Ily, you have a fantastic way of twisting the words I wrote and taking them completely out of context. You also continue to overlook or address the fact that I have run SW through P3 and regardless of what pots are best have noticed little difference in overall difficulty and total round performance. DW is actually viable so long as buffs stay up and you can keep him out of rampage(this is where all that extra haste comes into play).
No one has said that dying was unusual and yes, it has actually decreased substantially since SR first came out and again after the nerf. I've merced with almost every guild that runs SR regularly on their schedule, this isn't coming from just one or 2 guilds. Also, I previously stated that P3, not the whole raid, was originally geared towards high might, end game toons. Why shouldn't it be? Are toons that have either spent lots and lots and lots of time or money not allowed to be challenged anymore because it's not "fair" for the majority. It's supposed to be the hardest phase in the game and if you can't run it, especially as it is now, get rid of all your energy in p1&2 and keep working on getting your toon mighty enough to be successful. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that.
I never disagreed that the nerf to melee builds was OK or warranted but I know that both SW and Justi overwhelmingly ran melee builds in OS prior to the new raids thus my speculation as to why running nature/spirit was "forced" upon us. How exactly is making melee builds more viable for the new raids going to balance things better, when you still have the same fundamental problems you've already described?
WM have no viable melee build so the only fair comparison to make is if he was highly resistive to fire or ice, not both. Would I be initially happy about that, probably not, but at least it presents a new, unique challenge that can be adapted to. Maybe overall output/performance would decrease but at least it would still present as a unique challenge.
Again, no one, including myself, asked for or wanted an entire raid geared towards only the top might toons but there's also nothing wrong with wanting and having a single phase that's geared towards being successful for toons over 60k might.
No one has said that dying was unusual and yes, it has actually decreased substantially since SR first came out and again after the nerf. I've merced with almost every guild that runs SR regularly on their schedule, this isn't coming from just one or 2 guilds. Also, I previously stated that P3, not the whole raid, was originally geared towards high might, end game toons. Why shouldn't it be? Are toons that have either spent lots and lots and lots of time or money not allowed to be challenged anymore because it's not "fair" for the majority. It's supposed to be the hardest phase in the game and if you can't run it, especially as it is now, get rid of all your energy in p1&2 and keep working on getting your toon mighty enough to be successful. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that.
I never disagreed that the nerf to melee builds was OK or warranted but I know that both SW and Justi overwhelmingly ran melee builds in OS prior to the new raids thus my speculation as to why running nature/spirit was "forced" upon us. How exactly is making melee builds more viable for the new raids going to balance things better, when you still have the same fundamental problems you've already described?
WM have no viable melee build so the only fair comparison to make is if he was highly resistive to fire or ice, not both. Would I be initially happy about that, probably not, but at least it presents a new, unique challenge that can be adapted to. Maybe overall output/performance would decrease but at least it would still present as a unique challenge.
Again, no one, including myself, asked for or wanted an entire raid geared towards only the top might toons but there's also nothing wrong with wanting and having a single phase that's geared towards being successful for toons over 60k might.