Hi_Im_Sara wrote:Most of the in-game complaining I still here about p3 of SR being too difficult comes from people running melee builds in that phase despite knowing that he already has an incredibly high physical resist rate. The devs made the decision to focus on magic based builds(likely because they are underutilized by the majority and wanted to present a new challenge) with these 2 new raids and, complain or not, that's just how it is. Knowing that info and still deciding to run melee, and consequentially making things harder on yourself, is your choice. Again, I've ran a SW through P3 of TSR with only a haste elixir and haste pot, before the recent nerf, and didn't find it to be any more overy difficult(keep in mind I have almost no experience running a SW in OS) than using my WM, you just have to be careful and pay attention.
Totally agree with Shekka about the near entry might toons as well...if you're not over 60ish k, you were not meant to be overly successful(granted I don't think they should of been dying after 1 or 2 kills) in p3. Once people had gotten the hang of and understood how the p3 abilities worked, the dying decreased substantially.
P3 of SR is, and was manageable for any toon, in any class at 60k+ to make it through on a semi regular basis without dying and without having to go broke or spend anything on elixirs(haste pots people! Really easy to craft now!), you just have to willing to learn and pay attention to that phase. As it is now, IMHO, P3 has been geared towards too large an audience and lost the majority of its challenging "appeal" most high might, end game toons found with it.
Disclaimer to casual reader: your mileage may indeed vary. That doesn't make the opinions therein less valid.
I run poison just as often and it is easier with it. Everyone ignores the basic issue with SWs in the raid, which is if you can't use DW you're basically at a distinct disadvantage. Without it you will never be as effective as the other classes because you'll get less kills. It's that simple. You're basically plugging away doing far less damage than the other two classes. And haste makes very little difference - crit pots and dodge pots make far more difference for SWs in this raid. It would take a bigger tweak to their physical resists to make things easier, but what's Venan's opposition to this? If they checked with the player base they'd realise most Justicars were spirit now, mages are magic-only of course and a lot of SW players has poison builds already. There was no need to railroad everyone into using 'magic' builds generally because most already were. So if they change phys resist (if they have already there was no noticeable effect), it would go a long way to evening things up.
Let's stop this weird belief that it's unusual for people to die in the phase - it's not. It SHOULD be geared toward a large audience, or the might req should be much higher. Venan don't want a raid where a handful of players think it was 'fine' overall and the rest simply end up abandoning it due to frustration. It's killing players that are changing their builds, that are 'paying attention'. It's very easy to die and not be able to do jack about it in that phase. If that's not the experience of a handful of players, good for you - the raid isn't just yours though. It isn't just for those near 70k might though. The entire community need to be able to enjoy it, and frankly these raids suck compared to PM and LoB. Unfortunately to get the new gems and mats you have to do them. Dying hasn't decreased substantially in the raids I've been in. Still happening.
Melee builds should be equally viable in the raid. I'm currently testing to try and see if there's a workable build that could be used with it, but really what's the point? Melee was used in OS prior to this, Poison in mob phases. PM for example - first two phases use poison, last one melee. It's a well balanced raid that can still kill you if you're not careful. These raids nerf the use of melee completely and decide for us that you must use Nature builds completely. Imagine if it had been the other way around and all Ice or Fire attacks were now useless? I imagine people would be up in arms.
Understand the opposition, but your maxed toon isn't the sole focus of this raid. There are many many other players that also want to enjoy it. Some of those won't have the time or money to work on completely new builds, and that's a shame. Venan showed in the past that they were willing to listen and make tweaks, and that process is not over yet IMO.