I'm a Gold 3 PvPer who just unlocked the PM raid yesterday, so I'm neither a newbie nor uber. I've played for years, although I took a three year hiatus. My primary is a mage.
I've been thinking about what it means to claim that a skill or mechanic is OP. One possible yardstick is that it's OP or unfair if it deliberately subverts the game mechanics.
Backswing punishes dodging. No other stat besides dodging actively harms someone when they pump it, but a toon with high dodge fighting a justicar will be handicapped because of dodge. Often, when a justi punishes me for dodging, they take more health from me than they would have if the shot had gone through. Consider receiving a backswing for dodging a seismic: instead of 60 percent weapon damage, there is 100 percent damage. The weakness of the Justi class is supposed to be how often they (don't) hit, but this turns their primary weakness into a class strength and unbalances PvP.
What's particularly unfair about this backswing that there's no way to choose whether to try to dodge the seismic. Maybe I'd prefer to let it through and take the time penalty (mitigated by my armor), but I don't have that option as dodging is passive and stat-based. Further, bypassing ice armor is another advantage of backswing--and another way to punish a mage opponent with high dodge.
TL;DR version: Backswing is the only skill I know that punishes people for upping a stat. This isn't good.
If you accept this conclusion that backswing is broken, how could it be fixed?
One quick fix would help considerably: instead of doing 100 percent weapon damage, do half the damage that the attack would have done had it gone through (and no crits). Stop punishing dodge, which is not supposed to harm the dodger. It's fine to lessen the benefits of dodge, but it's unfair to turn dodging into a liability.
As a mage, I'm biased, but I also think it should be subject to the retaliation of ice armor. However, ice armor itself may be OP. Instead of retaliating 30 percent of my weapon as damage, as the text suggests it is, it should be 30 percent of the attack that hit it. That's the definition of retaliation, after all: sending some incoming damage back!
There are lots of things I'd like to change about justis (juggernaut is 100 percent effective, seriously?), but in all honesty, backswing is the one that seems to undermine gameplay by punishing folks for pumping a primary stat.
Backswing punishes dodging. No other stat besides dodging actively harms someone when they pump it, but a toon with high dodge fighting a justicar will be handicapped because of dodge. Often, when a justi punishes me for dodging, they take more health from me than they would have if the shot had gone through. Consider receiving a backswing for dodging a seismic: instead of 60 percent weapon damage, there is 100 percent damage. The weakness of the Justi class is supposed to be how often they (don't) hit, but this turns their primary weakness into a class strength and unbalances PvP.
What's particularly unfair about this backswing that there's no way to choose whether to try to dodge the seismic. Maybe I'd prefer to let it through and take the time penalty (mitigated by my armor), but I don't have that option as dodging is passive and stat-based. Further, bypassing ice armor is another advantage of backswing--and another way to punish a mage opponent with high dodge.
If you accept this conclusion that backswing is broken, how could it be fixed?
As a mage, I'm biased, but I also think it should be subject to the retaliation of ice armor. However, ice armor itself may be OP. Instead of retaliating 30 percent of my weapon as damage, as the text suggests it is, it should be 30 percent of the attack that hit it. That's the definition of retaliation, after all: sending some incoming damage back!
There are lots of things I'd like to change about justis (juggernaut is 100 percent effective, seriously?), but in all honesty, backswing is the one that seems to undermine gameplay by punishing folks for pumping a primary stat.