Book of Heroes

Mercs, power, and instability · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jun 26, 2016 4:32 pm
Dumknight wrote:My biggest problem with the change... Is that the more raids you run, regardless of guild member contribution the higher ur power will be. Realistically I should split my guildies into two raids and then have 15 Mercs helping in each. That would maximize our ranking.

That is a flawed thing to promote. It will lead to guilds running as many raids as possible for ranking and hoping for Mercs.

To make my point simply.... I'm the GM of a captains valor guild. Should guilds that constantly run KFS as much as possible with 90% merc contribution gain the same amount of power as our guild that runs a closed Vg with no Mercs ? Is that realistically reflecting the "power" and teamwork of a guild ? I don't think so. My 2 cents. It might be different for GV raids, but for mid tier cv and Kv this seems like it's gonna end up with a lot of people starting raids and praying they finish with Mercs. Which will lead to a bad gaming experience for a lot of players and instability.

DumKnight epix

Try and do raids by splitting guildies and hoping the mercs finish them...let us know how that goes.

Captain valour? What might are your lowest toons? Are you multi-tooning or relying already on big hitters in raids like KFS? Don't worry about other guilds. If it's so easy to run KFS, run it. Maybe even move to higher raids, unless the guild in question in one of those that is actually affecting the game, where people camp in their own old guilds (that can't raid at the level of their members due to inactivity) out of sheer stubbornness rather than moving on or merging.
We are a healthy guild thanks :) we primarily run Vg and don't open all the merc slots. I don't really care about rankings. Before we the update we just hit top 15. Now we have dropped, because we don't rely on Mercs and we don't host as many raids as others. That's my point.

Should power ranking reflect how many raids you can host relying on Mercs, or how healthy your guild is and the teamwork. In my opinion the system before this patch was fine. I don't see a reason to change it. But I do see how it could negatively impact the boh community by people praying for Mercs and starting raids they should cause they are rank greedy, or power ranking not reflecting the realistic health of a guild.

DumKnight epix.
One more thing, if the biggest benefit of the old system is rotating ur toons in and out of guild for extra hits during a raid. (Yes I played in 2012 before raid finder) Other Mercs joining guild just to hit and leave ...

This is bypassing the merc limit. This is bypassing the 100 guild limit. It's basically cheating, these limits were in place for a reason. Stability, teamwork and challenging game play.

People guild hopping is detrimental to the community and team work that this game should be encouraging.

DumKnight epix
Illy, give it up, we all know how the game works and guilds run. It's one thing to argue for something but to resort to arguing that something done everyday for years is impossible by some semantic tweaks simply casts doubts on your real motive. Hopefully it's as obvious to Venan as it is to others.
Illy_the_Red wrote:
De_Gallis wrote:Doyle, no disrespect but I would expect you to be thrilled just on the basis of methodology employed in guild. However, for those of us who value community in BOH, that's exactly the effect we are finally speaking up to oppose.

You have been pretty successful under the old system. There was no need to eviscerate it.

Don't diss people without explaining exactly what you mean. Don't tiptoe around what you want to say.

Community in BoH has nothing to do with mercs. The old system is and will continue to be poor, because at the moment the guild concept is dying. I think Venan recognise this and are throwing the game a hand. I'm yet to see a coherent explanation of why exactly this is bad. I'm guessing it will allow some other guild to pass the guilds of those posting above to get above you on the boards. Most people don't care about any guild board, and if the current situation is affecting your board placing then adapt.


I meant no disrespect to Doyle. Simply that I understand his reason for liking the change. It suits his method and he has been very successful. Hardly disrespectful to accept his opinion but point out that it worked without a change.

Your reasoning is much more opaque.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Jun 27, 2016 4:01 am
Laid it out in terms any English speaker should be able to understand. We get that you're not happy about the change but that's too bad. Maybe Venan will change it back, maybe they won't. Adapt to the situation.

Any guild that throws multiple raids open and expects mercs to finish them is going to be very surprised. It doesn't get much clearer than that.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Jun 27, 2016 4:06 am
Dumknight wrote:One more thing, if the biggest benefit of the old system is rotating ur toons in and out of guild for extra hits during a raid. (Yes I played in 2012 before raid finder) Other Mercs joining guild just to hit and leave ...

This is bypassing the merc limit. This is bypassing the 100 guild limit. It's basically cheating, these limits were in place for a reason. Stability, teamwork and challenging game play.

People guild hopping is detrimental to the community and team work that this game should be encouraging.

DumKnight epix

Raid finder didn't exist until very recently.

Success! I knew you'd spill what you're really aching about. Rotating in toons is done across the board in many top guilds when they are very active. Why? Because they have more toons (that's toons, not players) than can fit in a 100-toon guild. If you think that's 'cheating' then you're wrong and also misunderstand why anyone is doing it.

Guild hopping made the community what it was, as anyone who's been around long enough would likely tell you. The current guild system is not only unpopular, it strangled the social aspect of BoH quite a bit.

Again, adapt to the situation. Make it work for you. Without a very active guild you can't do high raids, no matter how loyal the active players are.
Guild and merc space limits exist for a reason. To make the game challenging and to help support the game by using energy potions for GS which help support venan making new content $$.
They can't help it however if someone has 30 toons to bypass the system (no life).
But it's still basically bypassing limits/abusing the system.
If ur saying that no matter what you need to do this to complete high level raids then that is a different problem.

This thread is simply for talking about how merc power counts the same as guildie power. Power ranking previously reflected the amount of guildies contributions and teamwork. Now it reflects the same plus merc contributions. I have seen PM and KFS raids with 90% merc contribution. How is that fair to give this guild the same power ranking as another guild that ran the same with 90% guildie contributions. Simply put, Idc about being first. But this makes power ranking an inaccurate reflection of guild health, and it increases the chances and desire for some gms to post raids and hope Mercs finish them (they have nothing to lose after all).
If you want "guild hoping" it's called mercing. Still get to socialize with other guilds and meet new players and have a community. If u want to bypass the limits of that, ask venan to increase merc slots and guild size. But last time I checked they don't want to. In order To keep the game challenging, competitive, fun and team oriented.

DumKnight epix

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Jun 28, 2016 5:42 pm
Sure. Don't care about boards but say something that is standard practice among guilds with high membership is cheating. It's not, that's all there is to say on it. Adapt to the situation or don't, up to individual guilds.

Derpy_as_I_wanna_be

Wed Jun 29, 2016 8:11 am
Wait... Did they only remove the raid penalty for using mercs or did they also remove the guild loyalty penalty for switching guilds??