Illy_the_Red wrote:Hi_Im_Sara wrote:Ily, if a guild took accounts per spot, rather than counting toons individually, would an account be able to be in multiple guilds at once? There are plenty of people who dont want all their toons in the same guild. Also, this could cause a "superguild" issue(not likely with current BoH population, but still a possibility) where you get 30-50 active individuala with 2-5 toons each spread across 2-3 guilds who no longer need mercs for raids. Just trying to ubderstand what you meant exactly by account per guild.
You'd still be able to be in 5 guilds (or 8 when update comes) if you like, it would mean though if you moved your toons into your home guild you would only ever take up one slot. Then this toons in, toons out problem would hopefully go away. It would give the flexibility to have all your toons somewhere to help if need be, or spread yourself about, as it were.
Not needing mercs for raids should be the goal of the game. BoH was much better when it was still possible to gold a raid in-house, now it's just throw the doors open early and hope for the best in most cases. Mercs should be a resource that you go and get if needed, not rely on, like it was pre-Guild Loyalty.
Plus, people are already rotating plenty of toons in and out, sometimes a whole account, to help raids. Then there's those who can jump on other accounts to help out too.
Why bother with guilds at all at that point???????
Jumper wrote:Illy_the_Red wrote:Hi_Im_Sara wrote:Ily, if a guild took accounts per spot, rather than counting toons individually, would an account be able to be in multiple guilds at once? There are plenty of people who dont want all their toons in the same guild. Also, this could cause a "superguild" issue(not likely with current BoH population, but still a possibility) where you get 30-50 active individuala with 2-5 toons each spread across 2-3 guilds who no longer need mercs for raids. Just trying to ubderstand what you meant exactly by account per guild.
You'd still be able to be in 5 guilds (or 8 when update comes) if you like, it would mean though if you moved your toons into your home guild you would only ever take up one slot. Then this toons in, toons out problem would hopefully go away. It would give the flexibility to have all your toons somewhere to help if need be, or spread yourself about, as it were.
Not needing mercs for raids should be the goal of the game. BoH was much better when it was still possible to gold a raid in-house, now it's just throw the doors open early and hope for the best in most cases. Mercs should be a resource that you go and get if needed, not rely on, like it was pre-Guild Loyalty.
Plus, people are already rotating plenty of toons in and out, sometimes a whole account, to help raids. Then there's those who can jump on other accounts to help out too.
Why bother with guilds at all at that point???????
The only real reason to at the minute is that you get bonuses for being in one and you can chat to your mates. The guild concept is pretty ropey with the current state of the game but I don't see it changing any time soon.
Switching to account based rather than toon based slots would just make things easier for people. There are some moving 4-5 toons into guilds just to hit, then taking them out again because of the guild limit.
To me, join-hit-leave guilds are just inflating their membership just to be number one. It's taking advantage of a flaw in the system.
*If* you want to have a realistic competition to see who is the top guild, blah, blah, blah, they should disallow this kind of thing... Or we should just have a one toon per guild rule and have 5 guilds, period... Oops, make that 8 guilds, period, in the middle of June. Then everyone can be in the top 8 guilds and every guild can get the gold every time with no mercs.
Guild communication/coordination with guildmates waiting outside the gates would be tricky, though...
Hey, can we get a user-defined contact list for sending in-game mail instead of just "entire guild"?
Tamspawn wrote:There are many guilds, with smaller numbers of people, with multiple toons. Rotating toons in STINKS. It disturbs the flow of the raid and you end up rotating in with only 42e.
The response, make another guild, doesn't solve it. I want to play with my friends
Maybe try 120, unless your stats show a different number, is better.
Maybe try up to 150 possible members in one guild, with full 50e instead of rotating toons in and out.
Creating a raid schedule for existing toons and new classes won't be easy but as long as toons can stay in guild the can raid and quest with all guild favours.
The only possibility to keep 50e is to have all toons in their home guild.
Remove the energy bonus for guild loyalty and put some other kind of bonus for level 4 and 5. Make a captain valor and champion valor sigil so that everyone can obtain 50e.
This will allow everyone to have their alts obtain max energy without having to regen when joining the guild, be able to rotate toons for raids at max energy, and allow for a maximum number of actual players in a guild as alts can be booted once they're energy is used.
Don't need to increase the maximum. Don't need to make it account specific. The bigest gripe is the loss of energy and need to regen with alts when rotating so let's take the simpler route.
1. Remove the energy perks associated with guild loyalty and put something else in its place.
2. Make a captain and guardian sigil for energy and allow everyone to obtain and stay at max energy.
The question now is what will the level 4 and 5 perks be if venan actually did this for the players?......
Derpy_as_I_wanna_be wrote:To me, join-hit-leave guilds are just inflating their membership just to be number one. It's taking advantage of a flaw in the system.
*If* you want to have a realistic competition to see who is the top guild, blah, blah, blah, they should disallow this kind of thing... Or we should just have a one toon per guild rule and have 5 guilds, period... Oops, make that 8 guilds, period, in the middle of June. Then everyone can be in the top 8 guilds and every guild can get the gold every time with no mercs.
Guild communication/coordination with guildmates waiting outside the gates would be tricky, though...
Hey, can we get a user-defined contact list for sending in-game mail instead of just "entire guild"?
Join-hit-leave is nothing to do with leaderboards IMO. Does anyone even care who is in the top 10 any more? It's more to do with player activity.
Some guilds have alt policies that mean your spare toons don't sit in the guild taking up space all the time, unless activity is lower and there aren't enough active players coming online every day. 100 spaces isn't actually all that many in an active guild...which is why we're talking about it.
NBW cares... According to how some of their players talk to others.
Kicking people at less than a week of inactivity is a bit extreme and I have heard that some do it for X hours of inactivity.
Derpy_as_I_wanna_be wrote:NBW cares... According to how some of their players talk to others.
Kicking people at less than a week of inactivity is a bit extreme and I have heard that some do it for X hours of inactivity.
They boasted that they finished gold once ahead of someone that got silver. In a random raid. It's how it goes I think. At least one guild appears to care...it means nothing to the vast majority.
Kicking people every couple of days or less happens when things are busy and there are loads of actives.
However, as people have noted...
Things are not busy in BoH
