way melee justi can deal with dodge. We have no way to reduce opponents dodge chance(accu enchant is bad, so can't be taken as an option), we have no way to slow our opponent, we can't apply debuffs when we get dodged(dodged bleed has 0% chance to apply bleed and backswing doesn't apply bleed as well).
When WM gets its attack dodged he does half the dmg and can still apply debuff(dodged frozen shard does half dmg + can still apply slow on opponent), which is more powerfull than pure dmg from backswing(which is not even 100% chance, so it statisticaly procs 3 of 4). So which one of these two are OP?
About the 160% dmg: When you get hit by seismic, brutal strike is the following move, thats the 160% dmg going your way to deal with.
Ideal scenario vs WM is: undefended seismic, brutal, heroic, brutal, stun, execute, spit on dead WMs body covered in blood... so once the seismic is dodged, that bonus 40% dmg you take from backswing(if procs) is nothing compared to that combo.
Wyntre wrote:
For attacks that do low damage, backswing is too high since it can actually do higher damage than if the attack hit.
Attacks? Use singular here pls, cause its only about seismic. Every other melee move have bigger dmg(brutal, execute if used right) or same dmg and debuff(wound).
Conclusion:
Justies were nerfed enough, its time to leave them alone and take a look at other classes!!!