Book of Heroes

Please increase guild size

There are many guilds, with smaller numbers of people, with multiple toons. Rotating toons in STINKS. It disturbs the flow of the raid and you end up rotating in with only 42e.
The response, make another guild, doesn't solve it. I want to play with my friends

Maybe try 120, unless your stats show a different number, is better.
The best reason I can give for this is that with 3 extra toons more space is needed to have all toons in the same guild
Just to play devils advocate here, increasing guild size would almost surely mean an adjustment to all raids to increase waves. It would also be detrimental to game growth and new toon/player success as this would shrink the amt of successful new guilds that are already almost nonexistent and im pretty sure all of us end game players want new end game content. It would also cause even further ingame segregation amongst players that original fuild loyalty implementation already caused. My 2 cents for the othwr aide of the arguement

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jun 2, 2016 8:33 am
Suggested elsewhere but it could be changed so that instead of rotating toons in and out one account equals one space, rather than one toon. That isn't changing the number of players involved as they're already rotating.

Venan increased the raid wave counts originally in 1.6 because they decided everything was too easy, adjusting toon membership to 100 (to make it look like they were helping us out) as part of the deeply unpopular guild loyalty changes. I don't think any of their raid changes were related to how many players were in any guild at the time or overall player numbers in general. They wanted to squash the merc system as it was.

It's clear however that the number of players isn't fluctuating hugely; it's more a downward trend over time that occasionally levels out or briefly recovers. This means basing membership on accounts rather than toons is a good idea as more and more players concentrate their toons in one or two guilds.
We've had guilds for three years plus and there's been one time that a guild has had 100 members on line and that was for the first ever speed run event.
If they increased the amount of members allowed in a guild at one time but decreased the maximum amount allowed in a raid, would that solve both problems? Easier raids and not having to rotate toons.
Ily, if a guild took accounts per spot, rather than counting toons individually, would an account be able to be in multiple guilds at once? There are plenty of people who dont want all their toons in the same guild. Also, this could cause a "superguild" issue(not likely with current BoH population, but still a possibility) where you get 30-50 active individuala with 2-5 toons each spread across 2-3 guilds who no longer need mercs for raids. Just trying to ubderstand what you meant exactly by account per guild.
Rezel wrote:We've had guilds for three years plus and there's been one time that a guild has had 100 members on line and that was for the first ever speed run event.
If they increased the amount of members allowed in a guild at one time but decreased the maximum amount allowed in a raid, would that solve both problems? Easier raids and not having to rotate toons.


Those weren't even people from that guild. They booted people that weren't online to make room for mercs.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jun 2, 2016 11:14 am
Hi_Im_Sara wrote:Ily, if a guild took accounts per spot, rather than counting toons individually, would an account be able to be in multiple guilds at once? There are plenty of people who dont want all their toons in the same guild. Also, this could cause a "superguild" issue(not likely with current BoH population, but still a possibility) where you get 30-50 active individuala with 2-5 toons each spread across 2-3 guilds who no longer need mercs for raids. Just trying to ubderstand what you meant exactly by account per guild.

You'd still be able to be in 5 guilds (or 8 when update comes) if you like, it would mean though if you moved your toons into your home guild you would only ever take up one slot. Then this toons in, toons out problem would hopefully go away. It would give the flexibility to have all your toons somewhere to help if need be, or spread yourself about, as it were.

Not needing mercs for raids should be the goal of the game. BoH was much better when it was still possible to gold a raid in-house, now it's just throw the doors open early and hope for the best in most cases. Mercs should be a resource that you go and get if needed, not rely on, like it was pre-Guild Loyalty.

Plus, people are already rotating plenty of toons in and out, sometimes a whole account, to help raids. Then there's those who can jump on other accounts to help out too.

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Thu Jun 2, 2016 12:47 pm
What if guild loyalty were tied to an account? So every toon for that account would automatically begin with gl 5 or whatever.

I mean, you're not really trying to measure how loyal a cartoon character is to a given guild but rather the player controlling the toon.

Then players could move toons around without penalty as long as the account (e.g. at least one toon) doesn't leave a guild.

...and then limit the number of accounts per guild rather than the number of toons.